6 ms·
Why Google Plus Will Prevail
- disc 14y agoThis is a very liberal use of the word 'proof', to put it kindly. The strategy the author outlines doesn't sound markedly different to me then when Google Plus launched, so I'm not sure what makes him think there will be a sudden change in adoption rate.
- hobbes 14y ago"So then why didn’t Google shut down Google Plus if it was purportedly such a colossal flop?" Because failure wasn't an option, considering the landscape of social networking and the consquencies of failing.
- neutronicus 14y agoG+ hangouts are a pretty effective "carrot" for parents with children living far away. Both my parents have G+ accounts.
- mtgx 14y agoHangouts is quite convenient, and I've noticed it's catching on with both regular people and I've also seen sites using it more and more for podcasts or interviews and whatnot. What I'd hope they improve is being able to watch live in 720p (or at least being able to record it as that for now), but that might not happen until they switch to the VP9 codec, if Google feels such 5-10 people Hangouts in 720p would use way too much bandwidth for that to be worth it. But I do hope they switch to it as fast as possible. I also hope they can work on making focusing when switching to another person much faster, and imperceptible, unless that's something they can't fix because it depends on everyone's cameras, and upgrading their cameras to something that focuses faster.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI have no idea whether Google+ will succeed or fail. I do know a strategy that would have made it succeed because, when I was at Google, I proposed it.
- bigdubs 14y agoWhat was your plan and what proof did you have that it would work?
- michaelochurch 14y agoWell, step back to summer 2011, when Facebook was facing social network fatigue due to, among other things, quality problems in content. This was especially a problem as related to games. People hated the Zynga games and the spam. Facebook had actually solved its spam problem by then, but reputation is a lagging indicator and people were pissed at Facebook about all the shitty games. We needed to brand Google+ as a high-quality social network. That was well-understood to be the strategy, and it was intended as a long-term campaign. Start highbrow, dumb down harmlessly. This wouldn't be hard, because its early adopters were Googlers, who tend to be high-quality people. What makes "social" so difficult for Google is that it's ideologically different from Search. In Search, you win if people get in and get out quickly. The less time they spend in getting through, the better you are doing. If you're a Facebook, though, you want people to spend time in your site. That's an ideological discrepancy between Google's very successful Search ideology (get the user in and out so fast the service is invisible) and what you need to do to win in Social. You also need to generate comfort among your users, which is hard to do and can't be forced. Google+ has a lot of awesome tech in it (cf. Hangouts). It's a really neat piece of software. But people need to get into the product and get "comfortable" so they can start exploring. Early adopters explore right away. Most users want to be comfortable first. Facebook achieved "comfort" within an Ivy League college. It was just a silly thing your friends would see. It didn't start out as a general-purpose social network. Google+ lacked that luxury. It came into the social network space as a fully-fledged product and it's harder to establish social "comfort" that way. People are more comfortable with things that develop organically (cf. boiled frog). This makes Games a critical battlefield. Games are a great way to bring people into the site, to get them comfortable, and to get them using the other goodies (e.g. Hangouts). If the games are good, they'll use your product a lot. It was also an arena in which Facebook seriously fucked up by not curating quality. Zynga damaged Facebook's reputation (and community quality, et al) in a major way. Mid-2011 was the nadir of its weakness on that issue. We needed to make that our strength by having some really awesome games. Where would we get them, though? Google did Games, but not with the focus on quality. Again, this is success in Search hurting in Social. Google is admirably non-editorial when it comes to Search. What the web thinks is important is important. If you send someone to a crappy website (that he thought he wanted) so what? 5 seconds wasted, and then he types in a different query. It hardly ruins Google's brand that there's garbage on the Web. Google's job is just to document and facilitate, not to curate (with Search). The problem with Games is that people are looking for quality, but game quality isn't visible until someone plays it for 30 minutes. If you deliver someone a stinker, he resents you for wasting half an hour of his time. He'll associate you with the shitty Zyngarbage and never log in again. We needed to curate, but that doesn't scale, and the people in charge of game selection (while strong in general technical and project-management competence) did not know how to pick games. So I came up with the Excellence In Games (EIG) initiative. Originally, I called it "Real Games" (a pun on Real Names). The idea was, instead of publishing dreck from mainstream publishers, who were giving us mediocre product because they didn't expect us to succeed, we court the independent developer community: the people who in 2013 are trolling Kickstarter for their 2D "retro" RPGs and German-style boardgames. We court these developers and give them a platform that does for them things they can't do for themselves, plus access to an enormous number of players. We also publish casual games, but only of high quality-- no Zynga dreck. By doing this, we create the image of being a gold standard for game quality. We keep the Google reputation-- we won't waste your time-- intact. The engineers on the G+ Games team were huge fans of EIG and wanted to implement that instead of working with Zynga (who are apparently miserable to partner with) but the senior execs were not fans of this proposal. However, they were proven wrong. Google+ Games failed. Google did the smart thing and covered, which is why you've never heard of Google+ Games, but it's still an enormous missed opportunity.
- k3n 14y ago> Step one: Corral every single blogger. Have you used Google lately and noticed faces appearing next to certain posts? That’s called Google Authorship--bloggers can link their Google Plus profile to the content they create. Guess how many online writers see that and say “Eh, I don’t need to have that.” If you said “zero” you win a prize. False. I couldn't care less about a silly profile pic. I also don't even use Blogger. Perhaps the author is unaware, but there are quite a few bloggers out there who _aren't_ using Blogger, and who happen to control the ability to alter their blog at-will. This would include putting up silly profile pics or whatever. > Step two: Attract every single small business and at least one of their employees. Want your business to appear on Google Maps, Google Local, et al., so that you can tell your prospective customers where you are, what you sell, and when you are open? Yup, you guessed it--you need a Google Plus Local Business page now. False. You don't _need_ a "Google Plus Local Business page" for any of that, Google -- and, apparently, the author (who is playing the role of an agent of Google at this point) -- just wants you to believe that you do. > Step three: Convince you, because all of those other things that you already love get better. Maybe you’re addicted to that new augmented reality game Ingress. Maybe your Google Plus profile makes it way easier to win. Or maybe you want better music, movie, or book recommendations--look no further than Google Plus. Want to find a community of skiers or chefs or race car drivers with a flick of the wrist? Or perhaps that hilarious video about that thing that you once emailed to a friend but can’t quite remember enough about it to find again? When you have Google Plus, those communities and that video just appear when you search for your best guess. Could he be any more blatant with the Google advertising? I looked for a 'full disclosure' statement but couldn't find one, so I can only assume that the author is drunk on the kool-aid at this point. Regardless, somehow I'm still leading a meaningful, productive life without Google+. I don't know how, maybe I'm a freak of nature.....but I can still easily find music, movie and book recommendations without G+. Astonishingly, I can also still find meetups without G+. And G+ would be the last place I'd ever look to find an old video... With that said, I'm not saying G+ has failed. But it's not for everyone, and the more Google attempts to force me down that path, the more I am going to resist.
- JPKab 14y ago"> Step one: Corral every single blogger. Have you used Google lately and noticed faces appearing next to certain posts? That’s called Google Authorship--bloggers can link their Google Plus profile to the content they create. Guess how many online writers see that and say “Eh, I don’t need to have that.” If you said “zero” you win a prize. False. I couldn't care less about a silly profile pic. I also don't even use Blogger. Perhaps the author is unaware, but there are quite a few bloggers out there who _aren't_ using Blogger, and who happen to control the ability to alter their blog at-will. This would include putting up silly profile pics or whatever." You completely missed the biggest benefit stated by the author: the protection from duplication by content farms. When someone Googles the blog post, the original blog is always on top, rather than some content stealing farm. How did you miss that? The point the author made was that it won't "force you down a path", rather it will lure you with capabilities. My team started using it for Hangouts, because the screen sharing/etc was better than the other products we were trying to use, and by better, I mean faster/smoother/more reliable. Anyone who refuses to enhance their capability out of sheer stubborness is someone I will NEVER do business with.
- Irregardless 14y agoThe cognitive dissonance is startling: > Yes, of course Google could force most of us to use Google Plus begrudgingly tomorrow if it wanted to, but that’s playing with big, big, brand fire. And that’s not really who Google is at its core anyway. > Want your business to appear on Google Maps, Google Local, et al., so that you can tell your prospective customers where you are, what you sell, and when you are open? Yup, you guessed it--you need a Google Plus Local Business page now. The title "Plus-One This" is just another reminder of why G+ is such a failure: it's embarrassing to even talk about it. The name is clunky and awkward, as is trying to tell someone you +1'd something. Do you see what I just had to type? What the hell is that? And how do you say that out loud to someone? "Yeah, I plussed that article he posted". Wow, gross... It's also got that whole "made for geeks" stygma because it's most frequently seen in use as blogging platform for techies. So not only are you labeling yourself a geek by talking about it, you're also forced to use awkward phrases like "I plussed that", or "Why didn't you plus my post?". No thanks.
- batgaijin 14y agoYeah forums and aggregators for geeks never get a diverse base.
- jrockway 14y ago"Hey, go `like' my status update," is less awkward? Let's be honest: all new platforms and technologies are first used by geeks. Everything will sound geeky for a certain amount of time. Go back to 1980 and ask someone to "Google" you. Let me know how that goes for you. Also, I believe the past tense of +1 is +1'd, not "plussed".
- Irregardless 14y ago> all new platforms and technologies are first used by geeks Including social networks? I highly doubt that. > Also, I believe the past tense of +1 is +1'd Which just proves my point, because "I plus oned that" is even more difficult to say and type. The word 'one' has no fluid way of being written or spoken as a verb. Plus one'd? +1-ed? Plus 1'd? And yes, telling someone to 'like' something is far less awkard. Like is already a verb.
- sidcool 14y agoNot impressed. Not convincing enough.
- sorrybutno 14y agoYour buddy: “Oh, you need to have a Google Plus Profile or it doesn’t work.” Me: Don't be a jackass. You know I don't use any google services apart from search and youtube. When those require a login I'll either stop using them or start registering a ton of throwaway ids as I've done for years now when someone sends me a paywall link.
- richkidsoftwtr 14y agoHere's my problem, the three items that will "attract" users are not actually "attractive". They are actually just ways that Google forces users to have a G+ login to interact with one of their services. They may lead to more people using G+ but ONLY as a login service - nothing more.
- thinkling 14y agotl;dr: G+ is misunderstood as a failed social network, it's actually the key to search customization. Google will keep requiring a G+ profile for more and more of its services until they capture you, too. There are lots of statements in the article I find easy to argue with (or find too weird to bother arguing with). But I suspect the bottom line, that Google will eventually convince most people to create a G+ profile, will prove to be accurate.
- jere 14y ago>From its launch through today, everyone viewed Google Plus as "Google’s version of Facebook,"... Sure, there’s a social networking aspect to it, but Google Plus is really Google’s version of Google. This is called moving the goalposts. If you're redefining Google+ as Google, there's no prediction here. Google already has a staggering number of users. >So then why didn’t Google shut down Google Plus if it was purportedly such a colossal flop? Why is the team working on it the size of the contracting team building the Death Star? And why is Google integrating its other products with Google Plus at a freakish, breakneck pace? Sorry to keep saying the same thing, but my post from yesterday describes I how feel about this attitude: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5022549 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5022549 I have a couple dozen friends on Google+. There literally hasn't been a single post from one of them in over 4 months. Sometimes companies just fail.
- KirinDave 14y ago> This is called moving the goalposts. No. "Moving the Goalposts" is a dishonest technique for arguments by which criterion for sufficiency are continually redefined. Google has never said, "G+ is Google's Facebook" or anything of the sort. Quite the contrary, they've been clear it's something different from the outset. It's the endless parade of journalists eager to write linkbait stories that have made such comparisons, struggling to put together coherent thoughts on subjects they don't fully understand. > If you're redefining Google+ as Google, there's no prediction here. Google already has a staggering number of users. Google's Plus feature is an extension of existing Google services with social aspects. It has always been Google, and G+'s information is indeed provided to a staggering number of users. But no one has redefined anything, as far as I can see. What people want to do is paint Google as failing at something because they're simultaneously a very popular and unpopular company right now. Western civilization cherishes novelty, lionizes success, and hates the successful. A perfect storm for making up bullshit about how Google is failing, or stealing your information, or spying on your house. > I have a couple dozen friends on Google+. There literally hasn't been a single post from one of them in over 4 months. Sometimes companies just fail. Perhaps you should consider socializing with people on Google Plus before complaining you haven't socialized with people on G+. And maybe for you, G+ just isn't the place to correspond with your immediate friends. That's fine, most of the people I talk to on G+ I only know professionally or remotely, and I find it to be a much richer and less noisy channel than any other option.
- hunvreus 14y agoNot sure I agree with all the points made in this article (actually I'm pretty sure a lot of it is off). That being said I think Google has a track record of using the "boiling frog" strategy: not much fuss when adding new features, going easy on the PR for new tools and just slowly, but surely, surrounding the user. I think indeed, the wide variety of very high quality verticals being progressively tied up together with G+ around its users, wherever they come from, will do quite some collateral damages. We'll see if it extends to Facebook and the likes.