3 ms·
> The market is highly adversarial, and if anyone were "keeping it down" artificially, they would have their lunch eaten by those looking for value. Yes, which
by snowwrestler 14y ago
> The market is highly adversarial, and if anyone were "keeping it down" artificially, they would have their lunch eaten by those looking for value.
Yes, which is why it's hovering around $500 instead of $0.
But the real question is why competing companies have P/E ratios despite demonstrably worse prospects--Microsoft, for example, has a P/E of almost 15 despite far worse prospects in mobile, lower profits, and a smaller cash reserve. Explain that.
Even a back-of-the-envelope look at AAPL's business shows there is something weird going on with the stock.
- corresation 14y agoBut the real question is why competing companies have P/E ratios despite demonstrably worse prospects Apple and Microsoft's P/E ratio aren't that far off each other. The latter, however, pays a dividend (the two ways to make money off an equity are appreciation and dividends). Further, and saying this with the understanding the P/E is more general guidance than science, Microsoft's products are structural, and despite an endless stream of disasters Microsoft can still pull in the relatively mammoth profits. Apple, on the other hand, exists almost entirely on the backs of the iPhone and the iPad, neither of which have much structural fixedness at all. If the iPhone 6 is a dud for any reason, or the supply lines of either of those face any issues...boom, Apple's profits evaporate. There is dramatically more risk factored into Apple's profits.
- parasubvert 14y agoUm, Apple also pays a dividend - 10x more than Microsoft actually, at $2.65 quarterly vs $0.23. Further more, Apple's P/E of 11.4 vs microsoft's near-15 is a pretty big difference. Not Amazon big, at 3872x! But among the tech sector, it barely covers Apple's incoming 5 year cash flow in a zero-growth scenario. Supply lines for Apple are the same supply lines for other manufacturers, so that's not it. As for "the next phone being a flop and boom, dead", that concept seems rather far fetched, no? A slow meltdown in favour of Android or others is much more likely than any one model somehow being magically disastrous. How often has this ever happened in consumer electronics?
- corresation 14y agoUm, Apple also pays a dividend - 10x more than Microsoft actually, at $2.65 quarterly vs $0.23. Whoa, totally didn't see the news that they had caved to pressure and gone the dividend route. It isn't actually 10x, however, as AAPL has approximately 1/10th the shares issues. Their dividends are very similar. Regarding the P/E ratio, it isn't so big. Just a few months ago AAPL had a similar 15x P/E ratio. that concept seems rather far fetched, no Ask RIM. They owned the market, and one year everyone was talking about how much cash they had in reserves, and the next they were on life support. Apple has even less of a lock-in than RIM (enterprise blackberry messenger being how RIM hung in for a little while), though they've been trying to make their own platforms (Me, Facetime, Airplay, etc). If the next version simply isn't a compelling enough upgrade for existing users, Apple will see very rapidly declining fortunes.
- snowwrestler 14y ago> Just a few months ago AAPL had a similar 15x P/E ratio. Exactly, and what has substantially changed in their business since then? Nothing, which is why the depression in the share price is weird/suspicious.
- corresation 14y agoThere is nothing at all suspicious about what has changed. Skepticism has grown to the point where it is now actually somewhat believable. Six months ago a story about collapsing orders would have been laughed away, whereas now it gets a serious reading because it seems actually possible. Share prices are a speculation about the future, and Apple's heights have an inherent growing risk factor with them.
- snowwrestler 14y agoI assume you're talking about the Nikkei and WSJ stories, but those came after the share price was already down to about $520. To the extent those explain the slide, they can only explain a very small, late portion of it. With all due respect, it seems like you have a mental narrative about Apple and you're just going to stick to it without regard to the details of this specific situation. You didn't even know the stock pays a dividend. We'll just have to wait and see what the earnings report looks like. If it is satisfactory or good, as I expect, then I think it's likely the stock will be back over $600 within a couple months, and likely even higher by the summer.