5 ms·
"...did not warrant the severe punishments authorized by Congress and called for by the Sentencing Guidelines in appropriate cases." Scapegoating Congress now,
by rhizome 14y ago
"...did not warrant the severe punishments authorized by Congress and called for by the Sentencing Guidelines in appropriate cases."
Scapegoating Congress now, she is truly shameless in invoking the Nuremberg Defense.
- thomasz 14y agoCan we please not Godwin this?
- jychang 14y agoStrictly speaking, we haven't Godwin'd this yet.
- jacquesm 14y agoHe's not Godwinning this at all. Claiming superior orders is exactly what the Nuremberg defense was all about, it is simply an accurate association. Just because something happened in relation to WWII does not automatically mean that any reference to it invokes Godwin's law, that's for inappropriate comparisons. This one is entirely appropriate as far as I can see.
- finnw 14y agoIt is not appropriate because Ortiz is not accused of war crimes.
- jacquesm 14y agoIt is actually, because unlikely though the name may seem to you the Nuremberg defense is actually a lot older than WorldWar II and was historically invoked for lots of other things besides war crimes. The fact that during the Nuremberg trials it was used so frequently that it got named because of them does not detract from this. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superior_orders http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superior_orders
- rolux 14y agoSure. But what Ortiz is pulling here is not a Nuremberg Defense ("I was aware of the injustice, but my hands were tied"). She clearly states that she's completely fine with "severe punishment" in "appropriate cases", just that with regards to Aaron, it seemed somewhat inappropriate to her and her office. (I agree that her role, and the role of her office, in Aaron's prosecution suggests the exact opposite, but that's an entirely different question.)
- rhizome 14y agoI agree that her role, and the role of her office, in Aaron's prosecution suggests the exact opposite, but that's an entirely different question. It isn't, though. That she comes out with this attitude afterwards is absolutely self-serving and cannot be relied on as an accurate description of her motivations. The "hey, well, that was just the press release" claptrap should be completely disregarded as a mitigating rationale for the ass-covering bullshit that it is. This leaves us with the "hey, Congress passed these laws, don't look at me," attitude that, as Jacques astutely points out, removes her agency from her actions. The concept and practice of prosecutorial discretion, however, casts the lie to that position. Barthes and Derrida's "death of the author" is not a force in the law, so Ortiz attempting to play The Cog role should be seen as nothing more than sarcasm. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author
- grandpa 14y agoAs an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a debate over what Godwin's law says approaches 1.
- nirvana 14y agoYou seem to be operating under a popular misunderstanding of what Godwin said. Godwin said, merely, that if the discussion goes on long enough, eventually the nazi era will be mentioned. He never said it was always inappropriate to mention it, nor that those who mention it are always wrong, etc. The popularity of "Godwin's Law" (especially this incorrect interpretation) has lead to a lot of people denying that anything in the US (or any online discussion) could be accurately compared to anything that happened in Germany. Which is silly, but just another case of "when america does it, it's different."
- speleding 14y agoIn this case Ortiz "I'm just following orders" warrants a reference to Nuremberg. It's insightful to realise that things can get badly out of hand, even if you follow the letter of the law. Aaron's case proves the point.
- lclarkmichalek 14y agoDoes some other body write laws? It's 100% justified to criticize congress if you actually want to change things; a prosecutor can only prosecute for violations of the law.
- scott_s 14y agoProsecutors routinely use their own discretion in both deciding what to prosecute, and how severe of a sentence they will pursue. To say "Hey, the law is the law, I'm just doing my job by enforcing it" denies this reality, and serves to remove her own agency from her actions.
- res0nat0r 14y agoSix months in a minimum security jail seems perfectly reasonable to me for repeatedly breaking the law and in no way some sort of "overreach" or "witch hunt". Her job was to find a settlement acceptable to both parties.
- scott_s 14y agoHad they gone to trial, however, he was likely facing 7 years, according to another article on the front page: http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aaron-swartz-part-2-prosecutorial-discretion/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-agains...
- res0nat0r 14y agoCorrect. He could have gone to trial, or taken the 6 month plea bargain.
- mpyne 14y agoIn fairness to the prosecution, pushing for the same exact sentence that the defendant refused to accept on a "gracious" plea bargain is poor economic policy. If the plea bargain sentence is really sufficient then there needs to be incentive to take the plea. 7 years is far less than the maximum sentence so she's still correct in saying they didn't push for the maximum (pending other evidence that might come out).
- sp332 14y agoHuh? She's talking about the fact that people claim her office was dangling 35 or even 50 years in jail over Aaron's head. But her office had extended a deal to Aaron which would involve only 6 month's jail time. They had even been open to one that involved no jail time, and JSTOR agreed but MIT did not. (Not that MIT can just tell the DA what to do, but if the DA presents a deal to the judge, and MIT doesn't back them up, that's more likely to be amended by the judge.)