3 ms·
> downloading the entire contents of JSTOR so that you can publish it on a file sharing network and thereby destroy its commercial value It seems implausible t
by jlgreco 14y ago
> downloading the entire contents of JSTOR so that you can publish it on a file sharing network and thereby destroy its commercial value
It seems implausible to me that publishing the contents of JSTOR in such a way would actually destroy any substantial amount of JSTOR's value. What university would actually drop their JSTOR subscription in favour of a bunch of unlicensed PDFs they torrented? JSTOR, in addition to keeping you on the right side of copyright law, gives you all their systems for querying their data, and keeps itself up to date.
Maybe a university in a developing country would drop their subscription, but any in the US? I find it unlikely.
Such a torrent would be far more useful to an individual who didn't have access to an organization that subscribed. However it seems these pay-per-download fees only account for a fraction of a percent of JSTOR's operating budget (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5064408 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5064408).
So it looks like there is some feasible harm there, but by no means destroyed commercial value.