5 ms·
I'm a bit confused. It is strongly implied that Ivanov cheated by using computer assistance. But I don't understand how he would have done this. He is playing a
by js2 14y ago
I'm a bit confused. It is strongly implied that Ivanov cheated by using computer assistance. But I don't understand how he would have done this. He is playing at the same chessboard as another player, correct? How could he have received assistance unnoticed?
- a3_nm 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheating_in_chess#Cheating_with_technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheating_in_chess#Cheating_wit...
- gort 14y agoSome combination of covert communications and/or trips to the toilet.
- megablast 14y agoRadio receiver in his ear, device in his shoe, audience giving signals, sign writers in the sky, what is there to understand? There are lots of possibilities.
- dmd 14y agoHow I did it: Moves are transmitted by squeezing the right toes (1 to 8 squeezes for rank, long pause, another 1-8 for file). Computer comes up with countermove, which is transmitted by vibration pulses in the same encoding scheme.
- pinko 14y ago"How I did it"... that is begging for a story. Got one?
- dmd 14y agoNot really; I built a thing, I tried fooling some people with it, but the trouble with a system like that is it makes you extremely inflexible. If you make a mistake and get out of sync, you're screwed. And it's really obvious that something is up, because it takes you suspiciously long to make a move even when it's blindingly obvious what to do - because you still have to do the round trip in order to stay in sync.
- kvnn 14y agoWhat was the context of your exploit?
- barredo 14y agoIt says they didn't find anything on him. So if he cheated: 1) it was with a new unknown method/gadget in his body/clothes 2) it was someone from the audience (they switched off the internet broadcasting so anyone outside could not help him any further) 3) the method he used to cheat was destroyed/hidden before the search (eaten, thrown away, etc)
- ghshephard 14y agoSubdermal transmitter using vibrations. Embedded BoneContact Auditory communication. No end of ways to cheat without being detected if all you need is an inbound signal (The games were being broadcast on the internet). It's only a little bit harder if you need to communicate in two direction, but - this is chess - you don't need to communicate much data to send out position updates.
- VMG 14y agoIf such technologies go mainstream, there will be severe consequences for all kinds of fields (TV Quiz Shows, exams, Randi Million Dollar Challenge) Double that if there is two-way communication.
- DanBC2 14y ago"The Newtonian Casino" is about a group of hackers who build shoe-computers to cheat at roulette. It's a fascinating true story. A similar device could easily be built for chess computers. Especially since hardware now is much more powerful, and much smaller, and battery technology (while still being lousy) is much better. What kind of chess computing could you get from, for example, Raspberry Pi? What software would run at reasonable speed on it?
- showerst 14y agoThe really high powered chess engines will take 1-2s or more to calculate even on a high powered multi-core box. The more obvious approach is to compute the moves on a 'real' computer elsewhere and just transmit the result via some tiny hardware in a shoe or something. These games were streamed online, so they only needed communication to be one-way (computer to player).