3 ms·
> two "coherent claims" are so broad that they capture most of the the individual specific arguments That's not been my experience (I linked to a discussion fr
by beagle3 14y ago
> two "coherent claims" are so broad that they capture most of the the individual specific arguments
That's not been my experience (I linked to a discussion from a month ago, but you can find the same points reiterated in this discussion by others). Those "other points" are not remotely covered by these two claims, and are touted far more often.
> a conservative could reply that there are only a few "coherent claims" for public insurance too.
That's true; perhaps it's just one claim - but it's a matter of fact, rather than opinion:
1. Every western country that implemented single payer spends significantly less for comparable or better results (normalized by just about every attribute you want)
(corollary) 2. Medical bankruptcies (that is, attributable directly to cost medical treatment, rather than, say, the inability to produce income due to sickness) are essentially nonexistent in any other part of the world, yet are the reason for more than 25% of US bankruptcies http://www.factcheck.org/2008/12/health-care-bill-bankruptcies/ http://www.factcheck.org/2008/12/health-care-bill-bankruptci...
re: education - I'm with you on that. That's also something that the US can learn from other western countries - where generally, public education (at all levels, including preschool and academic levels) outperforms private education.