2 ms·
>> "And you know this because...." > Because .. it's self evident and obviously true? What are you trying to say - that the hostile suspicion of foreigners at
by anamax 18y ago
>> "And you know this because...."
> Because .. it's self evident and obviously true? What are you trying to say - that the hostile suspicion of foreigners at the US Border is not policy?
As I suspected, you're guessing - it's sort of like fundamental attribution error.
> Huh? We're talking about the US Border, specifically about foreigners trying to visit, many who have never been there before.
How does immigration/homeland security know that someone has never been to the US before? (Hint: their passport isn't reliable information.)
And, if the US isn't trading fingerprint info with everyone it can, it isn't doing its job.
BTW - The US does collect fingerprints overseas in certain countries. However, thanks to discrimination laws, it can't just check fingerprints of folks who look like they might be from those places.
If you argued that we're practicing "security theater", not security, you wouldn't get an argument from me.
> Anyway, I hope that with the new administration in charge and the memory of 9/11 receding, this horrible system will be turned off.
Be ready to be disappointed.
- sho 18y ago"As I suspected, you're guessing - it's sort of like fundamental attribution error." I don't think so. It's merely the most likely explanation. I note you haven't advanced any competing theories. However, not like I have any hard evidence, so consider the point retracted if it bothers you. (various points about fingerprint collection) Well, everything you say is true, as far as it goes. My point is not that fingerprint collection is utterly useless and no case whatsoever can be made for its enactment. What I am trying to say is that it is an extreme tactic with high costs, not least of which that it turns people off visiting the US at all, and its benefits are nebulous and require a lot of unlikely "what-if" scenarios to pay off at all. Meanwhile, the data collected is, IMO, very dangerous. Ah, I see you've heard of the term "security theatre". Yes, that's exactly what it is, and a very damaging and costly act it is too. "Be ready to be disappointed." I am, but I don't think it's impossible that the draconian entry procedures will be dropped. They're really a product of paranoia and irrational fear; this dissipates in time. When the drumbeat of terrorism scaremongering has died down a bit, and the post-crisis economic reality has dawned on everyone, it might well occur to the leaders of the country that perhaps they can't afford to throw away tourist and business dollars on misguided security theatre any more. It might take a while, but economic pragmatism wins out every time.