4 ms·
UK still has 13,000 black-and-white TVs
- stuartk 14y agoIt says there are 13,000 licences for black and white TV's, so I wonder how many of those are just trying to get their licences cheap but actually own a colour TV.
- culshaw 14y agoContrast = 0. Hipster.
- arethuza 14y agoAt a "saving" of almost £100 that does seem by far the most likely explanation.
- mseebach 14y agoThe language in that article seems to suggest that they're about to launch an offensive against the BW license payers.
- rcush 14y agoWhy would someone pay for a TV license at all in that case?
- thisone 14y agoBecause they lessen the likelihood that the licensing folks are going to be knocking on their door.
- alansk 14y agoPerhaps the idea is that they are less likely to get a visit from the TV License inspectors if they have a B&W license vs no license at all?
- mseebach 14y agoAn irrational sense of not cheating quite as much. A vast overestimation of TV Licensing's ability to detect you - something like correlating cable/satellite subscription databases with license payers list (as if paying for cable, but claiming to own a BW TV set isn't a red flag) and the nefarious detector vans.
- raverbashing 14y agoMakes me wonder how sensitive the vans are. The other methods you quoted seems to be much more accurate (not to mention seeing varying shades of light behind the curtain)
- pablobm 14y agoAs for the detector vans: does anyone know if they actually exist? Several times in the past I have looked up information on them, and all I find seems to be in the realm of urban legend -slash- marketing ploy. What is the physical principle behind this tech? Does anyone have reliable information?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoThe physical principle is that they detect the leakage from the local oscillator in the superheterodyne receiver circuit. I very much doubt that they exist now, if they ever did. It just isn't cost efficient compared to sending out letters and low paid inspectors who peer through windows looking for people watching TV.
- mjhall 14y agoThe only means I know of for one to reliably detect the image on the screen would be TEMPEST style attacks [1]. I doubt that Capita can afford to buy the necessary equipment, or even views it as economically viable given the volume of letters they sent out - 56 million letters were sent in 2009, for example [2]. I'm not sure if modern TVs will even emit anything obvious since the connection from the decoder to the panel is covered in EMI shielding. [1] : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempest_(codename) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempest_(codename) [2] : http://www.tvlicensing.co.uk/about/foi-administering-the-tv-licensing-system-part-1-AB19/ http://www.tvlicensing.co.uk/about/foi-administering-the-tv-...
- dalore 14y agoTo stop all the letters. I had no TV for a couple of years and we would get letters all the time. Even when told the inspectors would still try and come round. They even faked who they were once, pretended they were here to deliver a package.
- hackerboos 14y agoMy mother was fined for having a colour television whilst having a black and white license. She had forgotten to upgrade since being given the television from my grand parents.
- jgrahamc 14y agoAccording to the TV licensing people there are roughly 25 million TV licenses in the UK. So 0.05% of TV licenses are black and white. That's a tiny number and not really surprising if you consider, say, an older person who has a perfectly good working black and white TV set that they see no reason to 'upgrade' to colour. Other stats show that around 2% of households in the UK do not have a TV (or at least a license).
- dagw 14y agoIf the UK as anything like Sweden and if my circle of friends and acquaintances are in any way representative, I'd estimate at least 70% of people without a license have a TV.
- thisone 14y agoThere are also people(and I assume an increasing amount) who have a TV but don't watch live to air telly (and so don't need a license). As the numbers increase due to better on demand service, I'm betting the television license rules will change.
- dagw 14y agoIn Sweden you have to pay if you own a TV capable of watching live to air telly, irregardless of if you actually do or not. So unless you physically remove the relevant electronics, you need a license, even if you're only using it as a large computer monitor.
- alexkus 14y agoProbably the more sensible way to do it. In the UK they've made it more complex that a license is required (for your home address) if you watch live TV on any device (including a computer or smartphone).
- mseebach 14y agoIn Denmark, the license is on TVs, any internet-enabled device or smartphone - basically, anyone is covered. It's ridiculous that they haven't had the decency to just make it a plain household-tax instead of this fake-pretend.
- raverbashing 14y agoAccording to the article the digital switchover is complete. So this means people plugged a digital converter to their B&W TVs? If I have children/grandchildren I hope they prevent me from doing something like that.
- jgrahamc 14y ago"If I have children/grandchildren I hope they prevent me from doing something like that." Why? If you are an elderly person who has a TV set that they like why change it for a newfangled colour one with a bunch of features that they are not going to use? They just get their grandkids to install a Freeview box and connect it to the TV and they are happy once more.
- dagw 14y agoIf you're perfectly happy with your old trusty 65" 6k 3D TV with MegaHypervison 2, why would you want your grandkids to force you to upgrade to a new 110" 12k TV with SUPER3D-doublePlus and MegaHypervison 4? You'll probably mainly just be using it to watch your silly old movies and TV shows that are only in a pathetic 4k resolution and don't even use MegaHypervison 2 let alone MegaHypervision 4.
- arrrg 14y agoWhy? If it’s working why change it? It only costs money and you will buy something that is more complex and breaks more easily. If you don’t particularly care about TV or the image quality, why wouldn’t you? (During the last thirty years of their marriage my parents had two TVs, both CRTs. Just now they bought a new plasma TV. They never buy the cheap stuff, but they always try to use everything for as long as possible, a philosophy I’m also quite fond of. Nevertheless I’m not holding my breath for this new TV also lasting 15 years. The guy my parents bought it from – a nice gumpy old fellow, excellent electrician but no longer really fitting into this world – was pretty pessimistic about the prospects of this TV lasting any more than four, five years. Oh, and this thing is a computer. You can access the internet and install apps and all that crap. Nothing my parents will ever use, but if you buy a good panel that’s what you get. If you want it or not. At least it works perfectly fine as a dumb monitor for the cable box. Another of these unpleasant things of the modern age. However, I wonder what happens when Panasonic stops updating this TV, should it last that long, which it probably will. Suddenly having an old TV is no longer harmless.)
- topbanana 14y agoI thought they had already stopped broadcasting analogue TV signals
- dasmoth 14y agoThey have, at least in the great majority of the UK. You can get set top boxes to receive digital transmissions if you don't have a suitable TV. I'm sure these would work with a B&W TV if you wanted. I believe some groups (the elderly?) were offered subsidised set top boxes.
- gpvos 14y agoI was wondering about how it would work actually. I don't think B&W TVs have SCART inputs, so I suppose there are still settop boxes out there that can output a PAL antenna signal?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThey have converter boxes. But as other commenters pointed out they may not actually have b&w sets but have merely "forgotten" to upgrade their licenses (at a savings of 100 pounds per year).
- mmahemoff 14y agoBeing nitpicky, it's licenses, not TVs, so the number could be higher. 13,000 households claiming at least one B&W and no colour.
- EliRivers 14y agoThe TV licence inspectors are employees of whichever private company the contract is with at the time (Capita last time I checked, but that was a while ago). As such, they have no powers beyond those of any other citizen; their doorstep tactics are essentially to ask if they can come in, ask to look around, and try to catch people out in conversation. The web has numerous examples of people with no TV, who have told the relevant body this, and yet nonetheless receive an endless stream of threatening letters. The letters tend to follow the same pattern; polite reminders to harsh reminders to threats of discovery and huge fines, and then back to polite reminders again. Essentially, their model is to assume that anyone without a TV is lying, and does have a TV. It's probably quite effective and certainly a lot cheaper than trying to keep track of who actually doesn't have a TV. So, if you've got a TV (that you use to receive broadcast transmissions - you don't need a licence just to own the TV, you need it for some of its possible uses) in the UK and you have no TV licence, you can be pretty sure that you can ignore the letters and, should a private citizen working for Capita come to the door, you need not answer or let them in or even talk to them. The only way they could demand entry would be with a suitable court document and accompanied by an officer of the court (who frankly has better things to do with his time), but to get that document they need reasonable evidence, and simply not having a TV licence is not actually considered evidence of illegally using a TV to receive broadcast transmissions.
- gadders 14y agoAre detector vans real? I know the Post Office IT arm used to have a massive database of license payers and TV owners. I was never sure whether the vans were more than an urban myth.
- adnam 14y agoDetector vans are a PR stunt to frighten people. Nobody has ever been prosecuted based on evidence gathered from a detector van. They can be used to get search warrants though.
- EliRivers 14y agoIt was certainly possible to detect the operation of TVs once; the old-school CRT boxes had big oscillators in that emitted EM radiation. I don't know about modern TVs; for all I know they have a different method of operation now. That said, it requires not just the equipment to do so, but also the competence and training, and whilst it's not impossible, licence inspectors are just whoever Capita managed to hire that month; maintaining a cadre of competent people to operate that equipment would be a headache and an expense that Capita simply aren't interested in. Far, far cheaper to simply have that big list of addresses (I understand they've got a list of every address in the UK that ever had a TV licence associated with it) and just assume that every address on that list that doesn't currently have a TV licence is a licence-dodger. Every so often it presumably gets pruned for addresses that no longer exist, but otherwise the rate of false positive will be a minor annoyance in the scheme and certainly not worth the hassle and expense of more sophisticated methods. Threatening letters and intimidating adverts do the job.
- blowski 14y agoA partially-sighted TV license for a B&W TV is £25, compared to £75 for a full colour one. Ebay has quite a few B&W TVs available for £5-10. There are 360,000 people registered as partially-sighted in the UK, although around a third of those are over 75 (and so get a free license anyway). I imagine this must count for a fair proportion of those 13,000 TVs.
- knightni 14y agoBlind people who still like to listen to television may be a significant cause of this. They receive a 50% discount on both colour and b&w licenses, so from their point of view there's probably little reason to upgrade from a black and white television.
- andyking 14y agoI was always under the impression that the licence was for the tuner, rather than the actual TV screen. I know that you used to have to get a colour licence if you owned a VCR, because it had a tuner capable of receiving and recording pictures in colour. Now that we've gone through digital switchover, there are no purely B&W TV tuners - every digital set-top box can receive colour pictures, even if the TV can't display them. Surely, in this case, the Black and White licence is obsolete? (Incidentally, I dropped my TV licence this year - I just wasn't using it enough to justify the cost. What little TV I view now is on-demand through the computer. With fibre-optic broadband - paid for with the money saved by not having a TV licence - I can receive an HD picture on BBC iPlayer and it's actually better than the old TV reception.)
- Lozzer 14y agoIf you're watching live (or nearly live) broadcast on iPlayer, you still legally require a license: http://iplayerhelp.external.bbc.co.uk/help/playing_tv_progs/tvlicence http://iplayerhelp.external.bbc.co.uk/help/playing_tv_progs/...
- andyking 14y agoI only watch iPlayer on-demand, once the programmes have been uploaded.
- kalleboo 14y agoI wonder what the uptake levels of HD would be if there was a discount on the license fee for SD screens (basically the modern-day analog of the b/w -> color switchover)