3 ms·
The fact that Aaron faced jail time that was appropriate only for people who maliciously defrauded others to the tune of billions of dollars for personal benefi
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
The fact that Aaron faced jail time that was appropriate only for people who maliciously defrauded others to the tune of billions of dollars for personal benefit is the problem. The fact that the only way to receive a fair sentence was to give up the right to a trial is the problem.
If the outcome of a trial was potentially 6 months in prison then the likelihood he would endure a trial would be far, far higher.
Instead the criminal justice system was abused, and a disproportionate punishment was put on the table to scare Aaron (as it has been used to scare so many other defendants) into taking a plea bargain and give up on having his day in court.
That's a perversion of justice and something that we should in no way be comfortable with.
- slapshot 14y agoAny attorney Aaron hired would be able to read the sentencing guidelines manual (it's published in a convenient softcover version that any federal criminal attorney has on his/her desk) and inform Aaron that the maximum realistic sentence was less than a year, and that as long as the sentence was on "Zone A" on the chart I provided, the judge would be free to give probation with zero jail time. The maximum sentence was 35 years because that's the maximum penalty for all forms of wire fraud. The prosecutor is constitutionally required to inform the defendant of the maximum sentence. If you ever sit in on a plea colloquy you'll hear the prosecutor tell the defendant the maximum sentence and the defendant acknowledge the maximum, even if everybody knows that the sentence will be time served, or probation, or just a fine/restitution. I don't know why Aaron's lawyer dropped the ball on this.
- toyg 14y ago> I don't know why Aaron's lawyer dropped the ball on this. We don't know he did. From his (and Lessig's, who was also involved) statements, it looks like he got the feeling that Heymann and Ortiz were not bluffing, that they wanted to make an example out of Aaron and lock him up for real. We can only second-guess their motives (and many have done just that, in the last four days), but from what it has emerged until now, there was a real sense in Aaron's legal team that the prosecution was bent on throwing him in jail, even just for one day, and would have had it from any judge in the circuit. For sure, there was no incentive for the prosecution to be lenient: no loot to recover, no co-conspirators to turn, no scandal to keep quiet, nothing. I guess we'll know a bit more about all this in a year or two, when investigative books will come out and people in the US Attorney office will start unbuttoning, or maybe after the next Presidential cycle if there is a party switch at the top.