4 ms·
> Go up to your mother and tell her a story that involves someone breaking into restricted closet at MIT, plugging into their network, evading electronic attemp
by jlgreco 14y ago
> Go up to your mother and tell her a story that involves someone breaking into restricted closet at MIT, plugging into their network, evading electronic attempts to stop him, and downloading millions of scientific articles that normally are sold for a fee. If your mother is anything like mine, she won't be able to fathom why anyone would do something like this unless he were up to no good.
You mean you can describe "crimes" in such a way that a technically naive outsider draws the knee-jerk reaction that you want? Stunning! You should be a lawyer or something.
- tptacek 14y agoHe is a lawyer.
- jlgreco 14y agoI know. Am I supposed to take it as indicative of anything particularly relevant that he thinks he could convince his mother that multiple felonies were committed here?
- tptacek 14y agoThen I don't understand your comment. Sorry.
- throwaway1 14y agoHow do we know he is a lawyer? Because his profile says so? Maybe he's like so many folks who didn't know what to do with themselves but were pampered enough to get another four years of school dayz, got a law degree, then did something else? Sorry, but saying "I'm a lawyer" and debating people doesn't mean I have to respect your views on the law.
- jlgreco 14y agoI am inclined to believe he is a lawyer. He sure sounds like one. I'll even concede him to be a better source of opinions pertaining the law than others. Of course that means fuck-all in a discussion about ethics.
- dfc 14y ago"but were pampered enough to get another four years of school dayz, got a law degree," What does your class warrior attitude have to do with anything? I'm not sure what country you are from but in the states law school is three years and the majority of students graduate with mountains of student debt. Its hardly what I would call "pampered school dayz[sic]."
- rayiner 14y agoI'm not sure what "lawyering" you think I'm doing here. Maybe I should have used "accessed a restricted closet at MIT" instead of "breaking into." Does that sound less bad to my mother: "accessing a restricted closet at MIT; plugging into their network; evading electronic attempts to stop him; downloading millions of scientific articles that are normally sold for a fee." Better? I'm going for blandly factual here. Also, what does being "technically naive" have to do with anything? Do you need to be well-versed in the technology to know that Swartz was doing something on MIT's network that MIT did not give him license to do?
- jlgreco 14y agoI am not arguing that your mother reached the wrong conclusion for that particular phrasing, I am arguing that I am unimpressed with the importance of what your mother thinks in response to any wording at all. As you know, what you omit is just as important as what you include. Now yes, if I say "JSTOR had no continued beef with Aaron", a lawyer would (correctly) respond that this hardly matters since they are not the ones expected to press charges. Does the fact that this is then legally irrelevant make it irrelevant to a member of the general public who is forming an ethical, rather than legal, opinion? Hardly. Similarly, the response you will get from, say, your mother to "evading electronic attempts to stop him" is different from the response you will hear from many people who actually know and understand exactly what that entailed. Why do you think that is? Blind loyalty to someone they probably never met? Then there is the issue of "accessing a restricted closet at MIT"/"breaks into a restricted closet at MIT". Pretty damning, even to me. Sounds like there was certainly a crime happening here. Is it important that we point out that trespassing charges were dropped? I am inclined to think so. Merits of all of these points aside, the point is that you can be factual and make a layman think whatever you want. What they conclude in response to any particular wording is entirely irrelevant. There is a reason trials involve a lot more than just having the prosecution explain the situation to their mother.
- rayiner 14y agoThe "three felonies a day" thing is based on the idea that through stretching of the law, prosecutors can target people for activity that ordinary people would consider harmless. My point is that tech people are falsely assuming that their characterization of Swartz's actions as harmless is universally shared. Without this characterization of harmlessness, the prosecutor's actions look very different. To address some of your specific points: > Now yes, if I say "JSTOR had no continued beef with Aaron" What about MIT? > Similarly, the response you will get from, say, your mother to "evading electronic attempts to stop him" is different from the response you will hear from many people who actually know and understand exactly what that entailed. Do you think ordinary people draw an ethical distinction between changing a MAC address and more complex measures? Should they? Does that change the underlying intent? > Why do you think that is? Blind loyalty to someone they probably never met? How about cultural differences? My mother thinks that smoking marijuana is seriously wrong and a danger to society. Most people in say Berkeley, CA, do not. Until relatively recently, the former opinion was more prevalent. People who frequent Hacker News do not think it's a big deal to change your MAC address to get onto a network that MIT doesn't want you to be on. That sentiment isn't universal. > Is it important that we point out that trespassing charges were dropped? I am inclined to think so. Now whose being the lawyer? Does the fact that the trespassing charges were dropped change the fact that MIT didn't want people going into that closet? All I'm trying to say is that there are two different things to you could rant about. 1) A prosecutor abusing her discretion to target someone for activity that people think are harmless. 2) Laws that don't recognize that certain kinds of network intrusions are more harmful than others. Everyone on HN is going after (1), because they are steeped in a cultural context that considers what Swartz did no different than someone cutting across a private lawn. But that sentiment is not universal, and I'd argue that it's not even common. The correct answer here is (2).