5 ms·
We really need to change the laws as they relate to computer crime and copyright.
by rdl 14y ago
We really need to change the laws as they relate to computer crime and copyright.
- tptacek 14y agoI do not agree. Beyond that, I worry that what geeks hope for is a situation where the plain language of the law protects them from "overcharging". That's never going to happen. A zealous prosecutor is going to be able to make your life miserable no matter what. That's the problem we need to address. Count me among those who think what Swartz did could reasonably have been charged as a felony, but should never have been charged as multiple felonies. Swartz' attorneys tried to arrange a plea deal and were told that Swartz would need to cop to all thirteen felonies, and would still serve prison time. If all we know now is all there is to the story, that's a gross abuse on the part of Stephen Heymann's office.
- rdl 14y agoI would like to see some element of malice, profit, or real and reasonably expected destructiveness in intrusion as a separate crime, and thus separate sentencing guidelines, similar to degrees of murder or assault. The problem with prosecutorial discretion is sometimes you end up with abuses like this. Having at least an order of magnitude written into the law would go a long way. I think this was essentially on the line as a felony vs. serious misdemeanor. 1-3 year range, tops, and probably something which should have gotten a suspended sentence for that period, as well.
- tptacek 14y agoRegarding the addition of "malice" to some successor of the CFAA: the prosecution could have charged malice; there was clear enough evidence that Swartz's goal was to harm JSTOR. A malice requirement would have made the case harder to win, but the tragedy here isn't how hard this case was to win. Aaron's attorney, who at this moment is motivated to make the strongest possible case for the hardship Aaron faced, says he believes Swartz (a) could have beaten the charges as they stood and (b) was very unlikely to get more than a suspended sentence even if he hadn't. I think there's broad agreement that Swartz both shouldn't have and was unlikely to serve time as a result of this case. Which brings me back to Heymann and the conduct of the prosecution, which seems to have been hell-bent on scaring the crap out Swartz.
- rdl 14y agoThat seems like a reasonable argument. I mailed his attorney a couple days ago. Part of the tragedy is his attorney would have won this case. Maybe what is needed is some kind of "legal counselor" to guide defendants in cases like this. Especially if a defendant is irrational or depressed, it's probably an inherently hellish process.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>Maybe what is needed is some kind of "legal counselor" to guide defendants in cases like this. And then we could put them in an office and call it something like the public defender's office. ;) Of course, then having them do their jobs would be expensive and no one wants to pay to help "criminals" so it would end up chronically underfunded and become unable to properly serve its clients.
- jacquesm 14y agoBut he'd still be bankrupt even if he beat these charges. That defending yourself and winning could still ruin your life is something else that is terribly wrong here. After all, that means that guilty or not you're going to be punished, and punished hard.
- jacquesm 14y ago> If all we know now is all there is to the story, that's a gross abuse on the part of Stephen Heymann's office. And there you were saying we never agree on anything... you may have to re-visit that position. Now where we dis-agree is the bit where you think that what Swartz did could have been charged as a felony. This side-steps the question of intent and that is normally a big part of any criminal suit.
- tptacek 14y agoTowards intent: Swartz published a manifesto urging people to work against the interests of closed academic publishing, then repeatedly evaded attempts to prevent him from downloading bulk JSTOR articles from MIT's network.
- jacquesm 14y agoYes, but that is positive intent, not negative intent. What better use of ones time than to make the worlds knowledge more freely available, especially to those not privileged with university access to those articles? The interests of closed academic publishing are not aligned with those of the general public.
- tptacek 14y agoThe intent to harm JSTOR is by definition malice.
- jacquesm 14y agoThere is such a thing as the 'common good', and I believe it could be successfully argued that harming JSTOR while improving the situation of everybody but JSTOR is an examplary case to show positive intent rather than a malicious one. JSTOR is a non-profit entity that has significant amounts of funds revolving through it and that is technically tasked with making material available, but that in actual fact makes it scarce. Any attempts to break such a situation and to improve the status quo for the common good is not malicious by definition, it is beneficial by definition. I see how you favor a much more literal interpretation of the word 'intent' here, but I'm talking about it the way a human would talk about it, and not some kind of legal AI. After all, we're all human first and our intent derives from our humanity and if there is a corporate interest that is harmed over a humanitarian one than I for one don't see too much harm there. We're not talking about someone attempting to wreck the entertainment industry, we're talking about someone attempting to enable a large number of people to gain access to knowledge. Equating that with malicious intent because some faceless corporation might no longer have as much access to the gravy train is difficult for me to understand.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>Beyond that, I worry that what geeks hope for is a situation where the plain language of the law protects them from "overcharging". That's never going to happen. A zealous prosecutor is going to be able to make your life miserable no matter what. That's the problem we need to address. I don't know if overcharging is an unsolvable problem. "Plain language" may not be the right approach, but taking the excessive breadth and poor wording out of existing legislation would go a long way toward removing the number of felony counts a prosecutor can "legitimately" charge a typical bystander with. Here are a couple of examples: A lot of these laws have threshold amounts of property that have to be in question before someone can be guilty of the crime. (And the amounts haven't been adjusted for inflation in several decades, which we could easily fix too.) But the real trouble there is that we take the amounts and then shovel a whole bunch of questionable nonsense into what can qualify. If I'm reading Prof. Kerr's analysis correctly, if someone breaks into your computer and you hire someone to clean it up, that goes in. You're paying them, so just pay them enough to hit the threshold and you've made a felon of the accused. It seems the value of intangible works goes in, so you bring in the copyright mathematicians who say one copy of one work is worth $150,000, which makes that element of the charge totally redundant in virtually every single case involving a computer, because all computers do is send data to one another, and virtually all data is copyrighted, so you copy one work and it exceeds the threshold and you're guilty of a felony. So let's take the ability to count all of that sort of thing out of that requirement and only include actual cash money or tangible physical products with specific market values, and if you want to have criminal copyright statutes or trade secret misappropriation statutes with appropriate penalties then let them be separate from statutes originally intended to deal with fraud and sabotage. Then we can get rid of the vagueness. "Unauthorized access" is nonsense words. If someone is guilty of fraud, charge them with fraud. If someone is guilty of copyright infringement, sue them. If someone accesses a computer without authorization and hasn't committed any other offense whatsoever, use technological measures to prevent future access and don't charge them with anything. Furthermore, we can do something about the maximum penalties. 35 years is insane. It's insane for actual hardened criminals -- bank robbers often go to jail for five years. Murder is on the order of 25 to life. We can make the maximum penalty for any computer crime that isn't also a serious non-computer crime something like 364 days. Is that the sort of thing you mean to do to check over-zealous prosecutors, or did you have something else in mind? Because I'm open to suggestions. And we can do both.