6 ms·
Remembering Aaron Swartz: Commons man
- ender7 14y agoThe first two sentences of this article are quick, concise, and accurate. To call Aaron Swartz gifted would be to miss the point. As far as the internet was concerned, he was the gift.
- pyre 14y agoI liked the closing too: | As Sir Tim put it, in fewer than 140 characters, "Aaron | dead. World wanderers, we have lost a wise elder. | Hackers for right, we are one down. Parents all, we | have lost a child. Let us weep." And the web wept.
- cschmidt 14y agoI don't if this is known by everyone, but the anonymous author G.F. is Glenn Fleishman.
- azernik 14y agoI find it interesting that the Economist managed to figure out that Swartz's cause was open access to public documents, while the New York Times (even in a second article published today) is still writing about him as a purist all-information-must-be-free ideologue.
- ghshephard 14y agoThis would be Glenn Fleishman who figured it out. He's one of us. Has an awesome twitter feed @GlennF.
- brudgers 14y agoThe Economist writes spectacular obituaries. The editors work on them to fine polish - Ray Bradbury's was in development for many weeks before seeing publication. On the one hand, I was surprised that Swartz was the subject this week. On the other, it comes as no surprise. Ink has been devoted to what it takes to be worthy of a New York Times obituary. That Aaron Swartz's death made the Economist speaks to the deep impact that his life's work has had.
- mmakunas 14y agoThe Economist obits are indeed wonderful. It's almost always the first thing I read in it. But, as a point of clarification, this article is not the weekly obit. It's part of the Babbage blog. It remains to be seen if something about him will make the print edition.
- saryant 14y agoI don't think this is their "official" obit for Swartz. This article was published under one of their online blogs, not their printed obits section. However I suspect that within a few weeks such an article will appear. http://www.economist.com/obituaries http://www.economist.com/obituaries
- gojomo 14y agoAaron's interest in the freedom to share information went beyond just 'open access to public documents'. See for example: http://bits.are.notabug.com/ http://bits.are.notabug.com/ The 'Guerrilla Open Access Manifesto', also, does not limit its sights to just those materials that are traditionally, or commonly understood to be, "public documents", but to the "the world’s entire scientific and cultural heritage". http://pastebin.com/cefxMVAy http://pastebin.com/cefxMVAy With no legal case remaining to win, Aaron's views don't need moderating spin.
- azernik 14y agoThe whole quote is "The world’s entire scientific and cultural heritage, published over centuries in books and journals...". He then goes on to talk exclusively about academic publishing in the rest of the manifesto. Even the title - "Guerilla Open Access Manifesto" - refers to a very specific movement in favor of freely available ("Open Access") academic journals.
- gojomo 14y agoI think your reading of the Manifesto misses the forest for a tree. Scientific papers or the even smaller set of 'public documents' were not the whole program, just a useful (and especially moderate and academically respectable) 1st step. The whole program is opposing all "laws that restrict what bits I can put on my website". As the wordplay joke at the bottom of the "Bits are not a bug" page notes, "Attorney General's Warning: This page advocates advocacy of the violent overthrow of the United States Government."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- temuze 14y agoIt's humbling to be in my twenties and read about someone who had done so much at an even younger age.
- DennisP 14y agoEven more humbling to be in my forties, still not having done so much.
- Volpe 14y agoIt's also impossible, we have all "done" the same amount in the same amount of time (that's how existence works). We just do different things, some of which society rewards more than others.
- wglb 14y agoNever too late to start.
- lkgj 14y agoIt's like you're all almost purposely going out of your way to misrepresent what Aaron was. He should be remembered as a well-meaning, curious dreamer, someone who later in his short life wanted to organize others politically for the public good. An unusually sensitive everyman. He's being portrayed instead as a technical genius or some other kind of elite. He always sought to be involved in technology, but he never really accomplished anything technological; he did not invent RSS or even work on what people think of when they hear RSS. (His involvement was with a minor offshoot of the real 'RSS.') He contributed almost nothing to Reddit. He wrote a few minor open-source libraries, like thousands of others. I do not mean any of that as a criticism; obviously most people don't achieve much new technologically. The key here isn't "genius" but "public-spirited." Not "analytical power" but "playfulness." Not Gandalf but Frodo. Of course, his death is a horrible tragedy. It is even moreso a horrible tragedy if it actually resulted from the JSTOR incident, rather than from personal pressures he felt or from mental illness. The JSTOR stunt accomplished nothing. It would barely have helped anyone. It was purely symbolic. That is one reason the prosecution of him was so misguided, but it is also seemingly leading to a majorly misguided reaction by people who really have no idea what they're talking about. This caricature of him after his death feels grotesque and manipulative. Lessig and others should be ashamed of themselves. You should try to remember people for what they were, not convert a very understandable grief at an interesting, sensitive, and troubled person's suicide into a simplistic political cause. I say none of this to be harsh. The groupthink here is scary, though, and I do not recall seeing it here before. I'm cowardly posting this under a new username because I'm actually afraid of the mob mentality I'm seeing.
- tosser23 14y agoI agree with everything here. Most of what I've read approaches hagiography. I can't help but wonder if some of the fawning praise heaped upon him, and his elevation to a hero partaking in an epic battle between Good and Evil was no less a contribution to his death than the supposed bullying of the prosecutor.
- wglb 14y agoA little reading might show you that folks have been saying this for a long time. For starters read all of his blog.