3 ms·
"doctors are government employees" Not all doctors in the UK are government employees working in the NHS - there is a private health care system here as well.
by arethuza 14y ago
"doctors are government employees"
Not all doctors in the UK are government employees working in the NHS - there is a private health care system here as well. Nobody makes you go or work for the NHS - but you do have to pay for it - I have private health insurance from my employer (I would never pay for it myself although I could afford it) and I'm quite happy to pay for the NHS.
NB My son was born in an NHS hospital, when he has had an accident it's the dedicated NHS childrens hospital he gets taken to, when my wife got seriously injured climbing it was an NHS hospital that treated her - all of which were awesome. The NHS is far from perfect but I like knowing that everyone in this country can get a decent standard of healthcare free at the point of delivery "In Place of Fear":
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan
- tptacek 14y agoThe entire private health care budget in the UK is £5Bn. The second largest purchaser of private care in the UK is... wait for it... the NHS. The NHS budget is over £100Bn. The government has overwhelming control over the health care market of the UK.
- arethuza 14y agoBut as a consumer of health care in the UK I'm struggling to see what the problem is - the NHS is cost effective and generally available and if you want a slightly nicer room and to jump the NHS waiting queues (which do happen) then you can go private and get any kind of treatment pretty much when you want it.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not saying there is a problem with it, I'm just saying that the existence of a PH market in the UK is not a strong counter to the Republican concern about a government takeover of the market for health services.
- arethuza 14y agoSorry I was reacting (probably a bit emotionally) to the assertion by another poster that all doctors in the UK are government employees - which makes it all sound far too much like some kind of Soviet bloc nightmare.
- beagle3 14y agoIndeed, and that is perhaps one of the two coherent claims made by republicans against a decent public options (single payer or otherwise). Coherent Claim 1: The existence of a public option harms the viability and structure of a private option Coherent Claim 2: A healthy, careful individual should not be forced to subsidize an individual who does not take care of their own health - but is forced to by a public option. Both claims are a matter of opinion; It is my opinion that it is no different than police, school or war. (1: The existence of police harms private security; the existence of public schools harms private schools; the existence of the US army harms private mercenaries. 2: I should not be forced to pay for protecting someone who does not make an effort to protect themselves; I shouldn't be forced to subsidize teaching to anyone; I shouldn't pay for a war I didn't ask for). I'm not sure why health care, which is sometimes (literally) a matter of life and death, and about which one has much less control than anything else, would not get a public option when schools do. And I have yet to find a republican who was coherent about why, if public healthcare is a problem, should we not also abolish police departments and public schools. But I guess one might exist. The bigger problem with the republican standpoint, is that the coherent arguments aren't even made all that often; instead they tend to spread FUD with arguments that are easy to refute if you just care to look at examples - see, e.g. : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4888507 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4888507
- tptacek 14y agoThose two "coherent claims" are so broad that they capture most of the the individual specific arguments made against public health insurance; a conservative could reply that there are only a few "coherent claims" for public insurance too. And, obviously, Republicans aren't big fans of public schools either. In fact, unlike private health care, which is out-executed by Medicare, public education is generally outperformed dollar-for-dollar by private education. (Note: I am strong, strong supporter of public education and oppose vouchers).
- onetwothreefour 14y agoYou say that like it's a bad thing.