3 ms·
I don't see him as inconsistent. I just think that he didn't state his full position in a single place. My understanding is that his full position follows fro
by btilly 14y ago
I don't see him as inconsistent. I just think that he didn't state his full position in a single place.
My understanding is that his full position follows from two principles:
1. The only point of punishing Aaron is to deter him, so there is no reason to punish him more than what would deter him.
2. There is a reasonable limit to what is a fair punishment for Aaron's actions, by no means should Aaron be punished more than that.
The result is that the appropriate punishment is the minimum of the two. Given that Aaron could have been deterred by punishment that is far less than #2 provides, the limiting consideration in his case is #1. But even for a much more difficult to deter person, by no means is decades acceptable for #2.
- pdonis 14y agoYou missed a principle: 3. The punishment must be enough to deter him--more precisely, to ensure that he switches from illegal to legal means for achieving his goals. The whole point is that #3 might well be incompatible with #1 and #2, if Aaron was sufficiently committed to his goals and legal means did not offer enough of a possibility of achieving them (which is what appeared to be the case). Obviously if you leave out #3 there's no problem; but Kerr specifically included #3 and talked like he thought it was important.
- btilly 14y agoI did not miss that. The #3 that you discuss follows as a logical consequence of #1 and #2 if #2 exceeds #1. Which it did in this case. But the statement that #1 should be the principle under which Aaron should be sentenced does NOT logically imply that it is in all cases that right applicable principle.
- pdonis 14y agoHuh? Either I'm missing something or your logic is in error. To briefly restate: let P = the amount of punishment imposed; let D = the minimum amount of punishment sufficient to deter; let R = the "reasonable limit" on the amount of punishment. #1 says: not P > D. #2 says: P <= R. #3 says: P >= D. There are no logical implications between any pair of the above. #1 and #3 combined force P = D. But that is incompatible with #2 if D > R. To put it back into English: if the only amount of punishment that will deter is greater than the "reasonable limit", there is no way to satisfy all the principles.
- btilly 14y ago#1 actually is The only point of punishing Aaron is to deter him which means both that there is no point in punishing Aaron beyond the level of deterrence, and that as long as increased punishment increases deterrence, there is a point in increasing punishment. The point being that deterrence is not a binary yes/no. Even if tossing Aaron in jail will not stop him, tossing him in jail for 6 years delays his next offense more than tossing him in jail for 5 years, so that would be an argument for increased punishment. Therefore #1 as I meant it is both an argument for an absolute upper limit on punishment, AND an argument for as much punishment as possible as long as you are within that limit. Therefore if #2 limits punishment below the absolute maximum from #1, you can still satisfy all of the principles at once.
- pdonis 14y agodeterrence is not a binary yes/no That's true, but it doesn't change the argument. Just change D to the minimum punishment that will provide an acceptable level of deterrence. The same logic goes through. (Technically, yes, you now can allow P >= D instead of forcing P = D, but that doesn't matter if D > R.) Therefore if #2 limits punishment below the absolute maximum from #1, you can still satisfy all of the principles at once. Not if #2 limits punishment below the minimum that will provide a acceptable level of deterrence. See above.
- btilly 14y agoWhere are you pulling your notion of "an acceptable level of deterrence" from? If your willingness to persevere exceeds the willingness of society to punish you, then at some point society will be pushed to think hard about the issue. That's the whole point of civil disobedience. But those conversations need to happen in the realm of politics - not the courts. In short, the courts should not try to preemptively block all possibility of civil disobedience by subjecting people a sufficient pain point to prevent it happening. Judges need to stay within the limits set by maximum sentences and sentencing guidelines, even if the judges believe that this punishment is not enough to deter the unwelcome action.