4 ms·
I have a hard time getting past the "poor people have more stuff" idea in the beginning. This is akin to thinking that rich people are cleaner. My observation
by taeric 14y ago
I have a hard time getting past the "poor people have more stuff" idea in the beginning. This is akin to thinking that rich people are cleaner. My observation is just that rich people have help. I'd be highly curious to know if there are good numbers into these claims.
- gatsby 14y agoI ran a quick search for articles or data to support pg's idea but couldn't find any. I'm wondering if, on average, "rich" and "poor" people have a similar amount of stuff/junk, but the rich have higher-quality junk and more room to spread it out so it looks cleaner or more minimalist.
- taeric 14y agoPretty much my thoughts. If you ever find anything on this, I'd be interested.
- lmm 14y agoWhen you're poor you have to be more risk-averse. You can't afford to follow the recommendations of many people here and throw out everything you think you probably won't need, then re-buy the stuff you actually need. Even something trivial like the rotary telephone he mentions - if you ever needed a new phone you could get a new one for $10, which to you or me is nothing, but could be a lot if you're poor. I'd also be interested to see better numbers, but the observation seems to make sense.
- taeric 14y agoApologies for missing this while this article was live. Not sure if you'll see my response. My assertions are A) more that richer people generally just have more than they realize, and B) having help decluttering is huge. It is easy to have the appearance of less stuff when you have a 5 bedroom house. Or, multiple houses. Not so much when you live in a 2 bedroom apartment. Similarly, if you can hire cleaners, it is not shocking that you can stay clean. Even relatively inexpensive cleaners. ($50 every two weeks, for instance. Easily doable for anyone wiling to drop cable. So, not exactly reserved for the super rich.)