3 ms·
It doesn't have to be "complete" public funding. I'm gonna go ahead and guess that many, many of the universities that may have partially funded the research al
by rhizome 14y ago
It doesn't have to be "complete" public funding. I'm gonna go ahead and guess that many, many of the universities that may have partially funded the research also receive tax dollars. This last part is such a huge issue here, I think. "Well it wasn't very many tax dollars..." Yeah, well let's have our share then. One download of each document that tax dollars helped pay for seems fair to me.
- mjn 14y agoI agree with that, but I'd also say openness mandates should be added to every entity that takes taxpayer funding, including, for example, Lockheed, SpaceX, and just about every pharmaceutical company.
- rhizome 14y agoWorks for me.
- rayiner 14y agoOverall, university research is about 50/50 split between public dollars and private dollars. Coincidentally, Chicago's CTA receives about 50% of its operating budget from taxes. Should I get on the next Metra train and refuse to pay the ticket price?
- sp332 14y agoLet's say a university is going to do some research. They look around for funds and decide to do a project that the government is offering some grant money for. In that case, the government's money didn't really pay for the research, it just influenced what direction it went. I think the grant money did its intended job even if the results aren't public.
- rhizome 14y agoWell, does the study use tax-paid resources or not? It may not seem workable that no private results should result from research receiving tax-money in any way, but it is fair.
- sp332 14y agoI guess what I mean is, sometimes the grant money is to "buy" the results of research, and sometimes it's just to encourage research along certain lines. Or anything else... Think of it this way: if the government requires all publicly-funded research results to be public, a lot less people are going to take them up on the deal.
- rhizome 14y agoif the government requires all publicly-funded research results to be public, a lot less people are going to take them up on the deal. Non-sequitur, and you can bet plenty of researchers will publish publicly in order to get free money. What it will affect is private industry benefitting from publicly funded research and resources.
- sp332 14y agoBut if private industry profits less from the research, they will pay less for it. Pretty quickly you will see two exclusive sets appear: a little open research funded with a little public money, and lots of proprietary research funded with lots of private money.
- rhizome 14y agoI don't think it would be as complete as you imagine. There would be companies who would forego keeping results private to save the expense of building their own lab facilities and hiring people to run and work in them. That public resources can be used for private results is a back-door subsidy for commerce.
- rhizome 14y agoif the government requires all publicly-funded research results to be public, a lot less people are going to take them up on the deal. Non-sequitur, and you can bet plenty of researchers will publish publicly in order to get free money. What it will affect is private industry benefitting from publicly funded research and resources.