3 ms·
Only in astronomy can you "give or take 700 million years". Geologists must be jealous, lol So technically that star is long gone now, these are just distant
by ck2 14y ago
Only in astronomy can you "give or take 700 million years".
Geologists must be jealous, lol
So technically that star is long gone now, these are just distant pictures from history.
- rietta 14y agoActually, according to the article HD 140283 is only 190 light years away. That's practically right next door to us. So no, the star could quite possibly still be alive and well in its old age.
- ck2 14y agoAh you are right and given the theory that the universe is expanding, it may have been even closer to us at one point.
- maaku 14y agoSteller and galactic motion is much more important at that scale than cosmic expansion.
- gus_massa 14y agoThe expansion of the universe is visible in the very very very big scale. The galaxies are generally spreading away from one another. But it is only the general direction. The gravity makes them move in complex trajectories so some of then are aproaching or even colide. The Milky Way ~100,000 light-years in diameter, so this star is inside it. Inside a galaxy the movements of the individual stars are even more complex, so they get closer or more distant.
- baddox 14y ago> So technically that star is long gone now That's not a very well-defined statement, since there is no absolute simultaneity between here and a distant area of the Universe.
- jlgreco 14y agoTechnically if we see anything, we are seeing something that was, not is. The sun could have disappeared a handful of minutes ago but we wouldn't know; the earth would even continue orbiting the spot where it used to be (until information of the disappearance reached it.) Since no information, not even gravitation, is going that fast, it makes the most intuitive sense to speak as though things happen when we can observe them happening. Anything that we can measure shows the star still there, even if stellar evolution allows us to accurately predict that it wouldn't be if we could travel there faster than light.
- geuis 14y agoGeneric reply to every other comment on this thread. Its 190 light years away. That's close. That means that its light has only taken a bit less than 200 years to reach us, compared to the millions and billions of years we see when looking at distant galaxies. The star has been around for 13 some odd billion years. Its very unlikely that it finally exploded in the last 190 years. As for comments about universal expansion, no simultaneous events happening, yada yada, none of that applies nor has anything to do with an old-ass star that's literally on our doorstep. I'm not going to get into a physics debate right now, but suffice it to say that if you were here and I was there (somewhere around the star), the light from both stars would be 190 years old to each of us. You and I would comfortably be existing in the universe at the same moment as long as we weren't travelling at relativistic speeds. For a closer-to-home example, imagine that I am sitting at my desk in my office. (I am.) And you are currently reading this in the car or on MUNI moving at 30-60 mph. Are you going to say that I, or you, don't currently exist at the same moment on the same planet or even the same city (San Francisco) because you're going slightly faster than I am?