4 ms·
Get kids trained early. Next put them into all adult ID cards and make it illegal to walk around outside without one. Police can just drive through a neighborho
by ck2 14y ago
Get kids trained early. Next put them into all adult ID cards and make it illegal to walk around outside without one. Police can just drive through a neighborhood and see who everyone is and their drones can just tag you and watch you move through your day. Don't have a chip on? Then get a forced iris scan like the US military does in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The future freaking terrifies me, especially how people just roll over and accept it.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWhat terrifies you in this scenario? That the technology would be used by people other than the police, or that the police require identification?
- throwaway125 14y agoSeveral things: 1) Mass scale surveillance becomes trivial and you'll end up in a database of suspects even if you've never broken the law 2) Your identity can be checked without your knowledge regardless of probable cause 3) The technology might not be safe, but this is much less of an issue than #1 and #2
- ck2 14y agoYour response terrifies me even further. You don't see a problem with giving the police extreme powers? How about the police pulling up outside a neighborhood and making everyone get in a line for TSA-like gropes and clone everyone's cellphone because there were some crimes in the area recently (this actually happens now, not entire neighborhoods but select individuals at their whim). Tell me where you draw the line and how police won't immediately abuse any power they are given? Let me know how you feel after your first encounter with the police someday.
- jrockway 14y agoStop-and-frisk was struck down in court earlier today.
- phaylon 14y agoThere is a trend in Germany right now, where police ask whole neighborhoods for voluntary DNA testing when they are looking for someone. The problem is that you'll get a visit and asked why you didn't volunteer if you don't go. And it looks like it's not just Germany: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4161983.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4161983.stm I think part of the problem is that the reasonings in these cases aren't out of this world. So people will think of the whole issue as much less problematic.
- tomjen3 14y agoThat is surprising. Germany usually has its shit together wrt. privacy issues. Of course you can always just hint that they are acting a bit naziest. Makes them shut up really fast (totally unfair tactic, but it works).
- cafard 14y agoas far as I know the NYC stop-and-frisk doesn't check your cellphone, but it has stored up a lot of bad will...
- krichman 14y agoAn adult isn't required to carry/produce an ID unless they are operating a vehicle. Will that still be the case in five or ten years?
- ck2 14y agoYes you are. If you are not carrying ID, they will detain you until your identification can be confirmed - if that means taking you to jail for a 24 hour hold, they have no problem being paid overtime to sit and do that paperwork. All they have to do is pretend to terry-stop you for any reason and demand ID then. No judge will ever sanction them.
- mistercow 14y ago>No judge will ever sanction them. Courts have been plenty willing to overturn arrests in such circumstances. Moreover, while the cops are largely able to get away with that kind of behavior, it is still illegal for them to do so. Also, I wasn't able to find any evidence of cops being able to detain you in jail for hours on a Terry stop. Can you give a reference?
- vacri 14y agoI thought that you only had to identify yourself under suspicion of doing something unlawful, and couldn't be held simply for not handing over an ID.
- jlgreco 14y agoSome states require you to identify yourself upon request. This does not, in any state I am aware of, require the use if ID. All that is required in those states is that you tell them your name.
- spoiledtechie 14y agoDitto... Huge Ditto. I know I will be moving to a cabin in the woods when that happens.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 46Bit 14y agoJust before that day comes, they've got you tagged as a potential social disturbance thanks to your comment.
- nsxwolf 14y agoWe're already willfully, gleefully carrying these ID cards - they're our smart phones. A couple policy decisions here and there and your nightmare scenario will be fully realized.
- quorn3000 14y agoYou can use cell phones to estimate vehicle journey times.
- vacri 14y agoThe future freaking terrifies me, especially how people just roll over and accept it Every time I see one of these sorts of articles in the US, I wonder what the extremely vocal 2nd Amendment advocates are waiting for. There's never a call to action despite the bluster. It really highlights that they want guns to be unregulated because "I like guns and think they're fun", not because "government needs to fear the public".
- rtpg 14y agoPeople tend to forget that courts exist. Just because kids have their school ID cards doesn't mean that the police can (or will ever be allowed to) ask for them and check for the validity (sounds like a warrantless search). Your nightmare scenario is blocked by the fact that just because something is technologically possible, it doesn't mean the police are allowed to do it. This adult ID card you speak of? What will be the rationale for it existing? haven't national ID cards been pretty much decided to be unconstitutional? Not an expert but doesn't RFID have a really small range too? All RFID-ish cards I have seem to require being around 50cm to the reader, so if the police drove down my street, they won't be able to get my arcade card info, much less my subway pass (granted they could just get that from the transport company). On this situation, these cards seemed to be for attendance only. If the cards were replaced by people doing attendance at every door in the school, we'd probably be complaining about the fact that high-tech solutions to this problem exist.