6 ms·
Why do you even need a DUNS number? If you're an individual person, just get an individual account and sell it that way. Honestly, this seems a bit like a publ
by eridius 14y ago
Why do you even need a DUNS number? If you're an individual person, just get an individual account and sell it that way.
Honestly, this seems a bit like a publicity stunt to me. Everyone loves hating on Apple these days, and if you can tie it to "look at my new opensource project", then BAM, it hits HN front page.
- eduardordm 14y agoI opened a company specifically for this (ipad/iphone development) it was my plan to leave my current company and build something less stressful. I reached a point where I'm no longer interested in building apps for the app store, apple asks too much and give us too little. I posted on HN because most readers are also programmers and they are exactly whom will fork the project, etc. That said, yep, it can be considered a 'publicity stunt', but you make it sound as something bad. I really just want that those interested get in touch.
- Steko 14y ago"you make it sound as something bad" Because you've basically admitted that your post is disingenuous. The DUNS requirement is easily sidestepped in the short term and a complete non-issue in the long term.
- dutchbrit 14y agoBut it really shouldn't be an issue in the first place, right?
- pretoriusB 14y agoIt's not, except if you are a company. And if you are a company, you have a lot more paperwork to worry about than just DUNS. Plus, it helps keep out the less motivated.
- ghshephard 14y agoI'm confused - if you opened a company, then there is obviously going to be a lot more paperwork/hoops to jump through than if you did this as an individual. Maybe I'm missing something here - why didn't you just publish the App as an individual?
- eduardordm 14y agoMy idea was to release an app every 3-5 months and make at least 60k/year. I cannot sell that much in Brazil as a individual (limit here is 36k BRL). Actually, it took me 8 days to open the company. At the first day I had the CNPJ (EIN in the US), so, in fact, it took me less than 24 hours to be able to accept payments. I don't see the app store as a viable way of making a living anymore (for single developers). I'll try to build something that doesn't depend of other company's mood.
- eridius 14y agoFirst off, you actually have a limit on how much an individual developer can make? That sounds crazy. Secondly, I don't understand your anger at Apple. They don't control DUNS numbers. It's not their fault that you're having a problem getting one.
- Steko 14y agoElaborating a bit on DUNS: My understanding is that DUNS was not always a requirement for companies publishing on the iOS App Store. It was added about a year and a half ago (?) and given the timing and what DUNS represents it seems reasonable to assume that it was added as a reaction to app spammers and scammers that would run fly by night operations, take people's money and run. DUNS may not have been the best solution and like other areas of the submission/approval process it seems there are some obvious quality of life improvements Apple should implement but in the big picture what is the alternative to DUNS? (1) Go back to scammer friendly system. Yeah I don't see that happening. (2) Apple holds the money for longer. I don't see people lining up for this option. (3) Everyone has to buy insurance. Spoilers: insurer asks for DUNS number. (4) A better partner than D&B. Is there one? The US government appears to be looking for alternatives as well[1] but it doesn't look like there is a good replacement. [1] http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-715R http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-715R GSA has been conducting an analysis of alternatives for the use of Dun & Bradstreet's DUNS entity unique identifier and is expected to complete its analysis by March 30, 2013.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>I opened a company specifically for this (ipad/iphone development) it was my plan to leave my current company and build something less stressful. This seems more like wishful thinking (and underestimating the effort and polish needed) than a serious business decision. >I reached a point where I'm no longer interested in building apps for the app store, apple asks too much and give us too little. It asks for: a Mac to work (lots of people have one already) on, a $99/year iOS developer account and 30% of your sales. With that you get: an quite capable IDE for free, a top-notch SDK, tons of documentation, access to a market of 100+ million devices and one-click credit card accounts that is KNOWN to sell billions of apps. Seems like a bargain. Heck, companies used to sell a developer license for their SDK at the price of a high-end Mac itself -- and without providing access to any market or a free IDE. A lot still do. What exactly have you provided to feel so entitled? A half-finished app, built while "learning Objective-C"?
- readme 14y agoSo now you know how to make the front page!
- hrabago 14y agoThere are many benefits to being an LLC, and many reasons why one would want to publish as a company instead of as an individual. I have also read before (can't find it now, though) that there are people who give more credibility to applications when they are published by a company rather than an individual.
- droithomme 14y agoIn the US a sole proprietorship is a business. A sole proprietorship is the most common form of business in the United States. Sole Proprietorships do not require LLC or C corporation filings. Often but not always they require a business license. If one does not have business partners and is running a software company, the sole proprietorship is the most sensible form. Note that LLCs do not protect the actual developer from liability from his errors, they only protect the partners from liability from errors they themselves did not personally create. To protect oneself from ones own errors, businesses should acquire E&O insurance. Software development businesses that do not have E&O insurance are putting themselves at risk.
- No1 14y agoWhat you are describing sounds more like an LLP, not an LLC.
- capkutay 14y agoUnfortunately I agree. It sounds like a frustrating process, but people LOVE to hate Apple these days. And Apple is letting it happen. When you stop innovating and creating things people love, you allow yourself to take jabs. Maintaining and monetizing the hell out of what you already have seems like a good idea on paper, but it doesn't seem to be working out so well for Apple at this point.
- rimantas 14y agoLike Apple makes no money, nobody buys its products, etc.? Can we stop this "innovation" bullshit? Do you even know what you want (gimmics don't count). What kind of innovation do you expect from Samsung in its next phone? From Google in next Nexus? Coffee maker and kitchen sink? Or do you want them radically changing UI, just because someone got bored? How often do you want them to innovate, once a month or once in three monts would be enough?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]