4 ms·
I think Marx went into over simplification when it came to issues like these. Even in this case, and in most cases. The workers are actually are super fortunat
by kamaal 14y ago
I think Marx went into over simplification when it came to issues like these.
Even in this case, and in most cases. The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all. Everything is built ready, all the investments and risks are born by somebody else. All you do is work(Im not saying that's easy or insignificant, but it is individually insignificant to the larger scenario where somebody has built a big industry- your contribution are small but are compensated), and at that kind of financial security forgoing 1/6th part of your earnings is hardly a problem.
- cantankerous 14y agoMarx was concerned with the differences between an agrarian society moving to an industiralized society and the implications it had for the control of wealth and power. Prior to industrialization, at least in the mind of Marx, individuals were able to effectively reap what they sowed on a farm somewhere (also an oversimplification, but still). In an industrialized era, one man at the time could not compete on his own for lacking capital, an education, and connections (put Marx into the context of his time and geopolitical background). Marx wasn't overly concerned with the issue of compensation of a capitalist being commiserate with the risk s/he takes, but rather the protection of individuals who now live in a world where they are, more likely than not, stuck working for somebody else. While I don't really know about the particulars of his proposed solutions, I think Marx does identify a real problem that free-markets on their own do not guarantee solutions to. It's never a bad idea to be on the look out to make sure our economy is working to serve everybody involved in it, at least in my opinion. That's my biggest takeaway from Marx.
- yk 14y agoMarx was actually not so much concerned with fair compensation as with fair distribution of power ( of which money is one aspect). > The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all. I think the most important point about Marx analysis is, that this statement may or may not be true. There is nothing in the 'capitalist production process,' which guarantees that the workers are treated well ( or even survive their workday). If the bourgeois gains a advantage by treating his workers well, he will do it. On the other hand, if he gains a advantage by hurting his workers then he will either do it, or be replaced by someone who is willing to hurt his workers.