8 ms·
The Atlantic suspends the Scientology advertorial
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoI wonder how many subscribers and advertising clients threatened (or did) pull their funding of The Atlantic? The the time I saw it hit front page here, to now hasn't been that long. Must have hurt their bottom line.
- MartinCron 14y agoOr the sensibilities of their editorial staff, some of whom may not have even known about it until it went out. Damage is already done, though.
- Pitarou 14y agoIf they show that they take this screw-up seriously, then they could still come out looking pretty good.
- MartinCron 14y agoThey'll have to do better than the one sentence non-reply they have posted, but I totally agree. All organizations mess up, how they handle it can be instructive.
- joeguilmette 14y agoI guess everyone can stop hyperventilating. I subscribe to The Atlantic's Kindle version for (a shockingly cheap) $3 a month. Maybe it's $2? I don't know. I have also subscribed to The New Yorker but always had trouble finishing an issue. Most of the material just didn't resonate with me. The Atlantic, however, is everything I could want in a rag. I love it, and I'm happy to see them suspend this piece of ill-thought out advertising...
- amputect 14y agoI enjoy the writing in the Atlantic as much as the next guy. (Edit: and to their credit, here is a slightly more interesting story they did on Scientology in 2011: http://www.theatlanticwire.com/national/2011/02/scientology-slave-labor-beatings-and-an-fbi-investigation/21198/ http://www.theatlanticwire.com/national/2011/02/scientology-... ) That said, it's not hyperventilating to point out that prohibiting dissenting comments on articles, even if they are shameless (and paid-for) advertising, is pretty much bullshit. I mean, The Atlantic is a private company, they have the right to do whatever they want, squelch whatever discussion they like. The First Amendment doesn't apply to posting on websites. But they get to deal with the fallout that comes with it, and it looks like they either didn't anticipate exactly how badly their shameless cash grab would be taken, or they didn't think there was anything wrong with essentially putting their good name and credibility behind something as controversial (charitably speaking) as scientology.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI have never finished an issue of the New Yorker before another issue comes out, but the two or three articles I do read tend to be amazing. It's definitely worth the steep price of admission. I subscribed to the Atlantic recently (and won't be canceling, since they retracted the Scientology ad) and have to say that I get as much or more from their web articles as I do the print edition. I guess there's less guilt now though.
- joeguilmette 14y agoIs there a difference between the two? I always assumed that I could ignore all the web articles and assume it would magically appear on my Kindle when the new edition came out.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI always figured there was stuff in the print/digital edition that isn't on the website, but I never really bothered to check either. Guilt assuaged either way I suppose.
- 14y ago
- pmiller2 14y agoI never saw this. Anyone got a pointer to a mirror?
- Kazurik 14y agoMirror link: http://i.minus.com/iCziY2iQpxWav.jpg http://i.minus.com/iCziY2iQpxWav.jpg Via: http://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/16l4b4/the_atlantics_sponsored_story_on_scientology_it/c7x43ng?context=2 http://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/16l4b4/the_atlantics_s...
- sikhnerd 14y agoGoogle Cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fsponsored%2Fscientology%2Farchive%2F2013%2F01%2Fdavid-miscavige-leads-scientology-to-milestone-year-%2F266958%2F&oq=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fsponsored%2Fscientology%2Farchive%2F2013%2F01%2Fdavid-miscavige-leads-scientology-to-milestone-year-%2F266958%2F&sugexp=chrome,mod=16&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%... Image Mirror (Via Reddit): http://i.minus.com/iCziY2iQpxWav.jpg http://i.minus.com/iCziY2iQpxWav.jpg
- a_bonobo 14y agoAddendum: That top comment was deleted after a while, too, leaving only the obviously pro Scientology comments
- pocket 14y agoThe comment had reached over 630 upvotes (I think) when I saw it. Compared to at most ~30 for the next most upvoted comment… that little piece of data from the ads readership might've been enough for the editorial staff to make the change.
- philsheard 14y agoI recorded a short screencast to capture the pace of the upvotes https://plus.google.com/105550226241566085548/posts/YxafettTz8i https://plus.google.com/105550226241566085548/posts/YxafettT...
- lancewiggs 14y agoClearly editorial and sales have misalignment. The good news is that pulling the advertorial shows that the editors are still in charge. The Atlantic would do well to ensure that it remains that way. Quality content is the only way to earn respect in the long run.
- neumann_alfred 14y agopulling the advertorial shows that the editors are still in charge What kind of editing is it that would allow this crap to appear for a few hours? This shows that they didn't expect and couldn't handle the backlash, but nothing more. Well, maybe that the Disqus censorship hamster wheels were overheating, too. But unless they come clean and distance themselves from this in no unclear terms, and ask for forgiveness, they can just go play in traffic (pun wasn't on purpose but I'm keeping it).
- Pitarou 14y agoMaybe it just shows that they gave advertising too much of a free hand? "It's better to ask forgiveness than permission." and all that.
- Symmetry 14y agoTo quote the illustrious Popehat: "When you outsource your marketing you outsource your reputation."
- spitx 14y agoHow bad do the finances of a visibly healthy publication have to be, to go down the path of advertorials? Are things in print media that chafing? NYT being bankrolled and drip-fed for survival, by a Mexican billionaire is one thing. I was an avid reader of the Atlantic when David Brooks wrote for it. It was a fine publication back then. I didn't realize things, lately, had gotten so dire. This is just appalling. Why aren't these print guys experimenting with alternate brick-and-mortar distribution models?
- throwaway1 14y agoI can say, having been on the inside of Atlantic Media a little over a year ago, people are running around like chickens with their heads cut off about revenue there. They've made it into the black through aggressive advertising sales and extreme cost-cutting/staff demands (trying to make "startup hours" the norm, like working to 10pm, letting seasoned journalists walk and replacing them with interns and recent grads), but they were still taking on water whether anybody wanted to admit it. I'm happy I left before it got this bad.
- fusiongyro 14y agoWhen I got an Android device, I discovered they are trying an alternative distribution model. This company Next Issue sells a subscription for $10/month that basically entitles you to read any of some ~50 magazines on your tablet. The thing that really rubbed me the wrong way is that I theoretically get the New Yorker electronic edition for free since I'm a full subscriber, but I'd still have to pay an extra $10/month to use the Next Issue app (unlike the New Yorker app for iPad). They also sell a "premium" subscription for $15/month that includes the New Yorker and some other "premium" magazines (like Sports Illustrated). Then I discovered the New Yorker restricts people to devices with particular resolutions, which my tablet didn't have. So they're trying to figure it out, in fits and starts, but they seem to be aiming for Hulu, which doesn't strike me as the best model of success.
- spitx 14y agoI, for one, think that print publications have left far too many revenue streams on the table when the going was good, before the advent of Craigslist & Google, even before the blogs of today - Huffington Post & the like - started robbing attention share away from established print outlets. Print publications were and are notoriously stubborn in many ways. They could have done a dozen things to immunize themselves from the online entrants in the early days. They didn't. Now they're having to deal with the consequence of their arrogance and myopia in ways they've never imagined.
- jerrya 14y agoI don't understand the "sponsored" content gambit, but I do recall reading various print magazines that had bundled content inside of them that looked very much like "real" articles but were basically sponsored ads. But I don't understand it. I would think that any ad that looks like your material fundamentally is misleading your readers by conflating your brand, your mission, your reputation with its own. So I don't understand sponsored content, and I certainly don't understand making it look like regular, non-sponsored content. Going further, the notion of allowing moderated and only favorable comments on your sponsored content is even more deceptive. Hey, but maybe not. Maybe more deceptive would be having the sponsored content that looks like your own material and then allowing all comments which might give even more credence to the mistaken impression the sponsored content is not sponsored. So whatever, if the Atlantic wants to flush its reputation down, and that of James Fallows and so many other writers, hey, free country, free speech, there really is nothing to complain about. So in that sense, what I find more dubious is this. The Atlantic taking sponsored content from GE, but refusing to take sponsored content from Scientology. In what real, legal, sense, provable by things on the book, is Scientology different from GE that makes it okay for The Atlantic to take money from GE and not Scientology? The FBI is conducting its first investigation into Scientology in 30 years, but apart from stories, in a sense doesn't that confirm Scientology basically runs as a legal business? And in the sense the US Government seems to recognize Scientology as a religion, why is it okay for The Atlantic to refuse content from Scientology? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology#Recognition_as_a_religion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology#Recognition_as_a_re...) Would it so easily refuse content from Catholic, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, or Islamic organizations? (How many investigations of GE has the FBI performed in the past 30 years?) Again, The Atlantic is responsible for their own content, I have no idea why they do this sponsored content in the first place, if they want to flush Ta-Nehisi Coates reputation down the toilet that's their right, maybe with Andrew Sullivan branching out they have much more limited dollars, but, ... Hey I think they just compounded their initial stupid decision on sponsored content by caving to whomeever. I think they now look worse, not better. I think their response needs to be along the lines of no more sponsored content, or an explanation of what makes Scientology different. All that said, to hell with Scientology.
- fusiongyro 14y ago
- mhuffman 14y agoI understand the commercial need to make money, but if you have to trade your credibility in for the cash, it is probably a sign that your business model is over. Time to close the doors, or find a realistic method of finance.
- blakerson 14y agoThey just traded the Scientology article back in for HN traffic.
- nonamegiven 14y agoEntertainment Tonight is still on TV. The Atlantic used to make money by being reputable and engaging. They could easily decide to make money by making money. I'd miss them, but one day someone will say "The Atlantic is still on the web" in response to a similar comment.
- gleenn 14y agoOne word: Good.
- neumann_alfred 14y ago4 words: too little, too late.
- fusiongyro 14y agoToo little? Were you hoping for a refund of your $0? Too late? It was online for all of three hours. You're going to have to lower that bar if you expect anyone to get over it.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoWere you hoping for a refund of your $0? How about an apology? Even just "we are sorry for any confusion we may have caused", anything to indicate they are remotely aware of the gravity of wtf they just did? It was online for all of three hours. During which all negative comments except one were censored, while the votes spoke very clearly what the silenced majority was thinking. And that thing shouldn't have been online for even 5 minutes. They pulled it because of the backlash. That ain't enough. Every slimy scumbag sociopath understands punishment and eats chalk in response.. so? You're going to have to lower that bar if you expect anyone to get over it. Right, I totally forgot that everybody, and every body of people I trust and respect, occasionally slips up and supports Scientology while engaging in censorship, for "just a few hours". I guess I'll just have to be a hermite now :( Oh well, I'll take consolation in the fact that Scientology won't get me either. Nor will any of the complacent, spineless twats who just shrug it off when an organization which holds so many people hostage in such a cynical way gets an advertisement by a (former) newspaper. If this shit doesn't make you angry then you know what, fuck you as well.. as you can see, my bar is even higher than you thought, hah.
- fusiongyro 14y agoHow about it's 1 AM in DC? Can't wait until morning for your apology? "I demand justice—and I have to have it before going to bed!" I saw the article—there were plenty of negative comments. Not all of them were overt ("Too bad Shelly Miscavige couldn't attend!") but there were plenty there, along with huge quantities of downvotes on ambivalent and pro-Scientology comments. Much like unreported rapes, how accurate can your statistics on censored comments really be? Did you leave a "fuck you, Scientology!" comment and it didn't show up? Maybe there are other explanations we can identify before positing some kind of conspiracy. Changing behavior because of backlash has to be enough sometimes. Especially with organizations. Not every person in this country is as acquainted with Scientology as we are—most Americans think they're just some kind of new age religion for celebrities and are totally unaware of the kidnapping, abuse, murder, etc. Not every company can afford to have every decision filter through every person in the hierarchy to the top before its effects are felt.
- sk5t 14y agoThe really confounding thing here was the shaping/censoring on the comments... Want to post something that looks like an article with a comment area to boot? A responsible publication must then at least allow a healthy discourse, so that readers who don't spot the advertisement can find a little enlightenment. Alternately they may have, in good conscience, permitted no user feedback at all; put "Comments on sponsored content are unavailable" at the bottom. Good enough. The illusion of an article plus a sham of heavily censored comments went beyond the pale.
- corporalagumbo 14y agoThe guys from Scientology's PR department requested moderated comments with (I suppose) overtly negative comments removed. As they were paying for the content to be run, they were free to request any terms and conditions that they desired. The Atlantic was free to accept or refuse the terms and conditions and in this instance chose to accept them. For what it's worth I found it interesting to hear comments from people outing themselves as enthusiastic Scientologists. First time I've come across that on the web.
- rdl 14y agoI would have preferred no comments to moderated comments.
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> I found it interesting to hear comments from people outing themselves as enthusiastic Scientologists. I didn't read any of the comments; were they actual people you'd heard of before, or random scientologists for whom the association was already moderately public, or total sock puppets?
- corporalagumbo 14y agoThe second.
- nonamegiven 14y agoSome free-thought comments did get through. My favorite went something like "This is great! How much does it cost to join?"
- blakerson 14y agoFor those following the numbers, it would appear that traffic from HN is worth more to The Atlantic than however much Scientology paid.
- cheald 14y agoThis was much bigger than just HN. Twitter lit up like a Christmas tree on this issue last night.
- Sanddancer 14y agoThis was a much more telling article than the culties would ever want to admit. Read it. Carefully. Notice how they ever talk about buildings, and never people. Were this legitimate growth, we'd see much more information on the numbers, and of the people, filling these rooms. We'd see them announcing from the rooftops the number of "clears" they've made over the past five years. Instead, it's the same old story, of hollow husks of buildings constructed. of Miscavige in photo after photo looking exactly the same. The deletion of critical comments was equally telling of how desperate The Atlantic was in making sure the church got their squeaky image. From the story being told, giving the sales department editorial control over these comments is just wrong headed and asinine. Which leads to the scarier question -- exactly how high up the chain was this decision made? Forcing community content moderators to eschew their standards in order to make a few bucks makes me question any desire to read the Atlantic in the future, regardless of if they pulled the content or not.
- tptacek 14y agoUm, yes, this was definitely not an attempt to do an evenhanded or professional job of reporting on the Church of Scientology. You are right.
- ekianjo 14y agoWell, at least it was clearly mentioned that it was a sponsored article. There are so many times that articles are "bought" by advertisers or other parties while the contents pretend to be legit (not specific to The Atlantic, I am talking about the press in general).
- Peroni 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertorial http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertorial
- temphn 14y agoWhat is bizarre is this: how are they getting the money to build all these huge, fancy buildings and hold these kinds of ceremonies? This must be hundreds of millions of dollars. And they aren't all in podunk towns; one was even in Israel. Are they that good at wringing money out of people? Wow.
- Pitarou 14y agoI would like to believe that the responsible adults have now stepped in to clean up the mess caused by some moron in sales being given too much of a free hand.
- Natsu 14y agoDoes anyone know what the weird Hebrew (?) writing on those two symbols says? It seems somewhat out of place, along with the crosses, given that Scientology is not a Jewish or Christian sect.
- jk4930 14y ago"Church of Scientology of Israel"
- fortunatefein 14y agoWould love to do a fact check of the Goldman Sachs sponsored content.
- hobbyhacker 14y agohappy reading: http://kspaink.home.xs4all.nl/fishman/home.html http://kspaink.home.xs4all.nl/fishman/home.html
- iProject 14y agoEven before this suspension there was recent evidence that in non-advertorials The Atlantic was willing to call out Scientology. Googling "scientology site:theatlantic.com" yields, for example: http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/01/a-wonderful-new-book-about-scientology-by-a-wonderful-writer/267178/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/01/a-wonder... (dated Jan 14, 2013. Weirdly uncritical, simple praise for a book on Scientology) July 2012 The Atlantic: "Psychiatry vs. Scientology": http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/07/scientology-vs-psychiatry-a-case-study/259279/ http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/07/scientolog...
- hudibras 14y ago"dated Jan 14, 2013. Weirdly uncritical, simple praise for a book on Scientology" Jeffrey Goldberg posted that in response to or in protest of the advertorial.
- mxxx 14y agoIt's interesting to see everybody up in arms about how The Atlantic have "crossed the line" or "gone too far" because they took cash in exchange for a blatant advertorial, as though up until yesterday they were a sterling example of journalistic integrity. If you do a little googling, https://www.google.com.au/#hl=en&q=%22theatlantic.com%2Fsponsored%22+site:theatlantic.com https://www.google.com.au/#hl=en&q=%22theatlantic.com%2F... you'll see they've been doing it for a while. article after article of complete self-serving bullshit from whoever's willing to pay. I suppose the difference here is people really love to hate Scientology (with good reason, too.)