3 ms·
Emergent phenomena don't have "objectives", mate. GDP is a derived statistic. > I hope that in the remainder of the century we can can transition to better for
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Emergent phenomena don't have "objectives", mate. GDP is a derived statistic.
> I hope that in the remainder of the century we can can transition to better forms of society where the health and happiness of the general population is more important than the efficiency of our economic structures.
And your proposal is? A lot of alternatives have been tried in the past several thousand years and almost all of them suck. Real hard.
- nhaehnle 14y agoAnd your proposal is? A lot of alternatives have been tried in the past several thousand years and almost all of them suck. Real hard. Don't think in terms of The Alternative System, just think in terms of the small things that can make life better. Things like reduced working hours to have more time for family, or better economic freedoms for everyone. Those things do not represent a change in The System. In particular, they are perfectly compatible with allowing private initiative in the market. In fact, they enhance private initiative overall, in areas outside of the market (having more time outside of work can translate to becoming engaged in local community organizations, to give just one example).
- pjzedalis 14y agoIf enough people say they are done with 40+ hour work weeks and only will do 35 companies will adapt. So far there has not been enough people willing to do so.
- jayferd 14y agoI'm done with it, and all my current and future employers know it. But I'm in a pretty privileged position to be able to meet my needs working part-time.
- bksenior 14y agoIts actually quite simple. We need a massive dose of social proofing amongst those that have already attained the peak of accomplishment as seen in the current system to change their behavior. We are no different now than when we were 6 watching our parents. You emulate those you think live right, and the people that live right in the eyes of those under the spell of the implications of the article look to fame, money and power. If those that wied those act a certain way, those new ways become the pinnacle. This solution is the only non forceful way.
- justincormack 14y agoWelcome to Europe...
- forgingahead 14y agoBy "adapt", do you mean, "move everything to Asia"?
- tossacct 14y ago>>>Emergent phenomena don't have "objectives", mate. What makes you say that, mate? Are intelligence and consciousness emergent phenomena?
- jacques_chester 14y agoDo you think intelligence and consciousness have "an objective"? They might have a post-hoc discernible function, but that's not the same as a predetermined purpose.
- tossacct 14y agoYes, because the concept of an "objective" is very useful when trying to describe emergence. A semi-related question: If no emergent systems have "objectives", then what things do have "objectives"?
- jacques_chester 14y agoPlease, I'm too old for running down teleological rabbit holes.
- tossacct 14y agoIf you had simply stated that you didn't believe in the concept of "objectives", instead of singling out my precious emergent systems, there would be no rabbit holes to run down. :) Also is 1 thing that has an objective too much to ask for?
- jacques_chester 14y agoI'm saying that complex systems in and of themselves don't have "objectives". Deliberately designed systems can absolutely have purposes and objectives. If you want to be nitpicky there's a frothing sea of philosophers smashing endlessly against the little rowboat we're in here. Feel free to dive off and swim around, I'll stay here.
- sp4rki 14y agoRadicalized revolutionary socialism? If greed and self preservation wasn't such an important factor in the common peoples agenda perhaps. The reality is that history has taught us that the usual alternatives to the capitalist-imperialist driven society we live in today is radicalization of a substancial mass of people which invariably ends up with a non-insignificant number of causalities of the human, pedagogical, religious, and/or cultural types. And then you have people using those ideals to strike with unnecessary violence at what they define as their enemies... and then you get the PFLP saying they're fighting for the same ideals you're fighting. And then you get a bunch of people speaking about nationalism, antisemitism, racism, and then politics, politics, politics. I'm probably reading too much into what this discussion is actually about (it's a bit early for me), but I just wanted to contribute that I think that our current regimes are probably unsustainable if we as a world population keep growing at such expeditious rates as we are right now. That being said, I have no proposal. Bigger people than me have tried to come up with such propositions, and I'm not planning on organizing another french revolution.
- jb17 14y ago> Emergent phenomena don't have "objectives", mate. GDP is a derived statistic. Either you are nitpicking (an economic system doesn't have goals ("objectives") in the same way you do), or you're making a pretty strong claim here. If you try to do the latter, I would say you're wrong. Marx has written a good primer on the topic, which shows that the primary objective of capitalist society is capital accumulation.