3 ms·
> Yes C# is created by Microsoft, does that make C# bad? No. Sorry to burst your bubble, but you are wrong here. It does make it bad. One should learn from hi
by shmerl 14y ago
> Yes C# is created by Microsoft, does that make C# bad? No.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but you are wrong here. It does make it bad. One should learn from history. When language is encumbered with shady copyrights and patents (yes yes, I don't think something like that should ever be patentable / copyrightable, but in practice the broken system allows it), there is always a risk it'll become a potential problem. Look at what happened to Java with Oracle's attack on Google. It's good that Google was able to brush it off, but not everyone has the same resources to do it. Yes, Microsoft "promised" they won't do something like that. But do you trust their promises? And does that promise extend to anyone who can acquire Microsoft's "rights" on C# tomorrow?
So to put it shortly - better stick to truly free languages without some weird IP strings attached. Luckily there are enough of them around.
- raverbashing 14y agoThat's exactly the kind of attitude the article is about. There are several aspects that can be analysed, yes, vendor is one, and other aspects. The world is not black or white, people can legitimately pick C# based on its merits and capabilities as it may be the best solution for them.
- shmerl 14y agoNo, the article is about the attitude of saying "it's bad because it's vendor A" without explaining the reason for it. In this case, I explained the reason. Microsoft is too entrenched in intellectual property assertion, and therefore they didn't make C# free. It's not the fault of the language or language designers. It's the fault of Microsoft. So if someone says don't use C# because it's made by MS - they are right, but they should explain what it means.
- talmand 14y agoI disagree, he isn't wrong. He isn't wrong until Microsoft does one of these bad things you automatically assume they will do. Plus, even if Microsoft did do something to make C# not viable anymore that makes Microsoft bad, not the language. For instance, if someone came along with a patent claim that somehow shut down the viability of one of your free languages, does that make the language itself bad? Now, based on the concerns you bring up there is a valid debate over whether C# is a good choice for the future, but not whether it's a bad language. You could easily say that C# is a good language but I wouldn't use it because of reasons A and B.