3 ms·
The troubling attitude in TR advocacy is the claims of inherent safety. A sustainable energy-positive reaction can't be inherently safe. You can argue if it ha
by varjag 14y ago
The troubling attitude in TR advocacy is the claims of inherent safety.
A sustainable energy-positive reaction can't be inherently safe. You can argue if it has better failure modes than the alternatives but it's harmful to ignore a multitude of factors which could be not yet considered.
The previous catastrophic failures with other reactor designs were also not exactly forethought. For instance, xenon poisoning was little studied in the beginning of nuclear era. It is not implausible some critical piece of knowledge is missing in the current evaluation of "safe" designs.
Another thing is too much reliance on the neat presentations. E.g. this blog refers to a freeze plug as a kind of panacea of any mismanagement. What if freeze plug fails for whatever reason? Like, tectonic activity breaks the pipework, or it's sabotaged, or groundwater leaks into the dump tanks?