3 ms·
I understand that this is "sponsoderd content" AKA an ad. I have seen "sponsored pages" in newspapers for many years about a lot of crap, is there a reason to
by riffraff 14y ago
I understand that this is "sponsoderd content" AKA an ad.
I have seen "sponsored pages" in newspapers for many years about a lot of crap, is there a reason to consider this one worse than the average?
(Yes, scientology is evil but they are not forbidden from making ads I reckon?)
edit: the "sponsored" bit is right on top of the page, as it is in dead-tree-form newspapers too.
- cheald 14y agoWhen you run sponsored content, you're tying your brand to the brand of the advertiser who you are promoting. This usually isn't a problem, since most outfits will choose to run advertising deals with well-respected brands, and both brands become stronger (and wealthier) because of the association. In this case, I can't imagine any outcome except for significant brand damage to The Atlantic. They had better have been cut an absolutely toe-curlingly-large check, because I expect they're going to pay for this in credibility loss pretty heavily.
- a_bonobo 14y agoThey are allowed to run ads, but media should allow ads based on ethical decisions - lots of countries treat Scientology as a criminal organization (Germany: "It views it as an abusive business masquerading as a religion and believes that it pursues political goals that conflict with the values enshrined in the German constitution" Source [1], another example from Belgium: [2] ) Running a sponsored article for Scientology is, to me, akin to running an article about the great employment opportunities at Mexico's Zetas. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_in_Germany [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/28/belgium-prosecutes-scientology-extortion-fraud_n_2375823.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/28/belgium-prosecutes-...
- alecperkins 14y agoThere are "stories" to the right that are really pro-Scientology ads, but not marked as "advertisement". The whole thing feels slimy, not even considering the subject.
- ohjeez 14y agoIn newspapers and magazines, sponsored content is very clearly labeled (which arguably this is) and made to look _different_. For example, most magazines require advertorial to be in a different typeface and font size, so that readers have a sense that it's somehow "different." The difficulty here is that, unlike a magazine in which you're flipping pages, you probably only saw _this_ page and thus have no sense about whether it "looks different."
- tedunangst 14y agoThen again, the only reason I saw this page is because we decided it needs to be on the top of HN. It's like the bizarro Streisand effect.
- alecdbrooks 14y agoThere is a Streisand effect-like phenomenon when notorious publicity-seekers become famous due to widespread criticism. The attention, negative or not, is exactly what they want. The biggest example is probably the Westboro Baptist Church.