10 ms·
Some more context about the prosecutor: She was named "Bostonian of the Year" for her successful cases against mob bosses and drug companies: http://www.mainju
by danso 14y ago
Some more context about the prosecutor:
She was named "Bostonian of the Year" for her successful cases against mob bosses and drug companies:
http://www.mainjustice.com/2012/01/03/massachusetts-u-s-attorney-carmen-ortiz-is-bostonian-of-the-year/ http://www.mainjustice.com/2012/01/03/massachusetts-u-s-atto...
Out of the 94 U.S. DA offices, her office alone collected ~67% of the total criminal and civil fines in 2012, mostly owing to the successful prosecution of drug companies. Her success led to speculation that she would run for higher office:
http://www.mainjustice.com/2013/01/07/mass-u-s-attorney-carmen-ortiz-says-no-to-run-for-higher-office/ http://www.mainjustice.com/2013/01/07/mass-u-s-attorney-carm...
She is no stranger to being part of a disenfranchised group, as she was the first Hispanic and first woman to hold the position of U.S. attorney in Boston. Her first internship was with the DOJ's public integrity unit, created after Watergate:
http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2011/12/30/bostonian_of_the_year_carmen_ortiz_2011/ http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2011...
She's not of the "evil prosecutor" mold as is commonly thought and her background, particularly her history of fighting white-collar crime and corporations, doesn't strike me as someone who is intent on screwing the little guy over. That said, the seemingly-excessive charges could stem from a result of misconception and, let's face it, technological ignorance (hacking sounds bad, period). But in solving the overall problem in the justice system, let's not attribute to malice what can be attributed to other issues just yet.
--
One edit: a link to a piece by Aaron on yelling at the machine, rather than the person:
http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/nummi http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/nummi
My intent is not to say that the petition is wrong, but to argue that if people are going to call for action, call it for the right and productive reasons, rather than simplifying cause and effect to just one main person (even if the buck technically stops with her).
- jarcoal 14y agoThanks for posting this. The rest of this thread is ready to throw someone under the bus that they know nothing about.
- dantheman 14y agoIt doesn't matter what else she's done, we are judging her only by her actions in regards to this case.
- rdl 14y agoMaybe we should be replacing prosecutors who remain technologically ignorant years after these issues come up. If her job responsibilities include prosecuting computer crime, she needs to understand the applicability of computers to crime, otherwise she's not doing her job. Being old and an appointed official is no excuse anymore. It's not as if she's a holdover from the Reagan years. She was an early appointment by President Obama.
- eurleif 14y agoI'm not disagreeing here, simple asking for information: how has she demonstrated an ignorance of technology?
- danso 14y agoI know you're responding directly to the parent comment but for my part, I'll say that that's not my own accusation, just a possible speculation. Sometimes the reasons for terrible machinery to move ahead are rather banal. I'll say for sure that a lot of the initial backing by legislators for SOPA/PIPA was just status quo informed by vague technical understanding of the issue, and not because everyone was in the pockets of the movie industry.
- rdl 14y agoProsecuting downloading information in violation of terms of service as an abuse under CFAA. The 9th Circuit (the best circuit!) ruled this was bullshit in US vs. Nosal.
- eurleif 14y agoThat sounds more like legal ignorance than technological ignorance -- which is probably worse.
- tedunangst 14y agoWell, Boston isn't in the ninth circuit. I'm also curious how you would summarize the Nosal ruling.
- 14y ago
- geoka9 14y agoOK, she's a hero. Does it entitle her (or the people under her) to fuck up people's lives?
- danso 14y agoThat's not the argument here. The argument is that there may be some other specific point to apply activism towards. She is the head of her office but this is clearly not the most important case at the top of her caseload. It could've been a subordinate who made the calls and had the delegated authority. Technically, President Obama has the power to install and remove U.S. attorneys at his discretion. Should we start a petition asking him to resign, too?
- olefoo 14y agoI'm the author of the petition, so allow me to explain my thinking; and why I don't expect Ms. Ortiz to lose her job over this. 1. Obama appointed her, and by many metrics she is doing a good job. 2. The DOJ under Holder is anything but Liberal in it's outlook, a DOJ that's onboard with killing civilians who are American citizens without requiring even a closed hearing from a judge does not care what you think about prosecutorial overreach. 3. Using outsize threats and the power of indictment to coerce defendants into pleading out is policy, and goes well beyond an individual D.A.'s practices in a given case. That said; the purpose of this petition is to raise embarrassing questions in a way that demands an answer. Justice in this country should aspire to be more than "the shadow cast by the powerful upon the weak". note: I'm aware that I should have had someone else proofread the text and that my misedit of the first paragraph is now unfixable.
- danso 14y agoFWIW I hope the petition succeeds. It won't result in a resignation but it'll at least force an answer and an examination, if nothing else
- SoftwareMaven 14y ago
- jivatmanx 14y agoIt's clear that the severity of the charges were because the action was a political statement. That is why she wanted to "send a message" Had the same action been done by a non-political individual who simply did he "because he could" there would have been a quiet, minor settlement.
- jzwinck 14y agoDoes that make it better, or worse?
- jivatmanx 14y agoI don't know, but for one, the prosecutor tried to portray the action as solely having a profit motive - which is ludicrous.
- ratsbane 14y agoI agree. This makes it all the more important that we, as a community, "send a message" by calling out her actions as unacceptable and by peacefully petitioning for her removal from office.
- john_b 14y agoI agree especially with your last sentence. The torches-and-pitchforks crowd is missing the main point here. However, whether or not she is "evil" is irrelevant. She clearly went after Swartz with a self-righteous zeal that was far divorced from the seriousness of the alleged crime. I don't know if someone in the US Justice Department had beef with Swartz they wanted to settle, or if they just wanted to make an example of someone, but one thing is certain and that's that until these prosecutors face actual backlash to their jobs and reputation when they go so far overboard, nothing whatsoever will change. They simply have no disincentive for this kind of irresponsible and unprofessional behavior at the moment.
- danso 14y agoYes, it is possible she will have to be the proxy/figurehead towards which protest is directed...but if actual reform is the goal, then it's not a bad thing to examine fully what went wrong, if possible. Her office clearly has better things to do; who was the prime mover, if not her, in directing resources to this?
- shawn-butler 14y agoMIT, the state of Massachusetts, and Steve Heymann.
- objclxt 14y agoI wholeheartedly agree. It's understandable that after a tragic, upsetting event like this people look for someone to blame. If you are looking for someone to blame, blame the law. Prosecutors take cases they think they can win. No prosecutor wants to lose a case. The decision to take a case is made based on the law and precedent. Getting a DA fired solves nothing. What happens once you have achieved it? What have you accomplished? The law remains the same, and these type of cases continue to be brought. Change is difficult. But I hope that if people really cared about this they would put as much effort as they can into changing the law, rather than trying to place the blame on a single individual - because the latter can easily result in even more misunderstandings.
- bcoates 14y agoUnfortunately this conflicts with the reality of Federal law in the US, where prosecutorial discretion is essentially the beginning and end of the criminal law system. At any given time, any person and any company could be easily convicted of enough serious crimes to put them in prison for life or out of business. Prosecutors don't pick cases; they pick defendants, based on what are hopefully well-intended criteria. They then go through the extensive but essentially mechanical process of the justice system, which hopefully at least serves to shine enough daylight on the matter that prosecutor misbehavior is hard to hide. Saying we should not pressure them to pick in a way we would prefer is to abandon the only actual influence over the system we have.
- OldSchool 14y agoOnly a person of science or other black/white thinker would assume that law and procedure was an "essentially mechanical process." I once imagined it that way too. The very first thing a law student is taught is that everything is a grey area: laws are left vague deliberately in order to be interpreted by judges; evidence and procedure are negotiable; everything is subjective. The legal framework is only that, a framework. The legal machine is far, far from deterministic. It is designed from the top down to be discretionary. Otherwise you'd more often run into situations where you couldn't prosecute someone because a statute didn't spell out their exact actions even though in spirit they had violated it.
- Bjorkbat 14y agoDoing the right thing so many times you've lost count doesn't excuse doing the wrong thing. And the way this was handled, it feels more wrong than right, and she certainly had some considerable say in the way it played out. Maybe she's had plenty of opportunities to reflect on the consequences of her actions, maybe not (if it was all mob bosses and drug companies, probably not). In light of what's happened, at the least, she needs to reflect and grow from this experience.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoMy Grandfather, who was the US Attorney for west Memphis, once explained that prosecuting the law was messy. It was messy because there was rarely a case which hinged on exactly one part of the law or that had circumstances that nicely isolated the principle at stake. He was talking about pornography, and the difficulty of a general consensus that pornography was "bad" and should be outlawed, with the challenge of defining exactly what it was and the actual "bad" part of it. I see a lot of parallels between his struggle to enforce pornography laws with the current struggle to enforce copyright laws. These situations seem to arise when there is a fundamental disconnect between what "the people" think and what "the system" thinks. "The system" is represented by a codified set of strictures that are put in place by a variety of people representing what they assert are the best interests of "the people." Whereas the people themselves, act in what they consider a rational way given their understanding of or perhaps agreement to, the laws of the land. Finally our system of laws are a combination of written text, and argued cases, and the sum of those is an emergent thing thought of as public policy. When the rational acting people don't consent to the public policy, there is a rash of disobedience, and whether it is alcohol, porn, or copyright, the process of emerging to a consensus is challenging at best. One possible explanation for the zeal in which this case was pursued may be the lack of confounding factors with respect to copyright infringement, as codified by law. I don't know of course so this is just speculation. Having a clear, published, decision on the legitimacy or illegitimacy of what Aaron was doing might have been seen as a way to clear up a confusing pile of statutes and other decisions. An unambiguous marker between fair use and infringement, or perhaps a litmus test for intent. We'll probably never know.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jordanb 14y agoHonestly I don't care if she spends her nights and weekends caring for orphans and war widows. She's a politician who treated Aaron Swartz as a pawn in the political game she is playing. No doubt she intended for her campaign for governor to describe her as a "staunch defender of intellectual property rights" who, as prosecutor, put a "dangerous hacker behind bars" for "breaking into MIT and stealing millions of dollars of federally funded research." The Obama administration has thrown better people than her out the airlock because they became political liabilities. We need to add a new rule to the political rulebook that she's playing by. Ending her career is necessary to send a lesson to every other prosecutor who sees a guy like Aaron the way a housecat sees a cornered rat.
- monochromatic 14y agotreated Aaron Swartz as a pawn in the political game she is playing Well, maybe. It's also entirely possible that she was just doing her job, and didn't totally understand the technical aspects of what Swartz was accused of doing.
- venus 14y ago> she was just doing her job > didn't totally understand the technical aspects of what Swartz was accused of doing These are quite entirely contradictory. How can you charge someone for a so-called crime you do not even understand?
- dylanrw 14y agoThis hits the nail on the head. If the government can form legislation in a domain, and have the power to prosecute in a domain it should completely understand said domain. Ignorance on many levels is the reason for much of the discontent and injustice occurring where government and internet coalesce.
- drzaiusapelord 14y ago> and didn't totally understand the technical aspects of what Swartz was accused of doing. She had the resources to hire the types of experts who are what I call "executive whisperers." She doesn't need to know what a perl script is to understand what happened at JSTOR. On top of it, when the "victim" JSTOR is saying "what the hell, why are you prosecuting this guy?" Then its pretty obvious we're looking at political motivations here. Sorry, but you have way too much faith in people if you think what just happened was one big 'honest mistake.'
- wissler 14y agoIf you go to court and say "I didn't mean to break the law", he says "too bad." But evidently, you think she should get leniency from us for obliviously (you allege) ruining someone's life. Screw that.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWell by the justice departments own logic, we should end her career to send a message to other prosecutors. After all, that's what they would do.
- temphn 14y agoA young man is dead because Carmen M. Ortiz unambiguously railroaded him. Frankly the ignorance and tenor of her prosecution in this area makes me much less likely to believe that all those other people she fined and jailed were bad guys. That is: in the one area we do know - computer science - we can see that she pursued trumped up charges. So maybe a forensic accountant would be able to explain that in her past rise to "Bostonian of the Year" she jailed some poor middle manager for making a mistake, or a legal aid guy could break down how she made some minority kid selling pot into a "mobster". Won't know till the Internet and the press does a thorough review: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5048632 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5048632 Bottom line: she did not acknowledge any of Aaron's positive contributions when she decided to portray him as an evil hacker worthy of thirty five years in prison. Show her the same mercy she showed him by forcing her resignation. More, in fact, as I'm sure she'll be able to land on her feet as a high priced lobbyist. The RIAA/MPAA would love to have her.
- grogenaut 14y agoActually a young man is dead because he killed himself.
- rdtsc 14y agoActually if they drained his accounts and froze his assets and promised to shove in him a prison with hardened criminals for up to 50 years, where he could face assaults, rape and abuse (more so probably than the average hardened street criminal) killing himself didn't seem like such an irrational choice.
- grogenaut 14y agoThe point remains that the prosecutor did not kill him. He killed himself. Just trying to bring down the hyperbole on this thread... Speaking of which: In reality he would have gone to a while collar prison and would have gotten the counseling he obviously needed. (edit spelling)
- 14y ago
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"She is no stranger to being part of a disenfranchised group" Got it. Being a member of a "disenfranchised group" and "fighting corporations" excuses anything.
- hamai 14y agoThis article is about how the Feds disable criminal defense: http://www.forbes.com/sites/harveysilverglate/2013/01/03/black-whitey-how-the-feds-disable-criminal-defense/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/harveysilverglate/2013/01/03/bla... I've read somewhere she's was preparing for the Whitey's case mentioned in the article.
- josh_fyi 14y agoFire her pour encourager les autres.
- jortrp 14y agohttps://translationexercises.wordpress.com/2013/01/14/what-a-small-world-carmen-ortiz-aaron-swartz-and-tarek-mehanna/ https://translationexercises.wordpress.com/2013/01/14/what-a... Apparently, she knows VERY well how to destroy people's life for political profit, because she seems to have a good record on doing this.