2 ms·
Yep, you're right. Perhaps only 1K sites as a rule. I also like the idea of getting feeds and just manually sorting through them. I firmly believe that there's
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Yep, you're right. Perhaps only 1K sites as a rule. I also like the idea of getting feeds and just manually sorting through them. I firmly believe that there's a mix between old-fashioned editing, user-editing, and user-submissions that hasn't been tried yet. Seems like everybody wants to do one or the other, when mixing them up might be the best solution. Perhaps an editor scours the top-hundred or so sites in a niche, along with user submissions. After the editor is finished, users can validate or not the entries based on feedback, like you said.
At the end of the day, how many articles do you really need to provide the average reader? It can't be that many. If you can find four or five truly unique and high quality articles for a reader each day, I think you'll build a loyal following. So the goal is to have zillions of articles enter, but only a few appear to the reader. I don't think "herd mentality" or voting systems are the way to sort that data. There has to be a better way.
Good stuff to think about.
- russell 18y agoYou probably need to allow more than 4 or 5 per day to encourage your readers to submit stories. I would suggest putting featured stories at the top and other noteworthy submissions below or on anther page. People really like to see their names in lights. Some concession to that will encourage that. Of course the downside is more trash. HN survives by the diligence of its community. Manual moderation should work well too.