5 ms·
> Civil disobedience according to Thoreau, according to Gandhi, and according to Martin Luther King, Jr. is all about being willing to do the time after intenti
by jlgreco 14y ago
> Civil disobedience according to Thoreau, according to Gandhi, and according to Martin Luther King, Jr. is all about being willing to do the time after intentionally breaking a law
The issue I am seeing here is that this take on civil disobedience is only worth it if your incarceration does one or more of the following: threatens to clog the system, infuriates the masses, draws attention to the absurdity of the system, provides an opportunity to set legal precedent, or is just in general noticed and cared about. If it does none of those things, then the only thing getting caught/locked up accomplishes is the silencing of another voice.
Of course you could also say that protesters should accept arrests even if there is nothing to be gained by it just to adhere to some sort of socratic social contract mentality, but not everyone buys into that mentality. I know I certainly do not.
If you are confident that you can secure convictions, and are confident that the system can handle the load, and are confident that the masses don't really give a shit about anything unless a celebrity is involved, then telling activists to go get arrested becomes an effective tool of suppression.
Had Swartz been convicted and served his sentence, would the HN community at large care? We were dismissive when he was alive and it looked like he was hosed, would that have really changed when the jury came back with their verdict?
- gruseom 14y ago> Had Swartz been convicted and served his sentence, would the HN community at large care? I would have. I totally misread the situation. I thought there was basically zero chance he would be punished so vindictively. And I had no idea that he was all this time in Kafka hell. Had Aaron gone to prison it would have been a wake-up call for a lot of people, much as his suicide was — except that one could have done something about it. Actually, a trial and conviction would likely have become a cause celebre in the tech world. And yes I know that people don't just kill themselves for one straightforward reason. It's still sickening.
- jlgreco 14y agoMaybe so. I am not confident that his conviction would cause waves large enough to really cause any sort of change though. I can't help but feel many people here would be less inclined to change their position (or even care enough to read articles about it) were the revelations not accompanied by such a tragic shock. Maybe I'm just being cynical because I found the dismissal from prominent community members so shocking and offensive at the time. However I am certain that were he someone with even less celebrity who was interested in something more marginal than freeing academic works, getting convicted really really would do fuck-all for his cause.
- anigbrowl 14y agoHow do you mean punished so vindictively? A 6 month stint in jail (reduced for good behavior) doesn't seem wildly vindictive to me. For the people saying he was facing a lifetime in jail - well yeah, if you add up all the maximum possible sentences and run them consecutively. But that hardly ever happens except in the most egregious of cases. If he had lost at trial I doubt his sentence would have been much longer than a year or two. The indictment doesn't say 'he committed wire fraud, he must serve 20 years', it just says 'he committed wire fraud' - an offense for which the maximum penalty happens to be 20 years. The court decides what the actual sentence is after conviction.They rarely hand out the maximum and the statute does not assert any mandatory minimum (which provisions are unconstitutional now anyway, but that's beside the point).
- tptacek 14y agoAaron's own lawyer said he didn't believe that Swartz would have received a custodial sentence even if he had been convicted. What's vindictive isn't the outcome. The outcome never had a chance to happen, so it's hard to discuss it. What was bad about this situation is a prosecution that had taken such a hard line that a 6-7 year prison sentence --- a life-changing calamity --- would have seemed like a real possibility. Swartz was being required to swear before a court that he committed 13 different felonies just to get off with ~half a year's prison time.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWe'll continue to disagree about this, but I think the plea deal was fair enough. Sure, being a felon is a burden - but realistically, being a hacker felon is much less of a burden than being an ex-crack dealer or something. Plugging your machine directly into someone's wiring closet without permission and then running scripts to pull down 100x the traffic requests of everyone else on the campus combined (resulting in a multi-day shutdown that affects all the legitimate users of that campus) is pretty abusive. If I was running a business and someone did that I'd be furious, even if they were just using the bandwidth to download all of wikipedia or something equally freely accessible.
- 14y ago