3 ms·
Teenage boys boast about their sexual exploits (with photos, on the internet, because it's 2012). Teenage girls are incredibly cruel to one another. Exactly; a
by pdonis 14y ago
Teenage boys boast about their sexual exploits (with photos, on the internet, because it's 2012). Teenage girls are incredibly cruel to one another.
Exactly; and this is not news, it's been going on for as long as there have been people.
The article doesn't even talk about the real lesson here: be careful who you trust. If you can't trust someone not to secretly record you having sex and then posting the video on Facebook, then you shouldn't be having sex with them. The lesson has always been the same, and there have always been people who don't learn it until it's too late.
Edit: I should make clear that I am not trying to exonerate the teenage boys; quite the contrary. To allow someone to make an explicit video of you without your knowledge and post it on Facebook is naive; but to make and post the video is malicious and cruel. The girls need to be reminded of the lesson; but the boys need to be shamed and punished.
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> If you can't trust someone not to secretly record you having sex and then posting the video on Facebook, then you shouldn't be having sex with them. People are awful at assessing risk; why the assumption that teenagers will be any better? Your advice is sound, but it's also along the lines of "Don't have sex, and you'll be safe!" It's not practical.
- pdonis 14y agoI've seen this argument before, and I don't buy it. First of all, you're mis-stating the rule: the rule is not "don't have sex", it's "don't have sex until you know enough about the other person's character to be reasonably sure you can trust them with something that intimate". Second, if people are that bad at assessing risk, that's all the more reason to err on the side of safety. But most importantly, choices have consequences, including the choice to have sex with someone who isn't worth that kind of trust; you can say it's not practical to avoid that (I don't agree, but that's another argument), but saying that doesn't change the consequences of the choice. If you trust someone who doesn't deserve it, you're going to get hurt: that's a fact of life. No amount of social engineering is going to "fix" this fact of life.
- mnicole 14y ago> The article doesn't even talk about the real lesson here: be careful who you trust. If you can't trust someone not to secretly record you having sex and then posting the video on Facebook, then you shouldn't be having sex with them. The lesson has always been the same, and there have always been people who don't learn it until it's too late. This is nice in theory, but no one really knows who to trust - adults and teenagers alike. Additionally, girls are often guilt-tripped into sending these types of photos lest they want to be told they don't really "care" about the person. I've been hit with that one a few times, even by guys that were otherwise very respectful. There's also the "come on, everyone does it" pitch, which is true, but doesn't mean anything when push comes to shove.
- lotharbot 14y agoGirls (and boys) are often manipulated into acting foolishly. To generalize the above lesson, be careful how you allow your behavior to be influenced. Be careful how much power you give others over you. (Note that this doesn't absolve others of wrongdoing -- it's just an observation of a way people can protect themselves from victimization.)
- pdonis 14y agoBe careful how much power you give others over you. This is as good a short, one-sentence statement of the general rule as I've seen.
- king_jester 14y ago> The article doesn't even talk about the real lesson here: be careful who you trust. If you can't trust someone not to secretly record you having sex and then posting the video on Facebook, then you shouldn't be having sex with them. The lesson has always been the same, and there have always been people who don't learn it until it's too late. The issue here is that trust is impossible to judge in this context. Sexual violence and intimidation is has deep cultural roots in the US, changing that culture is key to reducing incidents of that violence and bullying. Most sexual assault is committed by someone the victim already knew and 1 in 4 women will experience domestic violence in their lifetime, so trust is not enough.
- pdonis 14y agoThe issue here is that trust is impossible to judge in this context. No, it isn't. It may be difficult, but it isn't impossible. And it would be easier if people were taught that trust is something important that should not be given lightly. It would also help, as has been commented already in this thread, if the people who abuse trust were publicly shamed, instead of the people whose trust they abuse.