7 ms·
This is the same guy who claims Facebook was his idea, and tried to get Facebook's trademark revoked: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/04/17/greenspan_harvard
by tlrobinson 18y ago
This is the same guy who claims Facebook was his idea, and tried to get Facebook's trademark revoked:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/04/17/greenspan_harvard_faceboog_trademark_battle/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/04/17/greenspan_harvard_fa...
- tjogin 18y ago- I have a super unique idea that nobody has thought of before: an online community where you can connect with friends, send messages and stuff. Keep a lid on it though, I don't want this never-thought-of-before idea to get out!!! (Ideas are worthless. Execution is all that matters.)
- jibiki 18y agoI've never understood all the AG hate on this site. I can see how you could pity the guy, or dismiss him out of hand, but a lot of people on this site seem to hold genuine malice towards him. It's bizzare.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- fallentimes 18y ago>I can see how you could pity the guy, or dismiss him out of hand I think more people would feel that way if legal action wasn't involved. Suits & lawsuits tend to leave a bad taste in people's mouths...
- jpwagner 18y agoWhat's really strange is that all this hate gets so much positive karma. Anytime I post something like these guys, I get blasted into the negative. I'd be curious to know the general thought on how often it's appropriate to get yourself into these types of legal issues. (AG seems to have a pretty loose trigger finger when it comes to serving papers.)
- Herring 18y agoThey're entrepreneurs here, or at least they identify with entrepreneurs. I think it makes perfect sense.
- thinkcomp 18y agoThis makes no sense, actually. I incorporated my company in 1998, so if entrepreneurs always identify with other entrepreneurs, then... Aaron
- Herring 18y agoAll the more reason for them to hate you, backstabbing cockbite. See now even I dislike you a little & I'm not an entrepreneur :)
- tjogin 18y agoI don't even have an opinion on AG. I'm just saying that having "the idea of Facebook", and that you were the first to have that, is retarded. First of all, it's a really really old idea. Second of all, the idea is irrelevant. What made Facebook succeed was the execution. That goes for most of the other online successes as well. Selling books online, or search, aren't novel ideas. Amazon and Google, too, succeeded because of execution. They all did.
- axod 18y agoSuing Facebook because you 'came up with the idea'? Writing a "tell all" book and trying to sell it? Blatently violating the Google TOS, and then suing them because they wouldn't tell you what part of the TOS you violated? That's 3 pretty big reasons.
- zasz 18y agoHe must have his fans, too. Many of his comments have high karma scores, and apparently people like this article he wrote and submitted. I can see why they might not be terribly vocal in the face of all these people willing to be negative, though.
- redrobot5050 18y agoBig same. Bucknell University, where I worked as a teenager on their computer help desk, had an electronic facebook that all the techies jokingly referred to as "Stalker.net". That was 1998. I don't know when Friendster launched, but i know people who've had profiles since 2002, so again, a "social networking site" had already been done and launched.
- kragen 18y agoAlso: sixdegrees.com.
- thinkcomp 18y agoTom, I don't think we've ever met, and I'm not sure what I ever did to you to merit repeated disdainful (and in this case, misleading) jabs in public forums, but I actually think 280 North is really cool and I look forward to seeing where Atlas goes. In the meantime, my so-called claims (which are narrow and do not include the wild notion that I "invented social networking," but do involve execution and not merely an "idea") were verified by The New York Times and are publicly available for inspection, so they're really facts. The trademark dispute is in the middle of discovery right now, and ironically, there are posts on this thread that support my case--so "tried" wouldn't be the best word to use, either. Anyway, if you want to selectively link to only articles that call me names, that's your prerogative. Aaron
- fallentimes 18y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/01/technology/01facebook.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/01/technology/01facebook.html
- tlrobinson 18y agoSorry if it was misleading. I just thought it was interesting to note, given your history of legal action. As for the link, it was one of the top hits on Google for whatever I searched for at the time.
- gojomo 18y agoMy (very low) opinion of your claims is not based on any Register article, but your own written account of your dealings with Zuckerberg, on p. 294 and up of your book Authoritas, a section I read when you had it online. I commented with my unvarnished opinion long before your Facebook lawsuit [1]. Congratulations on your small-claims win against an unprepared Google paralegal; Google should be held to account for cryptic and arbitrary policies that retract credited balances from users' accounts. However, in your own writings and lawsuits, you give me the impression that you are a legal gadfly rather than an entrepreneur. That can be a fine niche in life, and the press loves it, but you shouldn't expect a warm reception from aspiring entrepreneurs. Successful businesspeople often have to waste precious time and money defending against, and sometimes even paying off, legal gadflies -- even when the claims are meritless. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49294 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49294
- gdee 18y agoIs there any relevance to that tidbit in this context? ... thought not. Ad-hominem ftw.
- gdee 18y ago-2? Wow. For educational purposes, could those who down voted my comment provide an explanation. I mean... the linked article was about Google and a closed account... and someone seems to remember some Facebook thing and tossed it in, presumably to discredit the subject from the start. If those are not the very definition of OT and ad-hominem, what are they? No biggie, I care little about karma, but I would like to know why?
- pg 18y agoI would guess the combination of heavy sarcastic tone and light information content.