3 ms·
Offtopic; just curious if anyone knows. Edit: apparently I wrote some unreadable stuff here :) So simple rewrite: - people accidentally drop liquid (bottle of
by tluyben2 14y ago
Offtopic; just curious if anyone knows.
Edit: apparently I wrote some unreadable stuff here :) So simple rewrite:
- people accidentally drop liquid (bottle of water, coke, coffee, tea) on their macbooks
- people bring the laptop to Apple (or official partners)
- Apple says (rightfully so) that it's not covered by their warranty
- Apple says (in all cases, over 10 i've seen) that the motherboard is gone and needs replacement, which costs E800-E1200 depending on your Macbook
- after repair Apple (partners) refuses to return the broken motherboard to the paying client
Now, i'm saying that in the cases people found it too expensive and didn't have the macbook repaired (by Apple) that the motherboard was not broken at all and fixable within a few hours by themselves or friends (like me).
So my question: why do they refuse to return the old, broken motherboard to someone who owns the macbook and is paying to have it fixed?
- megablast 14y agoI have no idea what you just said. I think you are saying that in water damaged macbooks, you have to pay apple, and apple get to keep the mobo? They probably recycle them safely. Maybe you are suggesting they reuse the parts, but I find that highly unlikely.
- tluyben2 14y agoI'm asking why they refuse to return the broken motherboards; they belong to the people having the laptop repaired.
- Samuel_Michon 14y agoDear Tycho, I'm well versed in English and Dutch, but I have no clue what you're trying to say. As for dropping quantities of liquid on your Mac: don't do it, or at least get yourself some proper computer insurance. Apple's standard warranty doesn't cover accidents, AppleCare doesn't cover them either. If you bring your water damaged computer to an Apple Store (try Amsterdam), they might take pity on you and replace your computer on the spot, but they're in no way obligated to do so.
- tluyben2 14y agoI guess I shouldn't write HN comments and have a meeting at the same time :) Rewrote it; hope it's clearer now. I'm just curious if anyone saw this behavior. An official Apple partner repair shop close to Utrecht actually repaired my macbook which got over drenched because of a cat jumping in a bucket accident :) No questions asked and within the Apple care warranty, but they too refused to return the motherboard upon request.