3 ms·
This person has clearly never worked in a stressful trauma unit. I have actually tried the google docs and drop box think in an outpatient clinic, and it is ter
by lostlogin 14y ago
This person has clearly never worked in a stressful trauma unit. I have actually tried the google docs and drop box think in an outpatient clinic, and it is terrible. People accidentally delete things (sure you can get them back but the non-it person at the coal face wasn't able to). Records get written over and multiple people try to edit the document at the same time and conflict with each other. People forget their logins and then ask you for help working out their password (quote: shall we just ring them?). People accident sign the wrong email address up and distribute access to the wrong person. Privacy? Forget it. Data is stored offsite. Dunno where. Who is accessing the data. Unsure. Does it auto logout? Depends.
Piecemeal electronic record systems are bad, but consumer focused solutions are far worse.
The trauma unit isn't interested in population cholesterol or stuff like that. They want platelet levels now. X-rays now, CT Report, before now. Google and dropbox weren't made for this, and don't work on a day to day basis. I've tried.
Edit: typos. This subject makes me frothy mouthed as the commentator has valid concerns, terrible suggestions. Try it and see.
- jessaustin 14y agoI appreciate your experience (and it's good to learn that using these tools in the outpatient clinic didn't violate any regulations) but I don't think Phil is really suggesting Google Drive specifically here. He's suggesting instead that medical records should be more like a blank page (document) that physicians can fill in than e.g. a FoxPro app (dbms). Personally I think the "ideal" would fall somewhere in between. Physicians should probably be allowed to keep records however they like, but lives would be saved by the structure of a well-implemented [what a caveat!] digital checklist system.
- lostlogin 14y agoOne of the killer problems we have is that a huge local hospital (servicing probably several hundred thousand in population) won't give us any real access to their RIS and PACS, despite us doing lots of scanning for them. We have to get previous imaging and notes delivered on CD and DVD which is probably the worst type of digital info transfer possible. Even if we did have access it would likely take the IT team a few weeks to cobble together something that worked for us end users, but that would be an amazing improvement. We just finished a spell using google drive - oh wow it was terrible. I live in New Zealand btw.
- nobodysfool 14y agoI don't know where the author of the article got their data from, but I wouldn't rely on it. $100 million? You're kidding, right? I guarantee it won't cost that much. Try 1/10th to 1/100th of that. Yes, I work for a large healthcare services company. (this says the average is around 2.5 million http://www.leadingage.org/uploadedFiles/Content/About/CAST/Resources/CIO_Consortium_EMR_CostStudy.pdf http://www.leadingage.org/uploadedFiles/Content/About/CAST/R...) >(assuming they have first hired 10 lawyers to address patient-privacy issues!) Sorry, but this is just plain ignorant of the author. You don't need 10 lawyers just to collect aggregate data. Aggregate de-identified data is exempted from HIPAA. (see case 2 here: http://rockhealth.com/2012/02/hipaa-highlights/ http://rockhealth.com/2012/02/hipaa-highlights/) >But where is the value to the patient? How about not having your PCP not know anything about your recent hospital visit? Most EMR systems will automatically fax or send in a secure email updates to your health record.