4 ms·
The fragmented community doesn't matter. At all, really. It just requires that one group (Canonical, Redhat, whoever) put their guns behind what they provide an
by zanny 14y ago
The fragmented community doesn't matter. At all, really. It just requires that one group (Canonical, Redhat, whoever) put their guns behind what they provide and try getting that into the market.
While having more developers would help the individual efforts, having other people rebuilding the same thing doesn't hurt the individual projects. It hurts the ecosystem to have excessive duplication (and I don't know why I can list 3 dozen window managers or file browsers but can't name one good non-linear video editor) but the success of any single distribution doesn't depend on everyone else getting behind it.
I think the comment is actually pretty accurate in relation to the non-geek - the problem has nothing to do with developer fragmentation. Consumers don't care about that. The reason desktop Linux doesn't take off is because Grandma doesn't walk into Best Buy and see an Ubuntu laptop, they see Windows. And every computer 99% of consumers will buy will be from a store, carrying Windows of some flavor.
They won't go out of their way looking for a competing OS, or how to install it. As soon as the thing boots into Windows, you have lost them, because they won't change anything. And you can't try teaching them, because Windows has won for them - the device works, hence nothing has to change. Internet Explorer shows emails, even if it is slow, I don't know what "security vulnerabilities" are, or why developers hate it (and why do I care? they already rewrite the site to work in 10 year old non-standards compliant web browsers anyway).
Linux will get widespread adoption the day it is the default. Because it honestly does work, when you take the time to tailor the hardware to it. System76 or a Dell Ubuntu laptop are as far as you need to go to see that in effect - they work out of the box because the engineers tailored the device to the OS. Like they all do with Windows already.
The problem with Ubuntu, though, is that it is too different. It doesn't look like Windows 7 (or, for a lot of people, XP still). Instantly, nobody likes it. They want the same thing, better. Not something different. They don't want change, or to have to learn or read. They want to read their kids facebook posts. And you can't blame them for that.