7 ms·
There was a reddit comment the other day answering the exact same question. The person worked in a factory that cast plastic pieces for Lego as well as other co
by StavrosK 14y ago
There was a reddit comment the other day answering the exact same question. The person worked in a factory that cast plastic pieces for Lego as well as other companies. He said that Lego had much, much tighter tolerances, that they threw away many more pieces which weren't made to spec, and that they required much more expensive and frequently replaced molds.
I can't find it at the moment, unfortunately...
- zintinio 14y agoI mentioned it in my own comment, but here you are http://www.reddit.com/r/geek/comments/14ccan/lego_super_star_destroyer_now_available_at_target/c7buwv0?context=1 http://www.reddit.com/r/geek/comments/14ccan/lego_super_star...
- roc 14y ago"More expensive to make" doesn't necessarily justify "more expensive to buy". One would need to quantify how much more expensive the tighter tolerances and better molds actually make a package of bricks and compare the resulting margin to that of other plastic toys.
- specialist 14y agoI worked for a toy design firm during the mid-90s. Though I did software, I managed to learn a bit about this stuff (osmosis, helping with CAD/CAM, eavesdropping, etc). Tool die design for injection modeling is an art, a craft. Lego's die tools are smaller, meaning they hold many fewer parts. They had more supply channels. So the parts would be formed more uniformly. I forget what they did to ensure the parts cooled more uniformly. At the time, Mega Blocks were far inferior. The were using larger dies, more parts per die. So their bricks weren't as uniform. We used to bring in lots of other toys for inspection and play testing. I once assembled a Mega Block tank set. It just wouldn't stay together, with ill fitted pieces fighting against each other. The differences weren't even visible to the eye. Lego bricks just had better heft and fit. Also at the time, and I imagine is still the case, Lego and Playmobile were the gold standards for plastic molding toys.
- roc 14y agoI'm not saying Legos aren't well made. I'm just saying that you can't claim a price differential is justified by a cost differential without actually doing the math and providing X% cost differential ~+ X% price differential. Because absent those being equal, we have to consider that there are more factors and without context we can't even determine the relevance of the cost factor. In my view, the price differential exists simply because it can. People will pay $10, $20, $50 or more for a box of Legos. They grumble, sure. But they still buy them. I buy them because they work well, they're partnered with brands and properties that people also really like and they execute well in the tone and context of those brands. But I'm of the mind that prices for all non-commodities are set by willingness to pay and costs are a function of how much profit corporations needs to justify their investment. Ergo, that Lego spends more to make the pieces well is a consideration toward their profit margin. Not the price.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoWould it be legal to make compatible bricks which are called differently? If so, why is nobody doing it? If not, there is your answer why LEGO is expensive; to quote the dude from Idiocracy, "ohhh, I like money".
- danielweber 14y agoYes. See the link to Lego_clones elsewhere on this page.
- femto 14y agoYes, and they are doing it. For example, "Mega bloks" [1]. We have both at home, and in my experience, Mega blocks are interchangeable with Lego. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mega_Brands#Lego_lawsuits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mega_Brands#Lego_lawsuits
- bcl 14y agoIn my experience Mega Bloks fit, but don't hold together as well as LEGO.
- eloisant 14y agoYes, because if you can't make it as precise as LEGO, you can make it a bit loose so it fits anyway.
- rsheridan6 14y agoThey're also made of a different kind of plastic - they don't look or feel as smooth and shiny. There are a number of Lego knockoff brands, but I don't think any of them measure up to Lego.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoNice! But note Lego tried their best to fight them.. instead of welcoming friends and competition in this huge undertaking of measuring bricks correctly. Those Lego guys must really have figured out some hi-tech stuff there, so much is obvious; and it must weigh hard on their shoulders to not be able to share that with the world through a medium other than selling colored plastic blocks :(
- brazzy 14y agoExcept that the article seems to disprove that.