2 ms·
Not to forget that in the German legal system it is, well common maybe to big a word, but at least possiblke to put people almost indeffinitaly in a psychiatric
by hef19898 14y ago
Not to forget that in the German legal system it is, well common maybe to big a word, but at least possiblke to put people almost indeffinitaly in a psychiatric clinic. Needed for this is a criminal lawsuite and a psychiatric evaluation stating said individual is a threat for him or herself and others. If the court follows that evaluation, the defendant can be put in a forensic psychiatry without being judged guilty for the crime at all.
Just a different point, doesn't have to do something with the abuse potential of plea bargains. The biggest criticism I have regarding plea bargains in Germany is, that they usually apply for white collar crimes since these tend to be rather to complex for the average judge and state attorney to follow. Blue collar crimes are differrent matter all together.
The result is that a plea bargain benefits the state since the process is fast, the defendant since not the whole scope becomes public and the sentence tends to be rather short. While there are some public prosecution departments speciallized in white collar and financial crimes they are far between. So whenever there is one that can be settled out of court, it's tempting.
But that's just my personal view of it. One prominent example of a guy being in a psychiatry since 2006 is Gustl Mollath. And it turned out that he is not as guilty as initially believed...
- Xylakant 14y agoThe matter of detention in a psychiatric ward is a separate issue. In general it is a good thing since defendants in need of treatment get treatment instead of punishment. It is not intended as indefinite detention but requires regular reexamination. There's a problem with the examination though: There is little incentive to release a patient as "now safe", since the public outcry would be massive if the patient committed another crime afterwards. The Mollath case is contested. It may very well be possible that he is guilty, but not crazy or crazy, but not guilty. The problems found in this case are very symptomatic of the bavaria/baden-württemberg courts. One reason is that the appeals court for that region is unlikely to actually accept an appeal.