20 ms·
The Criminal Charges Against Aaron Swartz – Part 2: Prosecutorial Discretion
- gadders 14y agoOne question that occurs to me - does a felony conviction prevent you from taking political office in the US? Given Aaron's activism, might that be a reason why that was a sticking point?
- pdonis 14y agoInteresting follow-up by Orin Kerr. Brief summary of his summary: [quote] I’m going to break down the question into four different issues: First, was any criminal punishment appropriate in the case? Second, if so, how much criminal punishment was appropriate? Third, who is to blame if the punishment was excessive and the government’s tactics were overzealous? And fourth, does the Swartz case show the need to amend the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, and if so, how? On the first question, I think that some kind of criminal punishment was appropriate in this case. On the second question...here’s the key question: What punishment was the minimum necessary to deter Swartz from continuing to try to use unlawful means to achieve his reform goals? I don’t think I know the answer to that question, but that’s the question I would answer to determine the proper level of punishment. On the third question...I think it’s important to realize that what happened in the Swartz case happens it lots and lots of federal criminal cases...If you want to end these tactics, don’t just complain about the Swartz case. Don’t just complain when the defendant happens to be a brilliant guy who went to Stanford and hangs out with Larry Lessig. Instead, complain that this is business as usual in federal criminal cases around the country — mostly with defendants who no one has ever heard of and who get locked up for years without anyone else much caring. On the fourth issue, yes, the Swartz case does point to a serious problem with the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. But that problem is not the definition of “unauthorized access,” as some people seem to believe...Rather, the problem raised by the Swartz case is one I’ve been fighting for years: Felony liability under the statute is triggered much too easily. [/quote]
- gnosis 14y ago"What punishment was the minimum necessary to deter Swartz from continuing to try to use unlawful means to achieve his reform goals?" Let's say no punishment would deter Swartz. Would that justify a sentence of life in prison?
- pdonis 14y agoKerr says later on: "decades in jail would have been extreme overkill". So apparently he was willing to at least set some limits without even knowing the answer to his question. A little earlier he says: "I’ll defer here to the people who knew Swartz best, with whatever they think the right answer is. Would probation have been enough? A month of home confinement? Jail time?" Which also sets some bounds on what he thought was reasonable. So I don't know if Kerr really meant for his question to be taken at face value. OTOH, he does seem to consider it important that the punishment be sufficient to cause the person to switch from illegal to legal means for achieving his goals. So he doesn't seem fully consistent on this point.
- btilly 14y agoI don't see him as inconsistent. I just think that he didn't state his full position in a single place. My understanding is that his full position follows from two principles: 1. The only point of punishing Aaron is to deter him, so there is no reason to punish him more than what would deter him. 2. There is a reasonable limit to what is a fair punishment for Aaron's actions, by no means should Aaron be punished more than that. The result is that the appropriate punishment is the minimum of the two. Given that Aaron could have been deterred by punishment that is far less than #2 provides, the limiting consideration in his case is #1. But even for a much more difficult to deter person, by no means is decades acceptable for #2.
- pdonis 14y agoYou missed a principle: 3. The punishment must be enough to deter him--more precisely, to ensure that he switches from illegal to legal means for achieving his goals. The whole point is that #3 might well be incompatible with #1 and #2, if Aaron was sufficiently committed to his goals and legal means did not offer enough of a possibility of achieving them (which is what appeared to be the case). Obviously if you leave out #3 there's no problem; but Kerr specifically included #3 and talked like he thought it was important.
- fatbird 14y agoKerr does a good job reminding readers that what happened to Swartz was absolutely standard for federal prosecutors, and the outrage is triggered largely because he has a powerful constituency looking for redress on his suicide. The important takeaway from this, though, isn't about the injustice that happened to Swartz as much as the ongoing injustice of a system of federal prosecution that does this to many, many more defendants who are far less powerful and connected than Swartz.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI think a lot (most?) people understand that. Aaron is the rallying cry to spark action. Ortiz is an initial heading to point that action. And while I hope Ortiz does pay (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5071218 for hope it might be), I hope even more that it doesn't stop there. The value in Ortiz "paying" is to show other prosecutors what can happen when they get over zealous. There is only value in that if it is continually monitored and other prosecutors are "punished" when they do the same. To that end, it would be nice to have a way to monitor that activity, because it is nigh impossible to change what you can't measure, if the problems are systemic enough (as I believe this one is).
- andylei 14y ago> The value in Ortiz "paying" is to show other prosecutors what can happen when they get over zealous what i got from the article is that Ortiz was not overzealous. she was doing what most prosecutors do all the time. why should we single her out? if we wanted to fire all prosecutors that used her tactics, we'd probably have to fire the majority of federal prosecutors.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoWithout involving Ortiz, what could we do that would get as much press as this has gotten? If the media has no interest, your cause is going nowhere, and the media won't be interested without names and faces to talk about. Besides, it is completely logical to believe she was overzealous and every other prosecutor is doing it. Just because everybody else is speeding, too, doesn't mean I won't get the ticket. Ortiz happens to be the one who got pulled over. (FWIW, I'd much prefer we not have to drag her or, really, anyone down. She is a real person with feelings and passions, and is, as you mention, acting within SOP for her position. I just don't see a way to start affecting change across the country without going through her [I'm not convinced the change can happen even doing that, but we need to try.]. I'm open to alternatives that can realistically gain momentum.)
- tptacek 14y agoInterestingly, Kerr is apparently expecting to assist Aurenheimer at his appeal for similar convictions under CFAA this year.
- temphn 14y agoSwartz had something else in mind it seems; just taking the law into his own hands I think this is really one of the core reasons so many hackers disagree with this lawyer mindset. A hacker or an entrepreneur is someone who breaks rules to create something. Innovation and consensus are antonyms, not synonyms. Innovation does not happen by committee. If you wait for a "democratic process" that is bought and rigged by the copyright maximalists, you will wait forever. The bold actions of individuals are the only way anything has ever changed for the better. As for the fetishization of "democracy" in Kerr's post, sometimes elections produce good outcomes. But often the wisdom of crowds isn't so wise; I'd hate to have the value of the gravitational constant or the next CEO of Google determined by public plebiscite. And many times, perhaps most times, the crowd votes after someone bold has already moved and shown the way. That's what Swartz was doing. What is legal and what is moral are not the same thing, and all those who argue "it's bad, but it was the law" are the moral inverses of Swartz: "it's good even if it's not the law".
- rayiner 14y agoI think there is a strong grain of truth to what you say. My politics are fairly lawyerly,[1] and I find the anti-democratic sentiment on here disquieting, especially the constant attempts to discredit the democratic process at every turn by unsubstantiated hand waving about how the system is "bought." [1] I think the chicken came before the egg. The profession attracts people who have a strong sense of order and continuity, it doesn't make them that way. Though I think it's incorrect to juxtapose "innovation" so starkly with a love of order. "Cowboy engineering" isn't universal even among technical people. Lots of wonderful things are pyramids--created by armies of order-loving engineers. 787's aren't built by rule breakers.
- temphn 14y agoI am happy we can isolate a point of upstream difference here, as many times people argue about downstream things unproductively. Regarding "cowboy engineering", granted. I would argue that respect for engineering practices/stability comes after that blistering innovation that builds the system in the first place. And in some cases at least, many lawyers seem to endorse anti-democratic measures (e.g. having federal prosecutors immune from election, or having the federal government enforce civil rights measures that were vastly unpopular in the states of enforcement). So it is more complex than pro/anti-democratic on the lawyer side too. But ultimately even more than "democracy", it may just be whether you explicitly believe the ends justify the means. If your bold stratagem ends in failure, then even more scrutiny is placed on your extralegal or envelope-pushing means (see Napster). If it ends in success, you often have much more popularity/influence than you did before and the envelope-pushing is forgotten or romanticized (see Jobs' early phone-phreaking, or Youtube). So whether or not people verbally agree that the ends justify the means, they usually practically agree, in that one or more of their heros was a nonconformist who did change the system. Indeed, often the kind of hero responsible for creating the legal system that they're implementing. The guys on the dollar bills, like Washington and Lincoln, led a revolution and suspended habeas corpus respectively; they did what it took to win, and let history be the judge of whether it was right. So from this vantage point, those who simply execute the law without concern for higher morality are respecting the hackers/revolutionaries of times gone by (because they won) while blocking those of the present day (because they haven't won...yet).
- bcoates 14y agoThe one objection I have to Kerr's otherwise excellent article is that he entirely ignores the policy aspect of Prosecutorial discretion. Lots of people openly violate federal criminal laws. An enormous number of them, like Swartz in this case, do so non-openly but in a way that a trivial amount of investigative effort would reveal. The vast majority of them are not charged. This selective prosecution is a de facto policymaking process. It's not enough that the prosecution not be an abuse of discretion, it needs to also be good policy. Saying that the law needs to be amended to stop enforcement might be the technically proper thing to do but it's not the only option open to opponents of the law.
- mpyne 14y agoNo offense but it's hard to call this "selective". If Aaron had simply given up during one of the first few roadblocks put up that would have been the end of it. No calls to the police, no charges, no nothing. MIT didn't even know it was Swartz until he stupidly re-entered the network closet for the second (or third?) time and finally got caught by the police that MIT had to make special arrangement to have standing by. If you make yourself the object of a inter-agency sting operation then it's a pretty fair bet that there might just be charges coming en route when you get caught.
- btilly 14y agoI think it will take me a day or two to properly digest this article. That is a good thing. Here are a few gut responses in semi-random order. 1. I absolutely agree that the whole process of plea bargains, threats, etc is unethical, immoral, etc. And we should object to it in all cases, not just when it happens to someone like Aaron Swartz. 2. I absolutely disagree that Aaron's actions would seriously threaten the revenues for journals. Once a journal has been delivered, it has been paid for. Retroactive access to past journals does not lessen the desire for libraries to proactively gain access to future ones. The fact that journals are willing to let articles onto JSTOR where they are often available for a nominal (and in many cases a nonexistent) fee says very clearly that the marginal value that Aaron would have taken would be miniscule. 3. I strongly disagree that the process by which the USA acquires more laws at this point can be fairly described as "democratic". There is a minimum facade of democratic input, and in rare cases (eg SOPA) this can redirect the system. But on the whole the system is not democratic, and describing it as such tends to give people a false sense of complacency. 4. That said, I agree with the general principle under which Orrin would have recommended sentencing. But I emphatically disagree with the specific conclusions there. We have ample evidence from, for instance, the ease with which JSTOR got Aaron to back down and return materials before the prosecutors arrived that he actually could be deterred. There was every reason to believe that he found jail to be a very threatening prospect, and the plea bargain suggested by his lawyer would have, in fact, deterred him from future action. Given that, there was no need to seek large punishment. 5. The specific suggestions on reforming the CFAA seem very good to me. If we're optimistic that the Supreme Court will set precedent interpreting the CFAA in a very good way, then we don't want Congress muddying the waters with a provision that can confuse future courts about whether they should follow the reasoning in precedent or guess at the intent of worse recent statutory law. The ease of elevating crimes to a felony strikes me as a very clear problem. I could go on, but as I say it will take me some time to digest this article.
- newman314 14y agoI'm a big fan of understanding motivations. Prosecutors try to go hard on people so that they "look tough". Think about how disgusting it is to build your career on how many wins you have and fuck the collateral damage (pardon my French) which in this case was Aaron. Until prosecutors are not motivated to act this way, we will continue to see excessive behavior from them.
- rhizome 14y agoIt seems reasonable under Kerr's standards and interpretation that action against USA Ortiz, MIT Pres. Reif, and AUSA Heymann, special deterrence can be used to take their jobs, disbar them, or otherwise affect their career prospects in their current disciplines. The problem with legalistic interpretations is that they presume validity of the current laws as they stand, and that any change amounts only to a chipping away at overreach. Frankly, I'd prefer a repeal of the CFAA until they can get it right, citizens are not well-served when authoritarian lawmakers ask for twice what they'll settle for and receive 150%.
- pseingatl 14y agoProfessor Kerr says we should forgive the prosecutors because “they all do it.” This is hardly appropriate and a slur on the many professional federal and state prosecutors who do not engage in these kind of tactics. The fact of the matter is that in the United States a trial over a supermarket slip and fall is more fair than a federal criminal trial. Federal trials are trials by ambush. A defense lawyer has no opportunity to depose the witnesses against his client and usually only learns of their identities after the jury is empanelled. There is no way to determine if the witness has lied in the past or has reason to tailor his testimony to the prosecution’s case. The war on defense attorneys in the 1980’s was successful. Now almost all federal defense attorneys are underfunded public defenders or panel attorneys. The prosecutor has the resources not only of his own office, but of investigative agencies as well. Panel attorneys have no one and not only that, often have to finance the defense out of their own personal funds. It is a pleasure to try a case against a federal prosecutor who is fair and does not game the system. Based on the comments from Swartz’ defense attorneys, that was not the situation in Ortiz’ office.
- pdonis 14y agoHe didn't say we should forgive the prosecutors. He said we should understand that the way the prosecutors handled this case was not an isolated incident. Maybe there are plenty of prosecutors that don't act this way, but there are also plenty that do.
- jeswin 14y agoIt doesn't say whether they are seeking 35 years. But this is from their website: If convicted on these charges, SWARTZ faces up to 35 years in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release, restitution, forfeiture and a fine of up to $1 million. http://www.justice.gov/usao/ma/news/2011/July/SwartzAaronPR.html http://www.justice.gov/usao/ma/news/2011/July/SwartzAaronPR....
- rsingel 14y agoOrin is a good prosecutor (though retired). But let me drop two fine pieces of evidence to refute his statement that Aaron was going to put all of JSTOR into the public domain based on a manifesto. 1) Aaron's previous escapade was making PACER file available through huge downloads. Those files were all non-copyrightable and have become the basis of awesome open-source systems including RECAP and Justia. 2) Aaron had also downloaded some 400,000 Westlaw legal articles and then analyzed them to figure out which were sponsored. The resulting study was published in the Stanford Law Review in 2008. http://www.stanfordlawreview.org/sites/default/files/articles/BardayPD.pdf http://www.stanfordlawreview.org/sites/default/files/article... A very large percentage of the files Aaron downloaded were out of copyright. Other than a manifesto, what proof did the prosecutors put forward that Aaron was going to publish in-copyright material? Furthermore, without any evidence, Kerr says Aaron broke into the networking closet. It had no lock and no sign saying no entry. But Kerr's clearly in prosecutorial mode. I much preferred his mindset when he was fighting the feds abuse of the CFAA in the Lori Drew case.
- tptacek 14y agoThe docket suggests that 300,000 of those files were out of copyright. He downloaded over 4 million, didn't he? The prosecution did in fact offer evidence that Aaron knew he was trespassing. The closet didn't have a sign, but the building had many.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoI think it’s important to realize that what happened in the Swartz case happens it lots and lots of federal criminal cases. Yes, the prosecutors tried to force a plea deal by scaring the defendant with arguments that he would be locked away for a long time if he was convicted at trial. Yes, the prosecutors filed a superseding indictment designed to scare Swartz evem more in to pleading guilty (it actually had no effect on the likely sentence, but it’s a powerful scare tactic). Yes, the prosecutors insisted on jail time and a felony conviction as part of a plea. But federal prosecutors use those tactics all the time. That doesn't make it right.
- mtgx 14y agoYeah, definitely agree there. Just because "everyone does it" doesn't make it an excuse. Living in a country where bribing is pretty common, that's what you here all the time about it, too - that everyone does it.
- pfortuny 14y agoEverybody knows financial engineers at investment banks use cocaine on a daily basis. Should you use it if you want to become one?
- belorn 14y ago>When someone engages in civil disobedience and intentionally violates a criminal law to achieve such an anti-democratic policy goal through unlawful means — and when there are indications in both words and deeds that he will continue to do so I thought Swartz signed a deal with JSTOR that said that he was to never again going to download more articles. What indications existed then that he was going to continue with the specific crime he was charged with? The Manifesto, while provocative, is generic in form and should not override a more specific document stating a clear purpose of not continue with the violation of this law in this case.
- bambax 14y ago> If we don’t want a world in which prosecutors have these powers, we shouldn’t just object when the defendant in the crosshairs is a genius who went to Stanford, hangs out with Larry Lessig, and is represented by the extremely expensive lawyers at Keker & Van Nest. We should object just as much — or even more — when the defendant is poor, unknown, and unconnected to the powerful. To do otherwise sends an extremely troubling message to prosecutors that they need to be extra sensitive when considering charges against defendants with connections. This is exactly what bothers me with this whole affair. 4 million people are behind bars in the US and no one cares; most of those people have committed "crimes" with no victims but themselves (if even that)... and no one cares. And suddenly the same prosecutorial tactics are used on one of us (one of us hackers, not one of us geniuses, obviously) and ends in tragedy, and we ask for the removal of the prosecutor. This one prosecutor is not the problem; the US criminal system is the problem.
- gknoy 14y agoFrankly, I do care that many people are jailed in a degree which I consider excessive - and I imagine most of us here do as well. We just haven't had a concrete rallying point until now.
- mpyne 14y agoYes we did. We had one when Aaron Swartz was still alive but on charges. The consensus was pretty much that he'd finally actually done something legitmately illegal, so if people here really were that worried about felony this vs. misdeameanor that, or the legal process in general, then they'd had plenty of time to do something about it.
- sjreese 14y agoThe point Information is power. But like all power, there are those who want to keep it for themselves. The world’s entire scientific and cultural heritage, published over centuries in books and journals, is increasingly being digitized and locked up by a handful of private corporations. Want to read the papers featuring the most famous results of the sciences? You’ll need to send enormous amounts to publishers like Reed Elsevier.. There are those struggling to change this. The Open Access Movement has fought valiantly to ensure that scientists do not sign their copyrights away but instead ensure their work is published on the Internet, under terms that allow anyone to access it. But even under the best scenarios, their work will only apply to things published in the future. Everything up until now will have been lost. That is too high a price to pay. Forcing academics to pay money to read the work of their colleagues? Scanning entire libraries but only allowing the folks at Google to read them? Providing scientific articles to those at elite universities in the First World, but not to children in the Global South? It’s outrageous and unacceptable. “I agree,” many say, “but what can we do? The companies hold the copyrights, they make enormous amounts of money by charging for access, and it’s perfectly legal —there’s nothing we can do to stop them.” But there is something we can, something that’s already being done: we can fight back. Those with access to these resources — students, librarians, scientists — you have been given a privilege. You get to feed at this banquet of knowledge while the rest of the world is locked out. But you need not —indeed, morally, you cannot — keep this privilege for yourselves. You have a duty to share it with the world. And you have: trading passwords with colleagues, filling download requests for friends. Meanwhile, those who have been locked out are not standing idly by. You have been sneaking through holes and climbing over fences, liberating the information locked up by the publishers and sharing them with your friends. But all of this action goes on in the dark, hidden underground. It’s called stealing or piracy, as if sharing a wealth of knowledge were the moral equivalent of plundering a ship and murdering its crew. But sharing isn’t immoral — it’s a moral imperative. Only those blinded by greed would refuse to let a friend make a copy. Large corporations, of course, are blinded by greed. The laws under which they operate require it — their shareholders would revolt at anything less. And the politicians they have bought off back them, passing laws giving them the exclusive power to decide who can make copies. There is no justice in following unjust laws. It’s time to come into the light and, in the grand tradition of civil disobedience, declare our opposition to this private theft of public culture. We need to take information, wherever it is stored, make our copies and share them with the world. We need to take stuff that's out of copyright and add it to the archive. We need to buy secret databases and put them on the Web. We need to download scientific journals and upload them to file sharing networks. We need to fight for Guerilla Open Access. With enough of us, around the world, we’ll not just send a strong message opposing the privatization of knowledge —we’ll make it a thing of the past. Will you join us?
- jacquesm 14y agoI love this George Bernard Shaw quote: "The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man." Orin Kerr strikes me as a very reasonable man. There are lots of reasonable men. They're all going to stand around and argue about how many legal angels can dance on how many pins. Meanwhile, unreasonable men are plotting on how to make progress. Aaron Swartz struck me as a particularly unreasonable man. He made lots of progress until he ran into these artificial roadblocks. Laws are there to benefit society, not as a brake on progress or as a way to protect outdated business models against the greater common good, especially when it comes to such things as access to knowledge.
- karma_fountain 14y agoOrin did suggest quite a few ways in which the law could be changed to become more reasonable.
- vph 14y agoThe quote has lots of zing to it, but it ain't true. What it says essentially is that progress is an outcome of revolution. While revolution leads to big changes, progress is a product of evolution. And evolution has to be done in "reasonable" ways by "reasonable" man. To say that "all progress depends on the unreasonable man" is wrong.
- subsystem 14y ago"I think that some kind of criminal punishment was appropriate in this case. Swartz had announced his commitment to violating the law as a moral imperative in order to effectively nullify existing federal laws on access to information." This seems to be the going mistake. I can understand if someone has the opinion that the case should be tried in court or even that the charges were correct. But stating that someone should be punished based on their previous statements is dangerously close to political repression.
- gadders 14y agoIt's refreshing to read an article on the case that from a disinterested expert on the law, rather than the two sides in the case. Well worth a read.
- cgio 14y agoI am especially concerned about the author's logic /q When the police catch someone in the course of criminal conduct and intervene mid-way, the punishment is properly based on what the person was in the course of doing rather than how much he succeeded before he was caught. Let's say I issue a manifesto where I support free food for all. Would me picking up things in a store mean that I wanted to steal them or give them for free? The association between the man's principles and his assumed purposes is in direct contrast with the other author's argument on fighting lawfully. Even if he downloaded one article he could share it. Should he not be allowed access to information just because he was fighting for freedom of information? Do laws now impose principles and beliefs? Or does a principle render us in self-imposed seclusion until the relevant laws change? Highly problematic and indicative of how prosecutors argue the cases. And this man is considered an expert?
- czr80 14y agoHe just means that if you picked up food and walked out without paying it wouldn't matter if you were caught in the parking lot while trying to escape(and so could return the food immediately) or caught two weeks later at home, long after the food has been eaten.
- Tloewald 14y agoThe article is excellent. "Finally, I think the instinct to blame the prosecutors in this case should be checked because it is fueled in significant part by a human but improper motive: Making sense of Swartz’s suicide. When a young person commits suicide, there is a natural instinct to restore a sense of order to the world by finding someone to blame. We deal with the sense of shocking and unimaginable and senseless loss by pinning the blame on someone to create a tidy narrative of wrongful actor and wrongful act." You can disagree with copyright law, mourn Aaron Schwarz, and yet not blame prosecutors for Aaron's suicide and have a sense of proportion.
- gavinlynch 14y ago"I think this is really one of the core reasons so many hackers disagree with this lawyer mindset. A hacker or an entrepreneur is someone who breaks rules to create something. Innovation and consensus are antonyms, not synonyms. Innovation does not happen by committee." Honest question, curious about response: I get your general point about "breaking rules", but do you think it needs to be taken literally to the point of breaking laws? Is that an imperative call to action for all modern hackers? And furthermore, would you recommend Aaron take this action again, if given the choice? Would you recommend we all take similar actions?
- ep103 14y agoYes to all of the above questions. As to the specific one about breaking rules vs laws, a moral or patriotic individual has a civic duty, in a democratic society, to disregard or oppose rules and laws which they believe to be immoral or wrong. Hackers, of all people, should know this.
- mpyne 14y ago> a moral or patriotic individual has a civic duty, in a democratic society, to disregard or oppose rules and laws which they believe to be immoral or wrong No offense but if you believe that only thing binding on people is moral imperatives, then you don't believe in a democratic society, you believe in something closer to an anarchical one. The whole point to a democratic society is that the people set the rules, but there are still rules. You're talking about something else.