7 ms·
At the very least I hope they at least define it in terms of things that actually matter, not cosmetics. Most of the criticism I hear about "assault weapon" ba
by jlgreco 14y ago
At the very least I hope they at least define it in terms of things that actually matter, not cosmetics.
Most of the criticism I hear about "assault weapon" bans, aside from the standard criticism of gun laws in general, are that the things used to define "assault weapon" are largely irrelevant to functionality and that the definition amounts to "guns that look frightening".
It seems to me this is a valid criticism that should be taken seriously by both sides of the aisle.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoOne of the conditions in the original ban was being able to attach a bayonet. Which just seems ridiculous. So you have an otherwise legal rifle... but holy crap you mounted a knife on it... bad bad bad. WTF?
- MartinCron 14y agoHere's an illustration I saw in my local newspaper. Other than the collapsible stock (which makes the weapon easier to conceal) and the (separately regulated) high capacity magazine, pretty much everything is purely cosmetic. http://seattletimes.com/ABPub/2013/01/08/2020087609.jpg http://seattletimes.com/ABPub/2013/01/08/2020087609.jpg
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoExactly. And even the collapsible stock is partially cosmetic and partially functional... but only for ease of use. It does nothing to make that weapon any more deadly than any other.
- MartinCron 14y agoI can kind of see the collapsible stock as a functional thing, as it makes a rifle (more powerful and accurate than a handgun) easier to carry in a concealed way, but if that's the case, you could regulate collapsible stocks separately, as well.
- jlgreco 14y agoSeems like a better rule than "has a collapsible stock" would just be "is shorter than [whatever a reasonable length is]", since the problem is less what the stock can and cannot do, and more how long or short the gun can be.
- hga 14y agoImportant detail: the collapsible stock cannot make an AR-15 pattern rifle "short" beyond a very small amount because the recoil spring is inside it. It's mostly to allow issuing one variety of weapon that will fit anybody, and fit when wearing serious body armor or not.
- MartinCron 14y agoDid not know that. Thanks for pointing that out. I seem to remember this as a design feature of other weapons, but I am not an expert.
- hga 14y agoIt's all part of AR-10/15 design, which has one very big issue, gas is injected directly into the receiver (not where you want cruft), but also some big virtues: fewer moving parts and potentially lighter in weight overall, inherently the most accurate semi-auto design (much less is moving before the bullet exits the barrel, and it's all behind the barrel, not parallel with it), and the front is lightweight since the center of gravity is moved backwards compared to piston designs. I'm told AR-15 pattern rifles rule in 3 gun competitions (pistol, shotgun, and rifle/carbine) because of the weight distribution, which of course also is a virtue in close quarters combat/battle (CQB). I can't remember this feature in any other designs, but there are very possibly some ones that I'm not interested in and haven't learned the details of. Almost every other design puts a piston forward, which naturally incorporates the recoil spring. There's also the roller locking recoil designs, the ones that I'm familiar with (G3/HK 91, StG 57) have their piston forward as well, although that's not strictly required by the mechanism.
- hga 14y agoTypo: There's also the roller locking recoil designs, the ones that I'm familiar with (G3/HK 91, StG 57) have their spring forward as well, although that's not strictly required by the mechanism.
- jlgreco 14y agoOr for that matter, for pistols, "Magazine that attaches outside the pistol grip". That seems to be entirely design preference. What extra danger does one style present over another? It's like they looked at a TEC-9 and said "now, how can we ban this particular gun?". Or "A semi-automatic version of a fully automatic firearm". Is that to ban guns that are easily modified I guess? Is that necessarily an easy thing to do? Seems you could be more to the point and ban guns that can trivially be modified in such a way.
- rdl 14y agoYeah. I'd like to see guns categorized into three main functional categories. General (bolt, rimfire of all types, shotguns, probably lever -- and suppressors) High rate of fire (semiautomatic, particularly semi with detachable magazine -- semi with 5-10rd integral magazine might be general or general+). Fully automatic or burst might be considered HRF+. (there is honestly not a huge difference in performance in most plausible civilian shooting scenarios between a semiautomatic rifle and a fully automatic rifle. Outside suppression for movement, I've never wanted fully auto, including when the weapon I had was fully auto -- except for fun, or if it was mounted on a vehicle). This should include both imported auto and post-1986 auto. 922(r) should also be removed. Concealable (centerfire handgun, SBR, SBS, AOW) Have a licensing scheme for purchase and possession, but not registry of individual weapons within that class. If you have a HRF license you can buy any number of HRF or General or General+ all at the same time without reporting anything other than "HRF or lower" during the purchase. It's unclear how HRF and Concealable interact (maybe revolvers or fixed-small-magazines only if you only have a concealable license). It's unclear what level of training, background checks, etc. would be needed for each. I'd be inclined to raise the purchase/possession requirements for handguns and HRF weapons to the same as concealed carry permits are today in many states, with an actual course of fire, 1-2 days of training, etc., but there would need to be a requirement that such training be reasonably accessible and straightforward. It's acceptable to me if it takes 3-6 months and ~$500 to get a license to purchase HRF weapons and concealable weapons, provided basic rimfire weapons, shotguns, and bolt-action rifles are available with essentially an NCIC and <$25 fee on top of sale price.
- jlgreco 14y agoI would have both a Concealable permit and a HRF permit both include a General permit, but not include each other. If a gun fits into both categories, then you would need both permits. So in other words you would have 5 states; None, General, Concealable-General, HRF-General, All. That all seems very reasonable to me.. which sadly probably means it will never happen.
- rdl 14y agoOne way it's not reasonable is that pure collectors should be able to own weapons without necessarily being competent in their use, provided they're stored safely. (I mean, I'd love to own antique Japanese swords, but my knife/sword fighting knowledge is essentially prison style -- just get in close and stab-stab-stab as long as you can. There are presumably people who are the same way with guns.)
- efnx 14y agoAre there guns that <i>don't</i> look frightening? It really just depends on what side of the gun you happen to be standing.
- jlgreco 14y agoIt's a matter of degree. Matte black guns with pistol grips look "scarier" than the same gun with a traditional stained-wood stock and grip. People look at one and think "weapon of war" while the other says "hunting rifle". (Obviously both deserve and require the same amount of respect and caution.) Look at the old Federal Assault Weapons Ban and it should become pretty apparent what I mean. (PS: you can use italics like this: *foo bar baz* )
- efnx 14y agoAh nice, thanks.