3 ms·
I agree with your statement about only being able to judge 4 or 5 quality levels. This of course only applies to subjective work, not to things like math, gram
by baddox 18y ago
I agree with your statement about only being able to judge 4 or 5 quality levels. This of course only applies to subjective work, not to things like math, grammar, etc. Subjective classes like Composition usually don't feature such an emphasis on daily or otherwise regular homework assignments, therefore the large assignments would be the tests. But I would also argue that 4-5 levels of quality is too much, because is the grader comparing papers to other papers, or to some ideal paper that exists in his mind? I think for subjective grading, the only options should be pass or fail.
- time_management 18y agoBut I would also argue that 4-5 levels of quality is too much, because is the grader comparing papers to other papers, or to some ideal paper that exists in his mind? I think, in general, the grades A, B, and C map to the following standards of acceptable work: A: That of a student intending graduate study in the field. B: That at a major. C: That of an ordinary student, e.g. a non-major. Hence, C is failure in graduate school, whereas a C in Calc 2 for an English major is unambiguously not failure. F obviously represents failure. D is essentially a high-fail that's counted as a pass. It means, "you didn't pass this class, and you shouldn't use it as a prerequisite, but you didn't do so poorly that I want to set you back a course." D would probably vanish if college weren't so fucking expensive.
- antiform 18y agoSome schools already do something like this. For instance, I know that Brown does not have pluses or minuses, and they only have grades of A, B, C, and NC (no credit). Furthermore, the NC grades do not appear on official transcripts. On top of that, you can take almost any course Pass/No-Credit with an option of a written evaluation instead of a grade.