3 ms·
> Yes, it produces less waste but The difference is minimal. As far as I understand, the difference is orders of magnitude! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thori
by stcredzero 14y ago
> Yes, it produces less waste but The difference is minimal.
As far as I understand, the difference is orders of magnitude!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium#Benefits_and_challenges http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium#Benefits_and_challenges
> So, while there are benefits the ROI on a multi billion dollar Thorium R&D progect are probably negative.
It could be possible to rebrand Thorium and overcome many of the PR challenges of nuclear power. A solution to a substantial part of the global warming problem is indeed worth hundreds of billions.
- danielweber 14y agoWhat do they mean by "long-lived waste"? Things that are highly radioactive stop being radioactive very quickly. Things that are lowly radioactive stay radioactive for a long time, but at low levels so you don't worry much about them. There's a middle "unsweet spot" of things that are radioactive enough to worry about but not radioactive enough that they quickly burn out. So where does thorium fit in that taxonomy?
- pkrein 14y agowell -- it's complicated. i started building a javascript library (nuclear.js : https://github.com/reinpk/nuclear.js https://github.com/reinpk/nuclear.js) to calculate the decay chains... the problem is that short lived isotopes, which are dangerous, can decay into long-lived isotopes, but basically the decay chains are complicated. i'll do a post about that soon :)
- uvdiv 14y agoWhat do they mean by "long-lived waste"? Actinides of half-life 100-100,000 years or so. These have a compounding disadvantage in that they are alpha-emitters, hence disproportionately radiotoxic (e.g. by ingestion) compared to gamma- and beta- emitters like common fission products. Orders of magnitude disproportionate. The theoretical advantage is huge: (this graph is from a French nuclear research lab which appears to be temporarily offline) http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-m6Jl1KpnH3E/TiwB5Ppo85I/AAAAAAAAADE/wJvHAVmTN28/s1600/img18.gif http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-m6Jl1KpnH3E/TiwB5Ppo85I/AAAAAAAAAD...
- Retric 14y agoIt's complicated, high level nuclear waste can be reprocessed and it becomes cheaper to do so the longer it sit's around. Low level waste is fairly cheap to deal with. So, it's really a question of what to do with the mid level stuff and they both produce similar amounts of that.