3 ms·
Stimulus: A history of folly
- trevelyan 18y ago"Despite Franklin Roosevelt’s aggressive spending, unemployment reached 25 percent in 1933, fell only to 14 percent by 1937, and was back up to 19 percent in 1939.1 " The level of ignorance in this article is astonishing. If the author knew economic history, he would know that Roosevelt's actions and the departure from the Gold Standard were responsible for the expansion of the money supply starting in 1933 and the massive reduction in the unemployment rate between 1933 and 1937. Roosevelt cut back on federal spending in 1937 against the advice of Keynes, making it ludicrous to claim the subsequent downturn was the result of aggressive Keynesian spending. It was the result of exactly the opposite. He also conflates monetary and fiscal policy. He questions why fiscal expansion is expected to work when monetary stimulus has failed and TARP is not working. Disregarding the obvious reasons why banks aren't lending (they are insolvent black holes that are hoarding cash instead of lending), this shows a colossal ignorance of basic economics. It asserts that public spending cannot stimulate the economy because government spending will somehow crowd out private investment and push interest rates higher. But if interest rates rise then monetary authorities can lower them and increase the money supply. We would be very lucky to have this problem. There are definitely long-term problems with current government policy. It is appalling to see to the public purse so eagerly take on such large amounts of private sector debt in starts and dribbles, especially when shareholders in institutions should have been the first players liquidated. I do not find Greenspan's argument that senior debt-holders need to be protected by the government to be very compelling. But these problems are overwhelmingly in the current efforts to salvage the banking system. The worst that can really be said for the fiscal stimulus plan is that it is probably too small, and about 10% of the funds spent will not do much stimulating at all, but were necessary to buy the bill through Congress so there would be ANY stimulus. As the far right passes further into ignominious lunacy I am very glad the Internet is here to preserve this sort of dreck for posterity. May it come back to haunt them, each and every one.
- mynameishere 18y agoYou're taking FDR's heroism as a matter of faith--as you've no doubt been taught. "Economic history" is a history of booms and busts. The busts normally were short, whereas the Great Depression was extremely long--not really ending until after WWII (or, if you prefer, the beginning, though I'm tempted to discount military activities as anything 'economic'). I would suggest, in a basic way, that the policies associated with circumstances should take responsibility for those circumstances. It asserts that public spending cannot stimulate the economy because government spending will somehow crowd out private investment and push interest rates higher. Well, it is. Though Berkshire’s credit is pristine – we are one of only seven AAA corporations in the country – our cost of borrowing is now far higher than competitors with shaky balance sheets but government backing. At the moment, it is much better to be a financial cripple with a government guarantee than a Gibraltar without one. http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2008ltr.pdf http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2008ltr.pdf If you think that can have a positive outcome, well...
- biohacker42 18y agoYou're confusing government spending with government lending. Also, banks which are in no way, shape, or form in trouble have taken TARP funds because the cost of borrowing is so attractive. I forget the name of the bank, but it's CEO was on CNBC, as an example of a healthy bank. Why does the TARP allow this? Because the program is a mess. But it's not crowding out private investment, and it's not even crowding out private lending, because it does allow healthy banks to borrow form TARP just the same.
- anamax 18y ago> Also, banks which are in no way, shape, or form in trouble have taken TARP funds because the cost of borrowing is so attractive. They were also told to take the money by the regulators. Apparently banks not being in trouble looks bad. Then Congress said "you took our money, so you have to do biz our way". Northern Trust is now trying to get out of TARP.
- Xichekolas 18y ago
- michael_nielsen 18y agoComing from James "Dow 36000" Glassman, I think this article can safely be ignored.
- gabrielroth 18y agoThe central fallacy here is "The stimulus money that flows to taxpayers, government agencies, and businesses has to come from somewhere (the unseen)." The short explanation for why this is false is that the velocity of monetary circulation is a variable rather than a constant. A slightly longer explanation is here: http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2009/01/time-to-bang-my-head-against-the-wall-some-more-pre-elementary-monetary-economics-department.html http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2009/01/time-to-bang-my-head-a...
- zupatol 18y agoI like how he emphasizes that economists really don't know much about the economy and often change their minds. Nobody knows what effects the stimulus will have. Whatever happens will not be the effect of the stimulus alone, so the question of its success will most likely remain unanswered. But this completely destroys his point that the stimulus is a mistake.