3 ms·
I did my D.Phil. at Oxford University, and my B.Sc. at Simon Fraser University; while SFU is one of Canada's best universities, it clearly doesn't have the stat
by cperciva 19y ago
I did my D.Phil. at Oxford University, and my B.Sc. at Simon Fraser University; while SFU is one of Canada's best universities, it clearly doesn't have the stature of Oxford or Harvard. Were the students at Oxford more intelligent than the students at SFU? No. Were they more motivated? No. Are there jobs for which I'd rather hire an Oxford alumnus than an SFU alumnus? Absolutely.
The largest advantage of a great university like Oxford is in increasing the range and depth of ideas presented to students. It's impossible to completely separate the teaching role of a university from its research role: Teaching (and inconvenient questions asked by irritating students, like yours truly, in class) informs research, and research informs teaching. And quite apart from the "indigenous" research, if you're at a minor university without a strong reputation for research, you don't have Knuth dropping by for a few months, or Rivest visiting to give a lecture (albeit about the rather odd notion of obtaining forward security by using a stream of broadcasted random numbers which is too fast to be stored).
There are undeniable advantages to being at a great university in being exposed to new ideas. Why haven't PG et al. noticed this? Probably because their measurement -- can someone create a successful startup? -- is just as biased as everyone else's measurements. After all, when was the last time that a YC-funded startup really did anything new?
- pg 19y ago> when was the last time that a YC-funded startup really did anything new? Considering how many there are of them, probably within the last couple days. But instead of me giving you an example to which you will predictably reply "that's not really new," how about you giving us an example of a non-YC startup you think is doing something really new, so we can see what level of really-newness it would take to satisfy you?
- cperciva 19y ago>...how about you giving us an example of a non-YC startup you think is doing something really new... The first example which comes to mind is powerset.
- jey 19y agoVaporware? That's not really new. Anyway, they're probably at +3 standard deviations for "newness" compared to all tech startups. Kind of a high bar to match.
- bharath 19y agoWell.. its not so much the vaporware aspect of things... Succeeding in search today is all about scaling. Only the big three have what it takes to build huge data centers. A startup the size of powerset -- not really. Natural language search is something that the average search engine user would consider a "cool feature" at best. The real power of a search engine comes from its ability to cater to the long tail -- which translates to its ability to build huge data centers.
- jey 19y agoThe software involved is more of a key issue. You can always get more machines off the shelf, but you can't just go to Dell.com and place an order for a few killer algorithms. If you have awesome software, you can get funded. IIRC, Powerset is already backed by some big players.
- corentin 19y agoThe infrastructure behind Google, Yahoo and even Microsoft is not just a bunch of machines plugged to the same Ethernet switch... They're building datacenters from scratch.
- jey 19y agoSure, but it's still an easy problem. Building big data centers is definitely a problem these guys face, but it's by far not the biggest or hardest one. The software infrastructure and algorithms are much more daunting problems. Let me remind you that Google was a small startup very recently, and that was during the "dot com bust".
- 19y ago
- corentin 19y agoWhy don't you fund a few (or at least one) "crazy" startups like Anybots? Because that's probably the coolest thing YC-related! Are you only interested in web stuff, or is it a lack of serious applications? Here are a few "cool" ventures I have in mind: http://www.armadilloaerospace.com http://www.armadilloaerospace.com http://www.intellasys.net http://www.intellasys.net http://www.teslamotors.com http://www.teslamotors.com
- pg 19y agoYou don't count justin.tv as crazy?
- menloparkbum 19y agoWireless jennicam? Not crazy.
- pg 19y agoIt's dramatically different not just technically but also in what it does to the subject's life.
- menloparkbum 19y agoIt isn't. The tech is interesting, the content is not. As for what it does to the subjects' lives, I don't really care.
- asdflkj 19y agoCongratulations, you're one data point.
- corentin 19y agoYes, I have to agree that the technology behind justin.tv is quite interesting. Right now, it seems like it's only used by a bunch of exhibitionist and egocentric persons in a real TV fashion, but it will probably end up being used for more interesting stuff (like, say, a sailor racing across the world). On the other hand, they'd be stupid not to go where the money is (that is, were all the MySpace generation kids are).
- comatose_kid 19y agoSFU one of Canada's best universities? Care to elaborate? I always thought that Waterloo and University of Toronto were the best. Of course, Canadian universities seem to vary less in quality compared to institutions in the US.
- cperciva 19y ago>SFU one of Canada's best universities? Care to elaborate? I always thought that Waterloo and University of Toronto were the best. For universities with medical programmes, I'd say that UToronto is at the top, closely followed by UBC and McGill. If you're not interested in medicine or law, though, I'd say that Waterloo and SFU are pretty much tied, with UVic coming second. >Of course, Canadian universities seem to vary less in quality compared to institutions in the US. I'm sure you could find people who think that any of the universities I've mentioned are Canada's best university; to a certain extent it will depend upon their field. That said, few would dispute that all the above are better than UCalgary, UManitoba, York, or Carleton.