4 ms·
Are detector vans real? I know the Post Office IT arm used to have a massive database of license payers and TV owners. I was never sure whether the vans were m
by gadders 14y ago
Are detector vans real? I know the Post Office IT arm used to have a massive database of license payers and TV owners.
I was never sure whether the vans were more than an urban myth.
- adnam 14y agoDetector vans are a PR stunt to frighten people. Nobody has ever been prosecuted based on evidence gathered from a detector van. They can be used to get search warrants though.
- EliRivers 14y agoIt was certainly possible to detect the operation of TVs once; the old-school CRT boxes had big oscillators in that emitted EM radiation. I don't know about modern TVs; for all I know they have a different method of operation now. That said, it requires not just the equipment to do so, but also the competence and training, and whilst it's not impossible, licence inspectors are just whoever Capita managed to hire that month; maintaining a cadre of competent people to operate that equipment would be a headache and an expense that Capita simply aren't interested in. Far, far cheaper to simply have that big list of addresses (I understand they've got a list of every address in the UK that ever had a TV licence associated with it) and just assume that every address on that list that doesn't currently have a TV licence is a licence-dodger. Every so often it presumably gets pruned for addresses that no longer exist, but otherwise the rate of false positive will be a minor annoyance in the scheme and certainly not worth the hassle and expense of more sophisticated methods. Threatening letters and intimidating adverts do the job.
- gadders 14y agoI knew the tech exists, I just wondered if it was ever implemented. I remember asking my Elec Eng lecturer at Uni whether they could tell between a colour and B&W TV, and he thought not.
- finnw 14y agoThe detectors are still operated by the BBC, not the contractors. (I know 2 former BBC detection engineers, one of whom also operated the machine.) They declined to tell me how the machine worked, sadly.
- olgeni 14y agoMaybe it jammed the signal on prime time and then they just picked up the angry screams from the windows.
- alexkus 14y agoThe vans can detect a CRT TV on the ground floor; that's about it. The database of TV owners is the easier way to catch people. In the UK if you buy or rent a TV (or other bit of equipment that can be used to watch/record TV programmes[1]) from a shop (not private sale) then the seller has a duty to collect your name and address and report this to the TV Licensing authorities. Same (I think) for people who sign up to any other form of TV programme distribution: Sky, BT Vision, Virgin Media, etc. They then look for people who've got Sky or have just bought a TV and that don't have a license. That'll get the vast majority of people. Then there's the people that either don't have a TV (or anything else similar), or who have one but don't use it to watch broadcast TV. I had a period where I didn't have a TV and used to get hassled by letter once a month. Some people in a similar situation would refuse to let the inspectors into their house and endured endless letters, phone calls and visits. I just let the bloke in to look around, he saw there was no telly and left. The letters and hassle stopped after that. The rules about what you do and don't need a TV License for make it even more difficult:- " The law states that you need to be covered by a TV Licence if you watch or record television programmes, on any device, as they're being shown on TV. This includes TVs, computers, mobile phones, games consoles, digital boxes and Blu-ray/DVD/VHS recorders. You don't need a licence if you don't use any of these devices to watch or record television programmes as they're being shown on TV - for example, if you use your TV only to watch DVDs or play video games, or you only watch ‘catch up’ services like BBC iPlayer or 4oD. " It really hasn't caught up with the digital age. All they've done is add endless extra layers and clauses to the legislation to make it horribly complex. 1. A gross simplication. The actual definition is even more complex (as with most UK legal stuff) than this.
- youngtaff 14y agoA friend from Holland was over and they wanted to buy a Freesat receiver which of course they couldn't without a UK address, so they used mine (asked me first of course)
- madaxe 14y agoThey're vans with a yagi glued to the top. No more a detector than clouseau was a detective. Pure scare tactics.