3 ms·
"otherwise superbly functioning"--highly functioning people don't kill themselves, not even in aaronsw's situation.
by philwelch 14y ago
"otherwise superbly functioning"--highly functioning people don't kill themselves, not even in aaronsw's situation.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoSo we define proper mental health as people who would not ever kill themselves? How convenient for you.
- philwelch 14y agoThat's how it's usually defined, maybe with the exception of terminal illness or mortal injury.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoAnd it doesn't bother you how circular that is? 1. Anyone who would kill themselves is not mentally well 2. We cannot allow you to kill yourself because you're not mentally well
- philwelch 14y agoThere are exceptions; can you argue that this is one of them or do you just enjoy disagreeing with people?
- hackinthebochs 14y agoI'm not sure what point you're making regarding exceptions. But I don't believe those exceptions are enough. Being able to remove someone's right because you don't like how they choose to exercise it is no right at all. Either you believe in a right or you don't.
- philwelch 14y agoI didn't say anything about rights.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoForgot which thread I was in. Either way, circular logic is circular.
- jacquesm 14y agoThe twin ghosts of Alan Turing and Socrates would disagree with you. Of course you're now going to argue that they were in a different situation, but both were apparently unable to reconcile living with the injustices heaped upon them by society and there is parallel with Aaron there.
- philwelch 14y agoAt least the way I meant it, there's a difference between "highly functioning" (even "superbly functioning") and "intelligent" or "accomplished"--and in any case, Socrates was sentenced to death and chose to accept his sentence rather than escaping from prison, so there's that.
- jacquesm 14y agoYou completely miss the point of the Socrates reference. I'll be lazy and quote wikipedia at you: "According to Xenophon's story, Socrates purposefully gave a defiant defense to the jury because "he believed he would be better off dead". Xenophon goes on to describe a defense by Socrates that explains the rigors of old age, and how Socrates would be glad to circumvent them by being sentenced to death. It is also understood that Socrates also wished to die because he "actually believed the right time had come for him to die." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socrates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socrates
- philwelch 14y agoOK, thanks.
- jlgreco 14y agoEven ignoring the sentencing of Socrates, Socrates refusing Crito's offer seems to me a clear cut case of suicide. He is offered a chance to avoid his murder and turns it down, in essence making the decision that his life will come to an end. Now, Socrates of course offers a rational defence for his refusal to save himself so if we accept the refusal as an act of suicide we also accept that suicide can, at least in some circumstances, be the product of a rational train of thought. Plato's accounts of Socrates offer us a superb platform on which to reason about this sort of thing. Helps to filter out a lot of the modern victim-blaming cruft that has built up over the past few centuries.