3 ms·
The big challenge with 'scholarly search' is that what users want is to get to fulltext, but most scholarly fulltext is behind paywalls. Google Scholar and MSN
by jrochkind1 14y ago
The big challenge with 'scholarly search' is that what users want is to get to fulltext, but most scholarly fulltext is behind paywalls.
Google Scholar and MSN Academic both have ways of trying to deal with this. Interestingly, both often get you to a copy from the extensive number of "a professor illegally posted a PDF on the public web even though the publisher holds copyright and wouldn't allow that" copies. Google Scholar also will try to let you register your academic affiliation as a 'preference' and use the academic institution's infrastructure to get you to a post-authenticated licensed copy.
scholar.ly... doesn't seem to do this all that well.
I'm surprised that dude_abides thinks MSN Academic is 'light years better than Google Scholar', hasn't been my experience.
(I happen to work in the field we're talking about, being a software developer for a university library)
- mhluongo 14y agoWe're only open-access right now, so there's no need to supply university credentials. Just click on a result to expand it and get the full-text, or go to the paper result page and click "full-text".