6 ms·
The idea of criminalizing "computer fraud" (i.e. breaking into Amazon's servers to have it mail you expensive products without paying or to steal credit card nu
by pdonis 14y ago
The idea of criminalizing "computer fraud" (i.e. breaking into Amazon's servers to have it mail you expensive products without paying or to steal credit card numbers) is not objectionable.
What I don't understand is why we need a separate law against "computer fraud", when we already have laws against, well, fraud. In the scenario you describe, in a sane legal system, the person who broke into Amazon's servers would be prosecuted for fraud, period. The fact that the fraud was committed using computers would merely be one of the facts of the case, not a reason for an additional charge.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI agree with you. You kind of have to understand the history: The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act was passed in 1986. I don't know if you remember 1986 (I know I don't), but from what I understand from the history books, computers communicated at around 300 baud and even if you exclude the mandatory freon compressor, the amount of energy required to run a computer with processor power equivalent to the phone in your pocket would still have been measured in tons of coal per fortnight. So in 1986 they passed a law because "computers are huge corporate things used primarily by banks and governments that cost big money and don't concern common people, so fraud on a computer should have really high penalties." That's why we have a special law for it. As to whether we still need it to be a separate law from ordinary fraud... no, I don't think so.
- betterunix 14y agoMaybe in 1956 computers were "huge corporate things," but by 1986 there was a global computer network for PCs that remains popular in some parts of the world to this very day: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fidonet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fidonet
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoIn 1986 large computers were still "huge corporate things" which is almost certainly what Congress was targeting with the law rather than Fidonet (hence the trouble).
- pdonis 14y agoI don't know if you remember 1986 (I know I don't), but from what I understand from the history books, computers communicated at around 300 baud and even if you exclude the mandatory freon compressor, the amount of energy required to run a computer with processor power equivalent to the phone in your pocket would still have been measured in tons of coal per fortnight. I do remember 1986--I was in college then--and it wasn't that bad. (Though your description was very entertaining.) PCs with modems existed in the late 1970's--a friend's father had a Commodore PET at that time. Certainly by the mid-1980s, with the IBM PC and clones going strong and Apple having released several different lines including the original Macs, computers were no longer just "huge corporate things".
- malandrew 14y agoBut those were simply hobbyist things like the Arduino or Raspberry Pi are today. I find it very hard to believe that anyone in congress reponsible for drafting the CFAA were considering anything other than corporate use of computers, just like it would be hard to imagine congress taking interest in the Arduino or Raspberry Pi today and passing legislation that impacts those and other hobbyist devices and platforms.
- pdonis 14y agoHuh? The IBM-PC and clones, and the Apple II, Lisa, and Mac, were certainly not "hobbyist" computers. They were used by businesses to do spreadsheets and accounting, by artists to do graphics, and by all kinds of people to do the same sorts of basic tasks we use computers for today. (I did so myself; I had a PC clone, and my college roommate had an Apple II, and they certainly weren't "hobbyist" computers; we used them for serious work.) Even if Congress was only considering "corporate use" of computers in 1986, which is arguable, PCs and Macs were already part of "corporate use". If you want to say that Congress was too technically ignorant in 1986 to recognize that PCs and Macs counted as "real computers", that I would agree with. :-)
- anigbrowl 14y agoWhat I don't understand is why we need a separate law against "computer fraud", when we already have laws against, well, fraud. Because when that law was written it wasn't obvious how to distinguish in law between authorized and unauthorized access. You might as well ask why there's a bunch of law specifically regarding real estate when we already have laws about property, or why the laws about murder are so complex when the basic idea is 'thou shalt not kill.' As an analogy, consider the standard definition of burglary: 'Entry into a building illegally with intent to commit a crime.' Now legally, that means 4 or arguably 5 elements - entry, a building, illegality, intent, and a contemplated crime. These might seem like hair-splitting points, but they're important - not just for the immediate situation of whether someone is guilty or not guilty, but whether or not that makes them liable under a three-strikes law, perhaps years later, or deportable, or how it might affect their sentencing for a completely unrelated crime a decade later, or.... ...I mean, have you looked laws on fraud? they're complicated! It's not obvious in many real-world situations, and it's even less obvious where computers are concerned. If I am operating a computer system, how much information do I have to give you as a user about what you are or are not allowed to do on my system? Where does my responsibility end and yours begin? I mean, many people can't even understand the distinction between copyright infringement and theft, and fraud is a lot more complicated than simple theft - and theft itself is more complex than most people realize. Lots and lots of legal situations arise because people have different opinions about what sort of behavior is acceptable. I don't know if you remember a pre-internet work environment, but when I was going about in the early 90s promoting the use of email and FTP to skeptical corporate buyers, one of the most frequent questions I used to hear was 'who owns the internet?' It was quite difficult for the typical business person to conceive of how network traffic could be separated from ownership of the network infrastructure, or how any participant in a network like some kid with a modem could possibly stand on the same legal footing as the phone company or the post office.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago> when that law was written it wasn't obvious how to distinguish in law between authorized and unauthorized access. I think you have it backwards. Passing the special computer fraud law was what created the problem of not knowing how to distinguish between authorized and unauthorized access, because it made that illegal regardless of whether the "unauthorized access" (whatever that means) was actually in furtherance of any particular malicious act. It really is a profoundly stupid law. Nobody seems to be able to tell specifically what it means, and any of the plausible readings make a felony out of plenty of things that ought not to be a felony. And even the cases where unauthorized access is in furtherance of something legitimately felonious, the actually malicious thing we want to prohibit will still have to be illegal on its own, since otherwise someone with authorized access could do it and we wouldn't be able to prosecute them. Laws are complicated because you have to handle the edge cases. And there are (rarely) edge cases in some laws where adding "on a computer" can make a difference, but the way to deal with that is not to have a special computer law with disjoint elements and penalties, it's to make a minor adjustment to the existing non-computer law to take that into account.