3 ms·
We don't have enough data yet to prove anything by research paper standards, but that doesn't mean I'm saying nothing. We try consciously to ignore where peopl
by pg 19y ago
We don't have enough data yet to prove anything by research paper standards, but that doesn't mean I'm saying nothing. We try consciously to ignore where people went to school; that is not standard practice; and moreover this is something I'm claiming we've changed.
- michael_nielsen 19y agoPresumably, your data can only show that it doesn't matter what school you went to, conditional on being accepted by YC. That is a completely different statement than showing that it doesn't matter what school you went to. Your article appears to me like it is conflating the two.
- pg 19y agoNo, I'm also considering people we invite for interviews.
- gojomo 19y agoSo the conjecture of the essay is some combination of the following: (1) Conditional on having applied to YC, YC finds that having attended a prestigious college makes one no more likely to be selected for interviews. (2) Conditional on having been selected for YC interviews, YC finds that having attended a prestigious college makes one no more likely to receive YC support. (3) Conditional on receiving YC support, YC finds that having attended a prestigious college makes one no more likely to succeed in the market (here defined as visibly thriving within about a year). Given the initial essay's strong emphasis on market success as the ultimate verifier (paragraphs 5-8), I thought the main idea was (3) -- but if interview invites/subjective-evaluations are a factor, some amount of (1) and (2) are mixed in, too.