6 ms·
Note, the PACER incident is not the direct reason why Aaron was in the legal trouble he was in, that was his downloading of JSTOR's material, which under the la
by btilly 14y ago
Note, the PACER incident is not the direct reason why Aaron was in the legal trouble he was in, that was his downloading of JSTOR's material, which under the law clearly illegal.
However there is widespread speculation that the PACER incident was behind why prosecutors may have wanted to throw the book at Aaron.
- rdtsc 14y agoPresumably it was the incident that left a bruise in the govt's eye and they never forgot it. But that is speculation, we don't know of course (even as tax payers who bankroll this crap) what goes into decision and who decides how and to what level of fervor cases get prosecuted.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mikehotel 14y agoWhat do those speculators say about the former Chief Technologist at the US FTC [1] leading the team behind RECAP [2]? 1. http://techventures.columbia.edu/news/professor-bellovin-named-ftc-s-chief-technologist http://techventures.columbia.edu/news/professor-bellovin-nam... 2. https://www.recapthelaw.org/about/ https://www.recapthelaw.org/about/
- mikehotel 14y agoIt appears the Administrative Office deemed RECAP ok, while at the same time prohibiting "fee exempt PACER users" from sharing content [1]. That is a fine line. 1. http://www.pacer.gov/announcements/general/exemptnotice.html http://www.pacer.gov/announcements/general/exemptnotice.html
- kamkazemoose 14y agoJust a note, but it's possible what Aaron did actually was legal. There was an article [1] by an expert witness in the case posted earlier today. So I think the trial would have been revealing. Admittedly the article doesn't prove anything, but I think everyone has so far been assuming Aaron's guilt. And while there is no denying the acts that he committed, they may have been legal. 1. http://io9.com/5975592/aaron-swartz-died-innocent-++-here-is-the-evidence http://io9.com/5975592/aaron-swartz-died-innocent-++-here-is...
- smackfu 14y agoA bit of a tautology there: If the expert witness that was on Aaron's side wasn't planning to testify he was not guilty... he wouldn't be the expert witness on Aaron's side.
- cma 14y agoI don't think it was supposed to be an argument from authority.
- nmcfarl 14y agoBut that doesn't mean the expert witness is wrong.
- smackfu 14y agoNo, it just means he's not the impartial expert on the facts that some seem to be imagining him to be. I'm sure the prosecution had an expert witness who could have written a post saying "Aaron would have been found guilty."
- AnIrishDuck 14y agoFor what it's worth, the expert we're talking about stated in his post that he usually testified against hackers. He explained what he thought was different in Aaron's case in his post.
- nmcfarl 14y agoTrue. But if we assume everyone put on the stand in a trial is a paid shill, lieing for one side or the other, we also have to assume that that the court system is a sham and there's no point in a trial. I'd rather assume that we can find smart, honest experts who happen to disagree, and that we can trust what they are saying to be their view of reality.
- kamkazemoose 14y agoI agree, it isn't a definitive source proving that Aaron was innocent. My main point was that btilly said it was "clearly illegal". And I've seen that point reiterated multiple times. Nearly every article I've seen has assumed his quilt. So I just wanted to point out that there is another side.
- hobbyhacker 14y agoAaron was also a vocal critic of the Obama administration, specifically the 'kill lists'.