3 ms·
On my blog I'm getting comment spam without any links as well. The usual stuff like "Great work! Plan to come back often!" but there's no link to Joe's Sex Shop
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
On my blog I'm getting comment spam without any links as well. The usual stuff like "Great work! Plan to come back often!" but there's no link to Joe's Sex Shop or anything -- just a bogus email address and fake name.
I used to think it was just poor comments, but it only happens on certain pages, which aren't at the top of my most popular list.
My theory is that the bots are working in waves -- first identify easy targets, then slowly exploit them. I wouldn't be surprised if the botnet guys are using Mechanical Turk-type operations just to work the CAPTCHAs and get valid logins for later use.
It used to be you could make generalizations about the bot wars. Now, with possibly millions of programmers out there with nothing to do but try to work the system? The complexity and nuance of attacks are several orders of magnitude greater than just five years ago. I'm not sure any kind of sweeping statement catches what's going on, except: there are a lot of entities on the web that are looking for doors -- any kind of doors. Once they find them, it may be months or years before they are ever used.
- 10ren 18y agoInteresting. Could it be that it's proof of account existence, and that's how someone gets paid?
- mixmax 18y agoI actually left a comment on your blog a while ago. You submitted an article here which I read and found to be amazingly good. So I wanted to leave a short comment saying just that. I had to retry a few times, and got some pretty weird errors. I tried changing e-mail adress, subject, etc. to see if the error would go away. So your problem might be that there are a lot of errors on the submission process, so people try again, often using different names, etc.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThanks. Will look into that. I like your idea about newbies trying out the system. Not as exciting as evil overlord botnets, but perhaps just as plausible. I guess the answers would be in a careful digging through the server logs. Appreciate your trying. I just upgraded to MT 4.2, so hopefully the comment submission bugs have been worked out.
- mixmax 18y agoNo worries. Appreciate your trying - I only did it because the article you wrote was really great :-) It's this one: http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2009/02/technology_is_h.php http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2009/02/technology_is...
- ks 18y agoOn my blog I'm getting comment spam without any links as well. The usual stuff like "Great work! Plan to come back often!" I don't have a blog myself (shocking, I know), but I have read that some blogs flag the mail adresses of previously accepted comments. The next time someone posts a comment, it will be accepted automatically. Could it be that some spammers use this approach to save accounts for future spamming?
- wheels 18y agoAt least the default for wordpress is that if a user has had one comment approved then further comments are approved automatically. I suspect that's the motivation for a first wave of pseudo-spam followed by the real influx.
- briansmith 18y agoOne of the ways Askimet works is shared-secret-key authentication using your email address. Notice how sites collect your email address when you submit a comment but they don't usually publish it. However, they do send your email address to Askimet. As a result, we can get a fairly good approximation of whether a comment is spam or not simply by checking to see if the email address was used for comments previously flagged as spam or ham. The more non-spam comments--and especially the more ham comments--that the email address has in the corpus, the less likely it is that the new message is spam. Now, imagine I am a spammer. I need to submit some automated comments that don't look like spam so that my spammy comments wll later get accepted. There are a variety of ways I can do this. The easiest is to give the user a generic compliment like "Wow, this was a great blog post! Thanks for publishing it." The comment doesn't add to the discussion but the blog owner is often reluctant to delete it because (a) it strokes his ego, (b) there is no way for him to tell if it is automatically generated or not. In fact, if his spam filter preemptively classified it as spam, he might even override the filter and reclassify it as ham; this would be a huge win for the spammer-to-be. Another way to do this is to automatically scrape a comment from another discussion about the page like Reddit, Digg, Twitter, or FriendFeed and submit it as a blog comment on the original page. A third way is to pay somebody a (very) small amount of money to read the blog post and write a comment (possibly using some fill-in-the-blanks response template system like those used in call centers.) It works the other way too. If I want your comments to start getting flagged as spam then I should start submitting spam-like comments in your name. Then, users will start classifying my forged spam comments as spam and the automatic classifiers will start automatically classifying your valid comments as spam.
- briansmith 18y agoI forgot to add the corollary. Much like computers will soon be able to solve CAPTCHAs better than people, automated spamming systems will eventually be able to generate comments that are as good or better than human-submitted comments. In other words, we can expect comments that are generated by spammers to eventually become valuable enough that we want to retain them instead of filtering them away. That isn't the reality today but it could be soon. You might have a discussion in your blog's comments and then realize that everybody in the conversation is a robot except you. And you will learn something from those robots and/or lose an argument with them, when they get really good. Eventually, you will be able to post a rough draft of your blog post, and the spam robots will start up a good conversation about it in the comments. Then, based on their feedback, you can revise it into the final draft (if the robots haven't already given you a link to a blog post that refuted your point or made it better than you can). As a final step, we might notice that not only are the best comments are written by spam robots, but the best blogs are spam blogs too. Right now, people are blogging-for-adsense manually; in the future, Google will be able to blog-for-adsense itself, cutting out the authors. Today, if a site wants its user-generated content (comments in this case) to retain its value, it needs to start filtering out the low-value content, regardless of whether it was generated by a spammer or a well-intentioned user. For example, If I add a comment to your blog "Great blog post!" on your blog, you should probably delete it, even if you know I am not a spammer. Unfortunately, if you do that, legitimate users who see their complimentary comments get deleted might react negatively (e.g. stop commenting or complain loudly, generating even worse comments). So, we can see that the spammers who are generating low-value comments already have the ability to drive away your valuable commentators if those commentators occasionally submit low-value comments.
- lacker 18y agoWhy do you think this is spam? I often use a bogus email address and fake name for a service I don't intend to use frequently, like blog comments.