13 ms·
The Nightmare That Keeps Microsoft Awake: Android On The Desktop
- petrel 14y agoJust a hot headline. Nothing will happen. Whether, Android on Surface or Winodws / Ubuntu on Nexus or something else on some other device. There is more world than just what Geeks do. Just a catchy headline and author have no any justified reason for it.
- digitalengineer 14y agoBut there is something to it: Linux could use some Google attention and to make Android/Linux run on laptops would be something Microsoft fears if it catches on. The Samsung ChromeBook is the best selling laptop for Amazon http://www.amazon.com/Best-Sellers-Computers-Accessories-Laptop/zgbs/pc/565108 http://www.amazon.com/Best-Sellers-Computers-Accessories-Lap... Why make Chrome OS and Android? Put the effort in Android for desktop...
- kenjackson 14y agoAt one point WP7 devices dominated the Amazon cell phone list in terms of sales. Due to the way people purchase and buy certain items (like desktops, laptops, and cellphones) -- Amazon is not a good sample. It tends to reflect niche groups that find a good deal on Amazon -- so everyone from ChromeLovers.com goes to Amazon to buy the Chromebook, but it's not really popular beyond that. "Linux could use some Google attention" -- I'm not sure if you noticed, but Google has been giving Linux its attention for the past 14 years.
- digitalengineer 14y agoYou've got me. I ment to say Linux/Android for regular desktopusers could use some attention. MS has released their own version of Mobile/Desktop. What if Google went the other way around and released an Android desktop version? Powerful stuff me thinks.
- zanny 14y agoWhy would they try to force an entire application stack that has nothing to do with windowing or full opengl and try to put it on x86? The people who don't need desktops or laptops are already using ipads and Android tablets as computing replacements. They get their web apps and that is all they want. To write emails, they might get a bluetooth keyboard. To write a document, they might use google docs. They have no use case for a full sized x86 desktop or laptop anymore. Meanwhile, productivity software like Photoshop or Sony Vegas is completely off the table for Android. Both depend on directX, and unless Google outright bought Adobe or Sony they wouldn't persuade them to rewrite the whole thing to port it. That stuff won't show up on Windows RT either, even though porting with DirectX intact would still be easier than porting to openGL. Same thing with old games. If Android x86 or just desktop ARM were put in stores tomorrow, no one would buy it. Gamers would get Windows for games, artists would get Windows for photoshop, grandparents would still buy tablets because they don't need a desktop, and businesses would still get Windows because all their shoddy business applications were written on Windows.
- martinced 14y ago"Just a hot headline. Nothing will happen." By that logic wouldn't we all still be using series S40 Nokia phones and Windows laptop?
- fatbird 14y agoWhenever I speculate with colleagues on what replaces Windows in businesses in five years, it's a Dell or HP machine that's just monitor, keyboard and mouse, running an upsized version of Android that accesses a cloud based office suite. That would keep me up at night, at MS.
- Joeri 14y agoIf it runs office, they'll still make their dime on it. Ah and look what we have here: http://www.theverge.com/2012/11/7/3612422/microsoft-office-mobile-ipad-iphone-android-screenshots http://www.theverge.com/2012/11/7/3612422/microsoft-office-m... They might still do ok on the corporate desktop. Windows rt is competitive with android in functionality and price (when you look only at the sort of tablets corporations would buy.) The lack of apps is not a showstopper for tablets that will be locked down anyway. Also, the PC market is getting replaced largely with tablets, so PC vendors who aren't big players in the tablet space face an uphill battle. HP is done for. Dell has some tablet expertise, and betting on windows 8 is smart in case it succeeds, but they will have to fight hard to not be driven out of the market by asus, samsung and google.
- fatbird 14y agoReplacing Office is really the fatal blow, and that's where I wonder when we'll see someone like Dell or HP selling a cheap, business class iMac-like running Android on Arm in an effort to restore margins on high volume business channel sales. The obvious drop-in replacement in that case is Google Apps, and I'm sure Google would be happy to partner with an OEM to develop such a complete device. The trick there is that the OEM needs to feel like MS won't or can't crush them. The aura of invulnerability of MS has to be broken, and when I look at the extended pratfall that is Windows phone and tablet, I can't help but think that OEM execs are feeling a bit drooly.
- rprasad 14y agoAside from the collaboration functionality which is now present in Office 2013, Google Apps is about where Office was in 2000. It has a long way to go before it is a suitable replacement for anything except the simplest business uses.
- jelled 14y agoIn case anyone wants to run Android on their desktop today check out androvm: http://androvm.org/blog/download/ http://androvm.org/blog/download/. It runs much faster then the emulator that comes with the android SDK.
- VLM 14y agoA couple years ago I installed androidx86 on an old netbook. Works pretty well. http://www.android-x86.org/ http://www.android-x86.org/
- keithwarren 14y agoThis is what happens when authors have quotas. They fill space. No analysis, no research. No facts even, would not have taken but a few minutes to pull data and do a juxtaposition on market shares of desktop PCs and the move to tablets in the consumer space. The sad thing is, that guy got paid to write those words.
- RexRollman 14y agoI agree. This was a horrible article.
- maskedinvader 14y agoI agree, not sure the author knows what he is talking about ! not a single number or research study result or even a trivia to support his claim, Mobile OSes simply aren't designed for using the PC hardware ! A claim I can make by simply looking at the Android SDK/ iOS SDK / windows phone SDK, none of them truly can match up to what windows sdk has to offer !
- neya 14y agoI am an hardcore Android fan. But this is too much of a stretch. I've been using Windows since Windows 95. I use OSX too, of course. And then Ubuntu too - 10.04 LTS, 12.04, and 12.10. As for smartphones - 4 HTC phones with Android 2.3+, an iPhone and a Nokia Lumia. But, even if today Google releases Android for the desktop, I wouldn't use it (as my main OS). Atleast not now. There are somethings that are hard-coded within users like me. No matter what we do, we will go back to windows, no matter how bad it is - be it Vista or Longhorn or whatever. Because that's the influence of Windows. Bill gates made sure Windows and PC's are in harmony with each other right from the beginning. The number of applications, the vibrant developer community and the number of epic GAMES! You may not notice this pattern within the US where you will encounter a lot of people on OSX. But the rest of the world, which is the majority, loves Windows. It's not going to be like one fine day someone comes in and says hey, you know what, Android's there for desktop, so you can stop using Windows. That will never happen. One main reason is the enormous developer community and applications available for Windows. Not to forget the fact that Windows is the #1 most pirated OS of all time ESPECIALLY in countries like China, India, etc. which is where the majority of the population lives (#1, #2 respectively). This means, if you take into account all the pirated copies too, the user base is enormous and it only keeps growing with each day. Because that was Bill Gates' vision and he has actually accomplished it. By no means I'm an MSFT 'fanboy'. This is just from what I know, what I observe around me, based on some analytical data derived from my business. In other words, this article is a fluff.
- Joeri 14y agoChina may love windows, but they love ipads more. Tablet sales are booming and pc sales are falling. http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/28/us-china-tablet-market-idUSBRE8AR04K20121128 http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/28/us-china-tablet-ma... http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/08/31/apac_pc_sales_decline_china_loss/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/08/31/apac_pc_sales_declin...
- w1ntermute 14y agoA lot of Chinese people buy Apple products just to show them off. It's quite common there to buy a Mac and install Windows on it, because they don't like OS X.
- nicholassmith 14y agoWould a medium to large business go Android over Windows? I really, really doubt it. Yes, there's Office apps and that's fine, but a lot of businesses run on oddball software or strange marriages of various bits and pieces that are Windows only for whatever reason. They won't, and that'll keep the cash going for Microsoft. Microsoft needs to worry about being relevant with modern consumers, not about Android. It could be anything that'll eat their marketshare.
- bdcravens 14y agoIndeed. Business sales will continue. I certainly don't plan on running Android as the base OS on a development machine. I'm failing to find recent statistics, but I've seen numbers that indicate that 80%+ of licenses for Office are the Home and Student editions. (Even so, the higher cost of business versions makes this a less relevant statistic) No matter what, Microsoft still relies heavily on sales to home and college users. Windows 8 has a definite non-business interface.
- martinced 14y agoBut large businesses represents less than 50% of the GDP (of either the U.S. or Europe). Contrarily to popular belief the real backbone of the economy is not "corporate america". They're just very vocal. Think of it this way: BlackBerry was still ruling king in the corporate world (with some companies buying thousands of BlackBerries at once for their employees) and yet everybody knew the writing was on the wall: nothing would stop the iPhone and Android. What's the result now? Employees are crying to use their iPhone and Android phones at work and so they're allowed to. I'm sure, say, corporate America is still high on Excel and Powerpoint and Exchange... But that is not exactly helping Microsoft deal with the fact that year-to-year sales of PCs worlwide have dropped 3.5% from 2011 to 2012 while, meanwhile, smartphones and tablets sales have skyrocketed.
- nicholassmith 14y agoOh I know that, but whilst the count for less than 50% of GDP they're also one of the biggest customer sectors for Microsoft, and one that is unlikely to dry up and disappear. They'll have a market there for as long as the market is there, and that's dependent on enterprise developers wanting to move development platforms to whatever the new hotness is. For consumers it's all a 'it depends'. It depends on whether it's good enough, rather than whether it does everything they could ever possibly need to.
- kmfrk 14y agoMarco (hate him or love him) nailed the criticism of this a few years back: The joke of “next year will be the year of Linux on the desktop” is almost as old as the internet, but it’s true: desktop-Linux fans always say it’s “getting better”, and there’s always a major distribution update a few months away that’s about to be awesome. But it never is. And it never will be, because the reasons why desktop Linux isn’t awesome today will still hold tomorrow: it’s still an extremely fragmented development community for which the non-geek user experience is one of the lowest priorities. Read the whole thing: http://www.marco.org/2010/07/04/great-since-day-one http://www.marco.org/2010/07/04/great-since-day-one. EDIT: I resubmitted it, because it is as relevant then as it is now: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5051152 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5051152.
- zanny 14y agoThe fragmented community doesn't matter. At all, really. It just requires that one group (Canonical, Redhat, whoever) put their guns behind what they provide and try getting that into the market. While having more developers would help the individual efforts, having other people rebuilding the same thing doesn't hurt the individual projects. It hurts the ecosystem to have excessive duplication (and I don't know why I can list 3 dozen window managers or file browsers but can't name one good non-linear video editor) but the success of any single distribution doesn't depend on everyone else getting behind it. I think the comment is actually pretty accurate in relation to the non-geek - the problem has nothing to do with developer fragmentation. Consumers don't care about that. The reason desktop Linux doesn't take off is because Grandma doesn't walk into Best Buy and see an Ubuntu laptop, they see Windows. And every computer 99% of consumers will buy will be from a store, carrying Windows of some flavor. They won't go out of their way looking for a competing OS, or how to install it. As soon as the thing boots into Windows, you have lost them, because they won't change anything. And you can't try teaching them, because Windows has won for them - the device works, hence nothing has to change. Internet Explorer shows emails, even if it is slow, I don't know what "security vulnerabilities" are, or why developers hate it (and why do I care? they already rewrite the site to work in 10 year old non-standards compliant web browsers anyway). Linux will get widespread adoption the day it is the default. Because it honestly does work, when you take the time to tailor the hardware to it. System76 or a Dell Ubuntu laptop are as far as you need to go to see that in effect - they work out of the box because the engineers tailored the device to the OS. Like they all do with Windows already. The problem with Ubuntu, though, is that it is too different. It doesn't look like Windows 7 (or, for a lot of people, XP still). Instantly, nobody likes it. They want the same thing, better. Not something different. They don't want change, or to have to learn or read. They want to read their kids facebook posts. And you can't blame them for that.
- raganwald 14y agoNot a great article, but I'll play along. If it happens, I don;t see Android on the desktop. I see android tablets replacing desktops in the future, with people docking a tablet or perhaps they're cheap enough that people have a 15" tablet more-or-less permanently docked at their desk but able to roam into a meeting, along with a 7" tablet in their briefcase or purse. And a phone, of course.
- rbanffy 14y agoI can easily see Android brains built into every monitor and TV. TVs already have reasonable brains and most of them run Linux. From that to running Android (and bringing a whole app ecosystem along) is a small step (some extra DRAM, some extra flash). When every monitor runs a full Android environment, you may just log on to your monitor and have your Google-hosted data and applications ready. For Microsoft, this is not only a nightmare scenario. It's a doomsday scenario.
- johngalt 14y agoThe future looks like a smartphone and docking station. The phones already have the horsepower needed to run all but the most demanding apps. Add a full size keyboard/monitor when in dock and people will switch in droves. The only question is which of the big three will get the formula right. Apple would have the best shot if that was their direction, but they seem to be betting on multiple device sync rather that a single unified device. Also they will be too pricey in the long run. Microsoft is pushing for a unified device vision with win8 but windows phone doesn't have market share. Win7 is good enough for desktop users. Clock is ticking and MS needs a 'hit' crossover device. Doubtful that we will see one. Google already has desktop mode for android devices and several phones with HDMI output. Motorola and Samsung are making docking kits today. Also android is by far the cheapest option. The only thing holding back Google is a lack of salesmanship. If Steve Jobs had announced the Galaxy Note 2 and demoed the dock/desktop functions this market would be locked up already.
- keithwarren 14y agoThis assumes the future needs a docking station. Which assumes a keyboard and mouse are still the tools interaction. I won't concede that they are. People in our business are a bit myopic because you HAVE to have a keyboard to code; that may not be true for everyone else. Granted that is what we are used to, but rewind a decade and no one was talking about playing games without a handheld controller.
- graue 14y agojohngalt didn't mention a mouse, you did. I think when we get larger touchscreens the mouse may indeed become obsolete. (I'm looking forward to it; I never had any love for that form of input.) But a keyboard will continue to be useful for anyone who has to write more than 2 paragraphs in a sitting. That's most office workers. Also, a reporter, marketer, investor or designer (to name a few example non-code jobs) can hardly do their work on a 3 to 4 inch screen.
- jackalope 14y agoVoice recognition and predictive text have progressed very well. Despite the challenges posed by group settings, there are plenty of people who would turn to dictation if it freed them from the tyranny of the keyboard ("You want me to type 2 paragraphs? By hand?").
- justinph 14y agoCan we please stop linking to forbes.com? They hardly post anything that isn't un-researched trollbait, inflated hype, or outright plagiarism.
- gillianseed 14y agoHmmm.. isn't the problem that Windows 8 is facing at the moment that the consumers are rejecting the notion of a mobile style interface on the desktop? Why retool Android for 'desktop use' when they already have ChromeOS which apparently sold very well this christmas in the guise of Chromebook's and is already a desktop oriented OS.
- mdasen 14y agoGoogle and Apple have both found great success in phones while Microsoft has floundered and so the article logically asks, "what's to stop Google and Apple from carving up the desktop (including laptop) space as they have with phones?" The key is inertia. While Microsoft may have had a mobile OS before Apple or Google, it never really caught on. There was no inertia in the smartphone space. When Apple came along with iOS, almost no one had a smartphone. Apple didn't have to convince users to switch from a mobile platform they already felt was ok. Similarly, even when Android entered, the majority of people didn't have to be convinced to switch. Most people didn't have a smartphone. Most people do have a desktop. They've invested years of time learning Windows and have applications specifically written for it. Desktop Linux has been around for years and hasn't made a dent in Windows. Why would a new desktop Linux distribution change that? In many ways Android Desktop would be inferior to most desktop Linux distributions because it would be launching with few, if any, apps. Android has many mobile apps, but just like iOS and OS X, we would really need separate apps for both. Google could provide a Linux with Android APIs just as Apple shares much of Cocoa between iOS and OS X. However, traditional linux distributions are quite usable (my complaints about Gnome 3 and Unity aside) and they haven't made much of a dent in Windows. If people don't want those, why would they want Desktop Android? Branding might help. People might hear Android and think, "oh, I've heard of that or used that before". Still, the "Windows" brand hasn't been helping Microsoft counter Google and Apple in the mobile space. In fact, looking at the mobile space, we can see how important inertia is. Despite coming out with a quite good mobile OS and getting Nokia to commit to exclusivity, that combined force just can't make a dent in consumer inertia toward iOS and Android. Even if Google came out with a premium desktop OS with the Android brand that people know and love, would users change their inertia? It just seems less likely to me. In mobile, Google and Apple weren't fighting inertia. They were creating a new space.
- rjtavares 14y agoWhile I don't disagree with your overall point: > just like iOS and OS X, we would really need separate apps for both Why? A desktop computer is powerful enough to emulate a smartphone, so existing Android apps could be desktop compatible (especially tablet ready apps).
- fh973 14y agoAgain somebody seems to misunderstand what OS means. Only because Android OS and Chrome OS are called operating systems does not mean they play in the same category as Windows. Windows is a platform, because it has vendor-provided high-quality drivers for basically any hardware device, wheres Android, Chrome, and OS X are always a customization for a particular device or device series. Drivers and a good driver model for the OS are hard. If there was no Windows (or better anything like the x86-Windows PC platform), there would likely be no hardware platform to run Linux on, and CPUs for OS X would be way less powerful due to lack of the progress of a highly competitive market over two decades. For this reason, the potential demise of Windows is a nightmare that should keep any IT professional awake. But I am optimistic: web apps have yet to prove to be on par with desktop apps, and there seems always to be the next desktop app when you think people are basically only using a web browser. I am confident that in 10 years there still will be Windows PCs or Laptops in private households, together with many other devices. Or am I missing something?
- f4stjack 14y agoUm. Doesn't anybody find a little funny that the word "linux" does not mentioned in the article? I mean, considering android is built upon linux kernel, a linux on a desktop pc can be called as android on the desktop technically, right?
- rprasad 14y agoUntil Android can run an office suite that doesn't horribly mangle basic formatting, Microsoft has nothing to worry about.
- krutulis 14y agoThe nightmare that keeps Microsoft awake is that the idea of "the desktop" might become irrelevant. While the metaphor was useful in its day, the trend-setters I encounter (who are not programmers) seem far more concerned with new notions of "presence," they view my focus on controlling my own little world as quaint, and they resent being tied to any particular device.
- mark_l_watson 14y agoAndroid is great for touch screen devices but I am not so sure about using it on a desktop with a mouse without all my software running on it. I spent almost a month with just my Galaxy S III on a trip up the Amazon River. I grew to really love the Android experience in general and my S III in specific. Great interface, great for reading eBooks, great for communications when around a wifi hotspot, great for taking pictures and videos. When I got home, it took me a while to start liking my iPad again. I have been looking at Android docking devices. With more powerful devices and future software Android support for Emacs, IntelliJ, etc., why not.
- mark_l_watson 14y agoActually, wireless docking, Bluetooth keyboard, and using the phone for a touchpad would work. Still need Emacs, IntelliJ, good terminal, GNU utilities, etc.
- foobarqux 14y agoI thought Emacs was already available on Android.
- Zigurd 14y agoHere is the killer quote: "I’ve no information on the likelihood if an Android OS will ever have an official desktop version, but then neither does Microsoft." Pumping up Android into a desktop OS, although it is theoretically possible, makes as much sense as dragging a bulky decades-old desktop OS into tablets and handsets. The article also lacks technical depth: The speculation might have even been fascinating, though still baseless, if it compared, for example, what it took to make Android multi-user versus a hypothetical desktop multi-window UI with all the attendant lifecycle modifications.
- vamur 14y agoI'd say they should be more worried about ChromeOS, as the Samsung Chromebook is still #1 on Amazon laptops despite all the marketing money spent on Windows 8. For Android, if Google added desktop mode and improved performance, and well-known OEMs released stick PCs with 4GB RAM and quad-core ARM A15, then Android could become a serious contender in the low-end market.
- meaty 14y agoAnd unicorns and monkeys will start flying out of my butt... There is absolutely no possibility that Android or any bastardisation of it can or will be used for anything involving moderate productivity apart from a geek niche. Why? People really don't have the time or inclination to meddle around and learn new interface paradigms for the sake of anything other than consuming. For people who earn cash or actually have to get shit done, it's too much of a context switch to get over. Not only that, it actually wrecks productivity. It's hard enough for people to move from Windows to Linux. And don't say about OSX market share or penetration as an example - there are precisely sod all Macs in the majority of businesses. People aren't even buying Windows 8 because it's too different. People actually really like Windows XP-7 and Office 97-2010 and don't want anything else. Sorry if this is painful news. Even smartphones are starting to piss people off. I've seen so many people switching back to feature-phones like Nokia Asha and cheap Samsungs recently, it's unreal.
- transitionality 14y agoYou can install Android on an x86 desktop now and even run binary ARM Android apps on it. http://android-x86.sceners.org/en/?p=580 http://android-x86.sceners.org/en/?p=580