4 ms·
Woah woah. Hang on. I used to work in this area so I want to comment. First, the mobile market has of late always been a mess. The whole Apple-introduced smart
by contingencies 14y ago
Woah woah. Hang on. I used to work in this area so I want to comment. First, the mobile market has of late always been a mess. The whole Apple-introduced smartphone era is basically about who owns the customer: the carrier or the device manufacturer. Clear winner? Not yet.
Google's whole play on the Android thing was to ensure Apple didn't triumph too far, and they've succeeded. It was never about putting Linux on phones. Look, Nokia's died. (Though last time I mentioned this someone on HN got upset.) The other device manufacturers (including Smart TVs now) are essentially presently dependent on Google (though Samsung is trying very hard not to be), and our mobiles are all online without us buying Apple devices.
Second, the whole lockdown thing is dual-faced. First, the carriers in the US and other markets that subsidise phones (advertising: $0!) with long term lock-in contracts don't want people hacking the phone. Therefore there's a requirement for them to make it a bit hard to open up. On the other hand, often a content licensing requirements from content partners force them to include this stuff, typically Hollywood studios. (I have it on good information that Microsoft paid a hundred million dollars up front to Samsung to convince them to introduce their new DRM solution in the Galaxy series. So the DRM thing is basically a moot point, if you are paid that much!) And finally, the devices do need some secure storage for cryptographic purposes, for example storing passwords.
Net result: the consumer is shafted. Thanks, industry. I hope FirefoxOS can get some traction.
Here's what I believe 'should' happen:
- Carriers realize their value-add is the consumer relationship, actually provide decent billing interfaces to all and sundry, replace PayPal and the credit card companies. (Problem: They can't. Their internal billing systems are generally a mess, custom hacks layered on to black boxes they outsourced to AMDOCS)
- Device manufacturers should embrace openness, encouraging people to load whatever they want with an OPTIONAL vector for validating cryptographic trust of a codebase. The manufacturers should actually invest in facilitating this. In most of the world, people are super keen to muck with phones, there is a community that will fix bugs and improve things, and those who sell the devices have time to customize.
- AOSP people should join FirefoxOS and work for a more open world instead of working on Google's pretend-open platform (step 1: upload everything to google, step 2: see step 1) for free. Work on there a year or so, then pimp yourself out to a device manufacturer. Guaranteed cash, feel good about your work, help break the unhealthy Googopoly.
- levesque 14y agoCarriers seem to be the problem here. That CM dev is moving to Sony, but I'm having the same crap over there. My Xperia U is still running Gingerbread even though Sony released ICS for that device 4 months ago (and the bootloader is locked by my carrier). Why carriers get to choose what OS runs on my phone is beyond me. My ISP doesn't get to decide which OS I run on my computers, I don't see why this would apply for cell phone carriers.
- w1ntermute 14y agoCarriers are totally the problem. Yesterday, Vizio announced two phones running stock Android (Jelly Bean) at CES. They look gorgeous, and The Verge staff, which has had hands-on time with them, says they're amazing. They would use these phones as their daily drivers. But these phones aren't being released in America - they're being released in China. Why? Because the American carriers won't play ball (because the phones run stock Android), so they're forced to take their product overseas. In China, you can just buy a phone, put a SIM card in it, and you're off to the races. Think about that for a second. A rare American hardware upstart success story is forced to sell its first phones in China because American carriers won't accept them.
- contingencies 14y agoI agree except that when you say "in China", what you actually mean is "in most of the world". You see, when we have less hegemonic mobile network operators (due basically to their inability to hunt down and nail people who reneg on long term phone contracts), we have a more heterogeneous system. In the end, everyone benefits. What we need is less authority, more internet. Hopefully GSM will die soon and we can all use some kind of public, tor-rerouted, bandwidth-metered cryptophones over wifi. I'm sure the NSA will love that.
- Camillo 14y agoSurely you mean "CDMA will die soon". That's the American technology behind the American idea of "this phone belongs to this carrier". The carrier decoupling that you see in Europe and elsewhere was enabled by GSM-family technologies (GSM, UMTS, LTE) and their use of SIM cards.